if atak flips wolf, i think i'd ignore anything he posted today (nich reads and i forget what else). if he's wolf, he knows he's dying soon and it's just a leveling game of who he "clears" and why

ok...but you've basically done nothing since then. if you're so great at endgames, why aren't you providing content now and working w/ 3 cleared villagers when it matters most?

the fact that you're lurking enough to respond to that but not really provide anything else is pretty bad

let's here some of those informed reads.

Did we ever figure out how many people entered the day 1 roleplay contest? If it's more than 5 there was a second prize that no one claimed, so there's a wolf with good roleplay posts.

busy working on other things irl

I don't feel at risk of being killed today

I shared who I think are wolves and there seems to be a pretty consensus agreement, especially around river/crossnerd

So I'm fine focusing on those two at the moment, and evaluate my unknowns at a later time.

I have 3 contestants so more:
- me with Gimli garbage
- jdalla with excellent Fobby posts
- aaronk with pretty good Jabba posts

Two more contestants and aaronk gets massive wolf points.

*so far

i played/submitted and didn't win anything

it was also pretty clear crossnerd did (indiana jones character maybe?)

Also wolves opted to roleblock JDalla over aaronk even though it was not that obvious that jdalla would win (imo). It increases the chances that aaronk is a wolf.

see above re: crossnerd

I didn’t enter

eh, votecounter didn't pick up my vote

riverfish

aaronk's RP posts were way better than crossnerd's imo.

Day 4: Automated Votals from #2973 to #2989

riverfish1 (5): KruZe (28), wdcbooks (14), aaronk56 (20), YouKnowWho (10), dmk (70)
KruZe (1): Crossnerd (1)
gusmahler (1): sixfour (15)
Felix the Cat (1): gusmahler (12)
Not voting (7): atakdog (5), Felix the Cat (21), jonnyd (72), Kukraprout (55), Nicholasp27 (16), riverfish1 (12), UNVOTE (0)

Phase ends in 2h38m. Hammer at 8.

Vote history:

<Beta v0.1.8>

afk for the rest of the day, will be checking thread every so often on phone though

glgl

It's late and I'm sleepy, so here are my final thoughts. I didnt reread everyone thoroughly.


Village
books
dmk
Kukraprout

Probably villagers
Nich
Jonnyd
YKW

No clue
Kruze
Sixfour

Probably some wolves here
Felix
Gus
Aaronk

Kill list
Riverfish
Atakdog
Crossnerd


Reasoning for people I didnt mention today:

jonnyd
He has too many posts to reread and he has been villagery enough for me today. Lazily giving him villager status, even if his suggestions regarding the coordi claim yesterday do look back in retrospect.

Nich
Slight villa lean. Posts mainly about mechanics but that's expected and he seems earnestly engaged in it.

Aaronk
A lot of posts, very low content. Also day 1 RP contest theory makes him a likely wolf.

Gus
Posts A LOT about mechanics. Not many strong reads. Doesnt interact much. Commentary mode.

YKW
General villageriness, I guess?

Wolves will almost certainly kill in books/dmk/me today. It might be useful to compare our reads and try to figure out the motivation behind their NKs.

If river is not the wolf vig, roleblocker should just target whoever he thinks is most likely to be a wolf. No point in trying to guess who plays like a vig or not imo. Except for Crossned: she did look like she tried to throw herself in front of the river wagon today, and is probably not a good block.

I thought of that, but I think we would all go Crossnerd or Atak tomorrow so I wouldn’t drive yourself too crazy trying to figure it out.

Good night all, see you on the other side!

riverfish1

(2 votes from hammer now)

leaving now, doesn't seem like changing my vote will matter at all so meh, river is a fine lynch

Day 4: Automated Votals from #2990 to #2997

riverfish1 (6): KruZe (1), wdcbooks (1), aaronk56 (0), YouKnowWho (0), dmk (0), Kukraprout (4)
KruZe (1): Crossnerd (0)
gusmahler (1): sixfour (1)
Felix the Cat (1): gusmahler (0)
Not voting (6): atakdog (0), Felix the Cat (0), jonnyd (0), Nicholasp27 (0), riverfish1 (0), UNVOTE (0)

Phase ends in 1h35m. Hammer at 8.

Vote history:

<Beta v0.1.8>

Hi friends, I'm subbing in for riverfish

I am a villager.

I haven't really read any of the thread beyond skimming a few posts over the last few days when bored.

Would love to not be voted out here but guessing that's not super likely given the votecount :P So I'll see if I can at least make some good reads or something

*****MOD NOTE*****

captain binkles will be subbing in for riverfish1.

For today, please cast any votes as "riverfish" not "captain binkles"


*****MOD NOTE*****