Interesting read, thanks bigd.
A couple points from Rob Vollman that caught my eye in the Flames analysis:
Quote:
...secondary players like Blake Comeau, Lee Stempniak, and Matt Stajan consistently outplayed the third and fourth liners they faced and could probably handle tougher assignments.
This is where the analysis tends to lose me. What constitutes success for these guys in "tougher assignments?" I'm assuming that means they'll be playing against better players. Better players play more often, meaning if you're going to give the bottom 6 guys a bigger role, they in turn must play more often. And if I'm playing Matt Stajan and Blake Comeau more often, on a team that just doesn't score that much to begin with, I think I'm going to run myself into trouble. So why are we playing them against better competition? Because they tend to outshoot the other team's plugs and they need a bigger challenge?
Never mind I'm skeptical that they could even play well against better players, because both of those guys have a combined hockey IQ lower than the sum of their jersey numbers, but I'm not even sure they were as good as advertised last year against the 3rd and 4th lines they played against. Watching Comeau especially was akin to piercing your eyeballs with hot needles - he was either wasting offensive opportunities his speed created because of his tunnel vision and hands of stone, or he was taking penalties 200 feet away from his own net. And Vollman kept bemoaning his bad luck on FlamesNation this season - if anything, his 24-goal year with the Islanders is clearly becoming the statistical outlier. You watch this guy waste 2 or 3 chances into the breadbasket almost every night and you understand why he had a 3.6% shooting percentage this year despite firing the 4th most shots on the Flames - he is garbage. That's the last guy I want getting a promotion.
It's great to move the play in the right direction, but you actually need to do something once you're there as well. Maybe if they did, teams wouldn't load up against Iginla night after night. It basically comes back to what we've already known for quite some time - the Flames just aren't that deep.
This made me laugh too:
Quote:
On defense Chris Butler surprised everyone by playing on the top unit with Jay Bouwmeester, but the duo hardly set the world on fire.
I wonder why. Was I the only person in the world who saw just how much Bouwmeester had to babysit Butler? It was so ****ing depressing by the end of the season and you didn't need to be a rocket scientist to see it either.
I'm glad David Moss got some props though, he made a big difference when he returned to the lineup and for my money, he's probably one of the most underrated two way players in the league.