Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Does Whining About Political Correctness in a Racism Debate Correlate to Being a Racist? Does Whining About Political Correctness in a Racism Debate Correlate to Being a Racist?

09-30-2014 , 12:04 PM
I always thought Casual-T would be the GOAT rap name; haven't found anyone who agrees with me yet.
09-30-2014 , 12:09 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by FoldnDark
A capitalist will balk at your use of the term "exploit," arguing we aren't exploiting classes...
The word 'exploit' here is admittedly used in a technical sense. That is as extracting material advantage simply by exercising class advantage... basically by profiting from a middle-man position. This is the true essence of capitalism.

The typical propagandist dodge is to say "how is the NBA owner 'exploiting' basketball players, he pays them millions?" This is a completely different usage of the word. A better example of this technical meaning is as used in black-hat hacking. A middle class (or poor) hacker running an "exploit" that steals a trivial amount of money from an NBA owner (or player, or fellow middle class or poor NBA fan) is 'exploiting' their victim.

Quote:
... that the system flourishes by taking advantage of what provides the most utility...
This is straight out propaganda. The trick here is that this 'utility' is measured in profit extracted. It's begging the question.

Typically we hear that capitalism is more 'efficient'. But when this so-called 'efficiency' is examined, once again the metric is extracting the most profit. So this statement devolves to "capitalism is more efficient at extracting profits for capitalists." If we use the term 'efficient' in the same way an engineer or physicist uses the term, capitalism is catastrophically inefficient. Example: global outsourcing.

Quote:
... ie, everyone including minorities are doing much better today than a hundred years ago due to a higher standard of living produced by capitalism...
People are better off because of the onward march of human knowledge, especially technology. People are better off, even despite capitalism. People are better off under non-capitalist regimes too. Capitalism, just like any other -ism, produces nothing. It's physically impossible for an ideology to produce anything... only hard work and mother nature can be productive.

Quote:
... Anyway, your arguments have plenty of merit, and are effective in arguing for a more socialized system...
I'm not trying to argue for a more socialized system ITT. In fact since Communism as practiced is also predicated directly on (a) profit motive, and (b) property rights... it suffers from the same exact defects.

I'm trying to explain that class hierarchy is an underlying cause of the creation, and of the continual and necessary maintenance, of racism.

Quote:
... It's hard for me to imagine a legitimate reason you wouldn't lead with similar qualifications.
Interesting thought. I'm at a loss however imagining what a similar qualification might be.
09-30-2014 , 12:23 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by tomdemaine
it's an insult to real tea.
Yeah, but proper tea is theft.
09-30-2014 , 12:24 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Shame Trolly !!!1!
Interesting thought. I'm at a loss however imagining what a similar qualification might be.
How about (to a typical Murican capitalist), "You're racist...but, what I mean by that probably isn't what you think, and here's why: _________________."

Then you can have a go at convincing them they should feel bad being a part of a class, that capitalism propagates the class system and isn't efficient at generating wealth, etc, etc. If your goal is to help eliminate racism and not simply add to the political polarization of this country, I think clear communication is essential.
09-30-2014 , 12:27 PM
Ice Cube's "Gangsta Rap Made Me Do It" This video has more on point social commentary than 99.99% of popular music that was produced in the USA during the 2000's.



I can't find the quote, but I remember reading that some of the first "gangsta rappers" wanted to call their art "reality rap", but the label didn't think that would market as well.
09-30-2014 , 12:44 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by FoldnDark
How about, "You're racist...but, what I mean by that probably isn't what you think, and here's why: _________________."...
OK, very good.

Although I might mess up sometimes, I try to always start out with the 'that's racist' line first. For example my first post regarding BruceZ on 8-26...

Quote:
Originally Posted by Shame Trolly !!!1!
How that racist derp he posted doesn't earn BruceZ a little 'time out' here at 2+2 is beyond me.
I try not to label a poster as a 'racist' unless they're out-of-the-closet, like Silver_Man2, or after having the racist content of their posting explained to them clearly and repetitively, they keep doubling-down.

