Quote:
Originally Posted by FlyWf
I meant just that random scene and line. But really, like the entire movie is full of adults making hard choices without crying about it. The scene where they decide to go to the other ship and the one dude says, "We are not a democracy" and they leave the decision to an expert.
The scene with the captain fixing the shield. The scene where they decide who to leave behind on the other ship.
Literally nobody in this show acts with any sort of maturity.
yeah, I realized shortly after I posted that you were referring to that particular scene, but I was too lazy to edit.
and while I agree that they portrayed tough decisions in Sunshine really well, one could argue that because the crew has a singular Earth-saving mission to fulfill and have been training for various contingencies, they're more likely to act rationally/maturely as opposed to lol women civilians during an open-ended zombie survival scenario.
Don't misunderstand, I think the Walking Dead survivors are plenty ******ed and wish they would have put a bullet in Jim's head, piled bodies onto the bonfire, etc. It's just that within the worlds of each scenario, it's justifiable that the Walking Dead survivors are more prone to being ******ed than the crew of Icarus.
why Darabont chooses to make them so ******ed instead of having them act logically/rationally/maturely is what I'm unsure of. I'd guess he thinks that arguments about burying vs. burning are more dramatic and make for better television than calculated, callous decision making and efficient tactics.
Quote:
Originally Posted by private joker
Sunshine was, for the first hour, one of the best movies I've ever seen. Then in the third act it turned into Event Horizon and was unbelievably horrible. Never seen a film take such a quality nose-dive before. Really fascinating actually.
see, I enjoyed the entire movie and didn't really mind the Event Horizonesque ending because, well, I really liked Event Horizon. I know you would have preferred
but perhaps that's a matter of differing taste.
Last edited by Eurotrash; 12-03-2010 at 07:41 PM.
Reason: imo