Quote:
Originally Posted by Achromatic
Slendy I am very annoyed that you aren't holding Dorian's interactions (or LACK THERE OF) with Ratchet to nearly the same standard as you are Banks. For some god forsaken reason you are holding Banks to a GROSSLY higher standard of sliding scale.
1) I still don't believe the alleged Cop!Ratchet -read was anything other than a retrospective excuse, and it seems blatant to me. Not outed-scum-blatant, like road's D2-posting, but pretty darn close.
2) I don't have a hard time seeing Mafia!Ratchet and Town!dorian interact like this
nor do I have a hard time seeing Mafia!Ratchet interact with Mafia!dorian like this.
The reason I'm after Banks isn't his interactions with Ratchet -- the point I want to make is simply that
they don't make Banks look any greener, and by that opinion I stand.
You could say that I don't hold the two interactions to the same standard, and you'd be right in a way -- I haven't yet seen the detail that would EXCLUDE one of the possible worlds wrt Ratchet and dorian. Since dorian and Banks are different players (like day and night, you could even say), so too would Mafia!Ratchet be obliged to treat both of them differently if he were to roll Scum with them.
3) We both want to make this as close to a sweep as possible. We both want to Lynch the final Mafioso
today, not tomorrow. I won't ignore your case as I reassess everything.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Achromatic
ALSO, I am getting pretty sick of the narrative "we have to solve for the Bs" as if them beginning with a B makes them linked or more likely to be scum. It is absurd.
As it just so happens, road was infinitesimally more scummy than anyone yesterday, and Mafia!road also makes Riki, the other R, pretty damn likely green. Hence, resolving the Rs yesterday.
As it so happens, after road's not-too-surprising Mafia!flip, the next candidates for his partner (based on their actions and some details that make dorian seem like a less plausible alternative) both begin with a B. With dorian being the third, but atleast for the moment least likely possibility IMO.
Surely you cannot seriously assume it has anything to do with the starting letter.