Quote:
Originally Posted by peso2paydirt
Do you guys chat much in Skype when playing together?
Considering these factors:
1) We both play hypers as our primary game multi-tabling
2) We are both members of the same skype omaha 8 chat group
3) We both have often have Skype open while playing our sessions (and while not playing for that matter)
That would you not think that
4) We have chatted at some point while playing is pretty bloody likely?
Except this is where your argument falls flat. This is because you have made a number of assumptions about the content of any communication.
You assume that a) we are talking about poker b) we are talking about the same table c) that we are talking about colluding.
To illustrate this point further.
Phil Galfond, Ben Sulsky and Hac Dang are all good friends clearly. They run RunItOnce.com. They are all proven as exceptional poker players in their own right.
They will have each others email addresses, phone numbers and skype handles. They probably have all these at hand when playing a session against themselves and others.
By having all forms of communication with each other available, they be a) using them b) using them to collude.
Quote:
Originally Posted by peso2paydirt
I know so many of you communicate,
Well we born with brains and a mouth so it's going to happen at some point. I mean Stars gave everyone a chat box and the nonsense I get called can only be proof that people like to communicate.
But heh communication can take many different forms, insults, compliments, conversations about woman, god, politics, racism etc. If I spoke to you about living in Mexico in the chat box would that be collusion because by your deductive assumptions it must be?
Quote:
Originally Posted by peso2paydirt
I can't help wondering the extent to which this affects soft play collusion, but a big enough sample size will provide illumination.
Feel free to do that. My Stars handle is luckyfool149. I would say I am a relatively modest winner who has only started to take poker a little more seriously in the last year.
Unfortunately, no proof has actually been forthcoming on Malloy despite repeated requests to yourself and playahata.
The human brain likes to simplify the world and seeks explanations to further their understanding. That's where evidence comes in. And this lack of evidence is at fault for people's reaction to you ITT.
You cannot keep bandying around accusations with no proof. It's just not acceptable or reasonable in this community.
Quote:
Originally Posted by peso2paydirt
By receiving the benefits of reciprocation in future games from the player they are assisting. Happens mostly around bubble play, building up short stack partners and pressuring the outside player when on the bubble with your big stack and FE. Typically a two on one scenario on the bubble regardless of how the profits are divided. By collaborating they are boosting each other's EV at the expense of the non collaborative players.
I have never really considered how you would do it until your insightful post above. It makes a lot of logical sense.
Does your discussion on the subject mean you are more knowledgeable about it and that you must be cheating?
No. Not at all. It just means I could easily leap from a) to e) on the causal chain and accuse you of cheating because of your intimate knowledge of the subject.
Quote:
Originally Posted by peso2paydirt
You would seldom have to type in chat. A good player can recognize a spot to assist his friend and do it without any discussion. Ask Duncan Malloy about this, he is an expert at multi tabling and collaborating.
Unfortunately, we cannot ask Malloy because he has disappeared. Therefore, we are asking you and hata, because you have made these specific allegations to tell us. We are appealing to your higher knowledge, because there are very bright people on here who have played far more games than you against him who didn't notice
Here are some statistics we do have available though.
No-one has played more than 5% of Malloy's total games with him. Every one of them except 2 I have played against in recent weeks and all as far as I can see have active accounts.
P.S A handful of the people on this list are in the skype group (MASSIVE COLLUSION ALERT).
Quote:
Originally Posted by AllInNTheDark
exactly... put up or shut up... no use in making "soft" allegations... show me, don't tell me
This and this. +1.
Quote:
Originally Posted by peso2paydirt
Why would anyone be stupid enough to share their stats and evidence to people on a forum, several of whom are also currently being investigated. Good try.
Quote:
Originally Posted by peso2paydirt
How is it beneficial to me to reveal my stats? If you want evidence, go compile your own hh's and data. There are several players being currently investigated here. Why the hell would I reveal what I have where the cheaters can read it, lol, some of you guys are clowns.
Dude. I genuinely can't believe that you wrote this. You have made allegations (see above and almost all responses on this page) to the effect of "where is the evidence?"
We must all be smacked off our tits on coke to want actual evidence. We are crazy to be in the majority on this one. Crazy.