Quote:
Originally Posted by SmartBomb
Dislike Dorian and he is my Day 1 case in the same way I described Day 1 cases earlier, due to his general passiveness and wont to question Slendy (which is my own personal scumread). Also he's right and I dislike people who are right and then do nothing else. dorian
You're saying that me questioning why Slendy voted for me is why you're scumreading me? I mean, he obviously voted me for a reason, and I can do nothing to address that reason if he doesn't tell me what it is. People apparently disagree on whether or not it's a good idea for him to keep the reason to himself.
As for being right and doing nothing else...well, sorry you dislike it, but it's definitely my playstyle in the early game. I'm very much not used to giving out thoughts on other players so early, but if you want my thoughts, here they are.
Banks - posting like his usual self according to most people. It's a fairly aggressive-but-polite town approach, he was town the last game he did this, I have no reason to think otherwise yet.
slendy - all game 5 (once he was active), pushed hard on people I considered easy targets. All game, I thought it was super-scummy because it's a tactic I see mafia use a lot, despite everyone eventually thinking he was the towniest town left. I dislike the tactic, but given he likes using it as town, that's a point in his favor that he's playing the same way again.
Smartbomb -
Quote:
Originally Posted by Riki
i think he sounds different from what i remember of game 5, but i'd probably attribute that more to this being early in the game while he only started playing game 5 in like late day 3
Riki beat me to it. He joined game 5 after there was plenty to discuss, and that's a very different situation. I can see how some people are noticing the difference, but I think that difference is because of the different situations. I was starting to lean innocent on him, but him dropping a second vote on me is making me reconsider my initial impression, though.
fontisian - It would be easy for me to townread her for being (I think) the only one so far to townread me. I'll have to see how the votes play out today before I try to make a slightly more informed and less gut-based decision here.
cue - not a huge fan of the posting style so far, but so many people on here equate a dislike of posting/play style with scummy, and that's BS. Especially when playing with people who you aren't familiar with.