i am very willing to believe jdalla is a villager who has no idea that shooting me doesn't make me a wolf. that level of density is role neutral

jdalla has zero votes, dmk, so it's pretty ****ing ambitious to come back to the thread and accuse me of thunderdoming him

maybe read the thread first, then get back to not bothering to read me

I buy this. Roleblock seems unlikely (though possible). But saving teh kill for a night makes some sense -- more as villager, though, and that;'s inconsistent with his lying.


But it's all totally consistent with him being a wolf, winning, and doing... [insert anything]. So lynching shortline on teh basis of it makes lots of sense, IF you know jdalla is village. I had him as wolf so I'm not convinced, but if he's been supervillagery, then maybe.


Still like my vote.

Sun Tzu is on fire. He is also nearly as lock a villager as Tokyo.

honest question for you all:

what the hell are you going to do with jdalla if i'm lynched and i come up villager?

if the answer is - you're not going to do anything with him - maybe you should rethink whether only a villager would make his play here, and whether it has any bearing on my actual role

really don't see how we don't go shortline today but any of the top four as of the last vote count would be alright, out

LOL I mean trying to imply I might not have even won the game is next level wtf


Shouldn't bother responding to you, obviously you are willfully ignoring that I found you the wolfiest player before you survived my shot, and you continue to howl it up after my claim with stuff like this

^^ this

If somehow shortline is villager I'm okay making that mistake, would be one of the worst villager performances of all time from a good player. Killing Luckbox over him seems crazy, since even if they are w/w, Luckbox basically wants to die in his place here.

Stop ****ing voting yourself and acting like an ass and you will make sense.

okay .. i will freely admit that i often find people wolfy based on personality [clashes] and not game mechanics and that i am not the best judge of who's who BUT .. the person I am keying in on the most as a wolf right now is aaronk56

another one jumping on shortline with a “meh” reason .. also i thought his vote change at the last minute last night was super wolfy but i already thought he was a wolf so maybe confirmation bias

seriously everything this guy posts screams wolf to me

and another ..

seriously he’s adding nothing to the thread

and again .. voting with no explanation

luckbox jumps on immediately .. w/w maybe? or maybe aaron is just playing up the fact that everyone thinks luckbox is a wolf?

also why is no one else talking about this guy?

super sketch .. does anyone have any info that would corroborate how busy this guy is?

as for non wolfs .. there are things i don't like about tokyo felix and YKW but the more i read i guesssss the more i think they're probably harmless .. YKW i think i have the same issue as jonnyd where i disagree with nearly every conclusion he makes but the effort and general tone of the guy seems alright?

as for shortline i really don't like how the wagon got rolling and how desperate some people seem to be to vote for him but i don't know you guys that well so maybe it really is obvious?

"Jumping on" is something I do. It has no bearing on Aaron's role.
And Aaron is posting pretty good I think. I'd be surprised if he's a wolf but he has the sort of game that is probably tricky. He'd make for a good peek.

well, if this sums up the attitude of the thread, then i'm truly out

you shot someone and they didn't die. you didn't consider that it is entirely role neutral for them, so you led a bandwagon lunch on them while basically telling everyone to ignore everything they posted. then you got salty because that person got annoyed with you and the whole thread for treating their lunch as a foregone conclusion with zero actual logic. now you're trying to make yourself feel better (or provide cover for yourself) by claiming i'm the one who played bad.

i didn't get a chance to give a single read or play normally bc you made today about me. you are responsible for the bad play of the village. i have sat here and endured it.

good luck, actual villagers. if Jdalla speaks with your voice, you're boned.

literally what i just posted are all his posts from the past idk 5 hours or so? .. how is that posting anything let alone posting good?

Sorry, I’m here for only a minute. Some IRL stuff came up unexpectedly today but I should have a ton of time tomorrow.

If I’m the seer, nichp is a villager.

I’ve skimmed the thread. Luckbox acting as a chaos agent itt is just him being himself imo. Not wolfy. Some of my top villagers are voting Gus. For the sake of today I’m just going to sponge them.

Gus

that sixfour vote on me is truly awful. i felt ok about him before because he was voting with me on crackedquads. but that post is really awful.

Also, just let Jdalla/short line resolve itself at night imo. Isn’t that an old Chips Ahoy rule?

Anyway, sorry, I have to peace out.

The low-content/no explanation stuff I'm pretty sure is going to be standard for him as a wolf or villager. The content that he has posted seems fine, and his volume is a lot lot more than he posted when I wolfed with him recently.

is Gus really not voting still or is that just a glitch

can anyone not under suspicion corroborate this? lol

Wait, I thought kruze was also voting Gus.

Well. Whatever ((shrug))

ahem?