Since it's really easy to inadvertently use a dog-whistle out of ignorance (I never heard of the watermelon/fried chicken shiz until I was ~17yo), or not have thought through the racial implications of something (like voter ID), I think it's kinda misleading to lump such accidental racism in with intentional racism.

However, my goal posting on line isn't to combat racism. That's something I do in real life through my activism. In fact, IRL I don't call anyone a racist to their face... I just try not to personally deal with them.
09-30-2014 , 12:49 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by tomdemaine
it's an insult to real tea.
Word.
09-30-2014 , 02:18 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by metaname2
I always thought Casual-T would be the GOAT rap name; haven't found anyone who agrees with me yet.
Sounds like a great rap name for a white guy who thinks he is more clever than he actually is.
09-30-2014 , 02:35 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by AsianNit
Sounds like a great rap name for a white guy who thinks he is more clever than he actually is.

Casual T?

Last edited by FoldnDark; 09-30-2014 at 02:40 PM.
09-30-2014 , 04:42 PM
Money2Burn, no reply?

Quote:
Originally Posted by spottydango
Money2burn,

Two questions.

I am curious if you think that the purchasing of sweatshop manufactured clothing from poor South American countries, or random products from amazon/target/walmart that are created in sweatshop conditions in Asian countries is supporting modern day monetary slavery so that you can enjoy your current standard of living?

If so, is this more less morally reprehensible than being more inclined to be more nervous around minority youth that are exhibiting characteristics that are associated with violent behavior than minority youth that are not exhibiting such characteristics? Bonus, does having such views ever become acceptable, or is it always repugnant racism?

Stupid double bonus aside, but curious: What if they are some dumb old white person that is generally and equally terrified of all youth. Just a dumb prejudice ageist, or secretly still racist?

Mostly just curious about the first two ?'s ty
09-30-2014 , 05:03 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by spottydango
Money2Burn, no reply?

"I am curious if you think that the purchasing of sweatshop manufactured clothing from poor South American countries, or random products from amazon/target/walmart that are created in sweatshop conditions in Asian countries is supporting modern day monetary slavery so that you can enjoy your current standard of living?
"
I'll have a bit of a go. I think its the hardest question of this type I have to grapple with..

The redistribution of wealth to poorer countries via trade has been one of the greatest things that has happened in my lifetime and long may it continue. The sickening exploitation that can be involved with this is disgusting. When I can tell which products to avoid then I try to do so but information is sparse and the upside massively too big to just boycott everything.

More information and law is the best answer but its such a tricky area that it's where I'd like to see companies have publicly stated policies that they're legally accountable for.

I understand that I'm very privileged in that it makes only a small difference to my standard of living either way.
09-30-2014 , 06:30 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by wil318466
Oh please shut the **** up. You sound like a ****ing moron.

Rap has never been about making money or being paid. Anyone who knows anything the **** about rap knows that. JFC you people are ****ing idiots. This is very basic principle of ****ing rap music for Christ's sake.


This was the third best selling rap album of the last 15 years, behind two Eminem albums. It is the second most sold album by a black artist behind Usher's "Confessions" in that same period. It is literally called "Get Rich or Die Tryin'." Stop pretending you have any idea about rap music or hip hop culture.

Last edited by aoFrantic; 09-30-2014 at 06:35 PM.
09-30-2014 , 06:33 PM
Punk is the genre that has closer to zero ****s about getting paid.
09-30-2014 , 06:39 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by spanktehbadwookie
Punk is the genre that has closer to zero ****s about getting paid.
I'd go with the anarchists for that. Compare:



with



both punk but one sub-genre was so much more about the $$$s
09-30-2014 , 06:44 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by chezlaw
I'd go with the anarchists for that. Compare:



with



both punk but one sub-genre was so much more about the $$$s
Fantastic comparison.
Crass, rudimentary peni, et al. pretty much acted allergic to money. Those were the types of punk artists I was thinking about when I made that post.
09-30-2014 , 07:54 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by metaname2
I always thought Casual-T would be the GOAT rap name; haven't found anyone who agrees with me yet.
In light of recent developments down in Texas, I'm thinking "E-balla" trumps. He's sick with it.
09-30-2014 , 08:12 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mat Sklansky
thoughts on ice-t?
Quote:
Originally Posted by ElliotR
Total sellout. The guy has done commercials for tupperware ffs. TUPPERWARE!!!
True, plus there was that reality show. But he's another example of a driven and creative hip-hop entrepreneur, one who parlayed his marginal skills as an early "gangsta rapper" into a pretty successful career in mainstream show business. I'm far from a hip-hop scholar, but I always thought he was a cut above many of the other early rappers in terms of political and social commentary.

