The only way to determine of Shortline is a wolf on D1 is to determine if he is trying to get obvious villagery people lynched. You might have thought you were villagery but I don't think you were. Only crackedquads was villagery and that's not enough. He needs to be pushing for at least 3 obvious villagers on D1 to be a wolf.

How confident are you that I'm a wolf now?

all that's required for traz to be the de facto nk is for there to be someone on the wolf team that has ever played with him

there's still time for you to be a villager but it's up to you, not me

I don't even care about the initial use of "obvious." It was his shifting story once others called him out for it, going from one explanation to another over time.

Plus forgetting you didn't call wolves "obvious" only "possible" to me seems like a manufactured answer to justify a list you made intentionally. Whereas a villager who says "possible wolves" and is uncertain about it would react with "wait, I didn't say they were obvious wolves"

I'm gonna need a percentage.
Tell me what you want me to be doing right now. Want me to go read someone? Who?

****** MOD NOTE******


Atakdog is allowed to post again.


****** MOD NOTE******

just give me your top 3 wolves

Day 2: Automated Votals from #1757 to #1808

Luckbox Inc (5): Sun Tzu (25), jonnyd (23), Luckbox Inc (79), aaronk56 (17), Kukraprout (53)
shortline99 (4): JDalla (24), dmk (39), Tokyo!! (42), wdcbooks (17)
gusmahler (3): shortline99 (60), Nicholasp27 (4), sixfour (3)
dmk (1): coordi (7)
KruZe (1): YouKnowWho (17)
coordi (1): Felix the Cat (20)
Not voting (9): atakdog (0), biggerboat (0), crackedquads (0), Crossnerd (0), gusmahler (14), KruZe (1), mrs. jonnyd (2), riverfish1 (0), UNVOTE (0)

Phase ends in 2h50m. Hammer at 12.

Vote history:

<Beta v0.1.8>

I'm not giving a percentage. I think in terms of superpositions more than probabilities

What does SPK mean?

Does the fact that there were no N0 actions change this analysis (or did you mean N1)?

Crap...I have no idea at this point.
I can't call any active players wolves unfortunately except maybe Dmk still and I don't really believe that.
JonnyD is the best I've got for an active wolf and I don't know if I believe that either.
So it's all afk/utr types or people I'm just ignoring like YKW.
So like Crossnerd, Atakdog, and a bunch of people idk who.

I agree Birdman was widely considered cleared but I'll remind everyone that DMK tried to start a wagon on him (I think aao and dustbox were the lead wagons). I remember this because it contributed to my (obviously wrong) grand wolf conspiracy theory.

this struck me as wolfy on my readthrough. But Kukra has done other things since to be villagery, so meh?

I had the same reaction as DMK to the luckbox/Jdalla posts above. Which is weird because I find DMK wolfy. It's also weird that Coordi is the only one on DMK, who is also pretty wolfy.


going back to village points for tokyo

thank you for pointing this out. Wolves could be going whole hog FPS and claiming this kill when they actually used it to kill someone else and their vig kill just whiffed.

Despite my DMK misgivings, I still like a shortline / dustbox wagon

so you're pulling a 180 from your standard wolf games and locking onto villa and refusing to call out fellow wolf players?

I'm not actually a wolf.

okay that took way longer than i thought but i'm here and i'm going to get caught up as fast as possible and try to provide some of my thoughts on the madness that is this game

I'm a big fan of a shortline vote. Would also like an atakdog wagon

I think luckbox is a fine option and that we probably just have to resolve him soon but I also feel like another day spent wrapped up in his orbit isn’t going to be the best use of our time. Seems like he’d better be resolved by having our vig kill him or maybe the SK can do it

Jdalla the most obvious villager itt. kukra and books heading in that direction as well. Leaning villa on jonny, ykw, and felix

Why YKW?

SK is not shooting dustbox. SK is not pro village. They are hiding UTR and shooting people who aren't getting killed by wolves or village.

Serial killer can shoot me. I'm a vanillager. I won't be protected.

Initially thought he was wolfy after comparing his original wolf game with this one as they were very similar. He made an entrance post how he wouldn't be contributing much, wasn't very interested and then completely disappeared. His first post itt struck a similar cord but since he's actually been pretty active and putting forth some effort. Tone strikes me as more relaxed and interested in what's going on

What are your thoughts on him?

Why is the SK inherently anti villa? He just needs 3 consecutive kills to win right? What's it matter if luckbox is one of them

It looks like SK also becomes part of the village if the village seer peeks him, so being a little pro-village doesn't seem bad for him

This post has some villagery moments but reads sort of wolfy to me (the villagery part is the apology at the end). I'll read him really quick though.