From 1991 (lyrics NSFW):
09-30-2014 , 08:49 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by TheDuker
True, plus there was that reality show. But he's another example of a driven and creative hip-hop entrepreneur, one who parlayed his marginal skills as an early "gangsta rapper" into a pretty successful career in mainstream show business. I'm far from a hip-hop scholar, but I always thought he was a cut above many of the other early rappers in terms of political and social commentary.

From 1991 (lyrics NSFW):
Solid read. I was a huge Ice T fan back when that video came out. Love his metal band Body Count. The irony of him playing a sex cop on tv, while embracing pimping is kind of odd. Though,as I recall, he does not advocate abusiveness towards women and sees pimping like management. Definitely a talented cat.
09-30-2014 , 08:51 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mat Sklansky
Why is nobody calling for the ruination of fly? He is obviously filled with hate and should be punished.
I don't understand this post. People have been calling for his ruination for half a decade or more. Practically every ATF Politics thread in that time has been directly or indirectly related to him. Every thread in ATF about Wookie's unfair moderation is specifically talking about how he regularly infracts and bans non-liberal types for things that are not as bad as what Fly does every single day.

In fact, it was the fact that spank cracked down a bit after Fly said

Quote:
Originally Posted by FlyWf
If you are aware you are autistic, you should be aware that when people yell at you for being aspy, that's your cue to shut the **** up, and not continue to asp it up about how you just don't understand.
that got Fly's fanboys' to get their jimmies rustled and harass spank until he was demodded.
09-30-2014 , 08:55 PM
Don't forget about the time Ice-t dressed up like a kangaroo for one of the WOAT comic book to movie adaptations.

09-30-2014 , 09:01 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by 13ball
I know who fly really is if anyone wants to ship me $5K.
It's not really a secret whose gimmick Fly is.

Unless you meant like the actual person.
09-30-2014 , 09:10 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by The REAL Trolly
On one hand, I disapprove of fly's tossing out the word "******ed" bc that's not how grownups talk in 2014, on the other hand, it's an outstanding tool for demonstrating exactly how full of bull**** the village idiots and their apologists are. Like, really dude, after #TeamBruce overlooked Hispanics being called cockroaches, Neoconfederate agitprop, and Holocaust denial, who in **** do you imagine is going to believe that you're super offended when fly calls someone a ******? C'mon man, we buy those poker books, we know how to establish ranges.
I'm actually terrible at putting people on ranges, but I balance that out by making it impossible for others to put me on a range.
09-30-2014 , 09:13 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mat Sklansky
making a direct comparison between bruce and fly, fly took the vicious, personal attack in stride and the other person went crazy. the other person could learn something from that.
It's not a personal attack when the person is a troll and mostly faking...

It's also not fair to compare a person who is not used to being attacked being attacked with an especially vile accusation to one who is attacked with obviously true accusations regularly.

But most important of all, what really got to Bruce was the dog piling. I think he would have been just fine if it had been only one person doing it.

Not to mention that the idea of emulating a sociopath because they react better to highly emotional situations is pretty silly.

So really, you are simply making a category error here.

Last edited by AlexM; 09-30-2014 at 09:23 PM.
09-30-2014 , 09:20 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by wil318466
When he calls someone a racist, that person has usually said at least some borderline racist ****.
Yeah, no.

Quote:
Originally Posted by FlyWf
P.S. Based on literally just this thread of posts, in which you haven't posted anything racist, I am 100% confident in labeling you a HUGE racist.
09-30-2014 , 09:21 PM
I thought I handled the autism thing pretty well considering my child was getting tested for autism around the time that was posted. I remember kurto stopped me from banning Silverman2 when he made an autism slur in that same time period because he hadn't been specifically warned about that kind of behavior.

      
m