Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014)

11-10-2014 , 12:59 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by thediceman
Quick rundown on why not?

Just want to know if there is someone you find much more wolfy or if you think he is villager.
baudib is a really spazzy villager

I'll lyk in a bit whether or not he's falling into his villager range in my opinion

also hi dice wb
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-10-2014 , 01:00 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by thediceman
Quick rundown on why not?

Just want to know if there is someone you find much more wolfy or if you think he is villager.
I think he's more in his villager range than wolf range. He's been engaged while he's around. He certainly doesn't merit being top wagon.
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-10-2014 , 01:00 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Top Tier Tom
I feel reasonably good about calling TN a villager
based on that post and my experience with her irt her meta I'd call that a fairly accurate assumption
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-10-2014 , 01:00 PM
lilrascal is another one I practically always find wolfy.
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-10-2014 , 01:01 PM
I'm gonna do this really strangely and read the thread backwards

glglgl
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-10-2014 , 01:01 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ReddBoiler
I just explained my read

You haven't looked for wolves you've simply looked for vmf drama

But let's say I didn't explain my read

When has explaining a read ever been helpful in ww?

No one actually cares they just want to look like they're smart and intelligent and some kind of detective deciphering all the hidden clues on the trail to finding the wolves


The way I play is simply an honest game. I tell u who the wolves are - don't try and overanalyze or over explain just simply say this guy feels like a wolf this guy feels like a villager

Its pro village and more should play like it but instead there's a common misconception that justifying your reads and forcing out an explanation is pro village
To the underlined, I have made over 100 posts since I last interacted with VMF, it should be apparent to you that what you're saying is demonstrably untrue. You haven't shown any evidence that you've read any of the gamethread other than when you've been posting, therefore I don't see why you'd be coming out with a figure like 80% accuracy when talkng about your wolf reads.

And just saying people are wolves and not having anything to back it up and not changing your reads based on new posting/evidence isn't an 'honest game' and it isn't 'pro village', it's a cop-out. Explaining your reads is a way to build up trust with people, imo WW is about working together w/e team you're on but it's essential as a villager, I'm surprised you don't think that way, I don't understand how explaining your thought process, when asked, could be anything other than a good thing.
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-10-2014 , 01:01 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by thediceman
I am here.

Go easy on me guys have not played for ages, feels like I am starting all over again.

Have read 1 page so far, damn Gad you say a lot of words, any chance of being more concise?
you may not have played for ages but you are guaranteed to have played with Gad & you all know how wordy he is

people doing this make me

that means you too Tommy

Quote:
Originally Posted by thediceman
Nothing and Boner jumping on lilrascal so fast is a bit ???

Odds on finding a wolf from their first post are pretty low if I recall correctly, how about giving the guy a chance to post some thoughts.
he's been here for about 20 minutes now. plenty of time to jump into a conversation or even ask - hey who is this about?

instead he's just saying "wow there's a ton of posts. i see some drama. are there cliffs?

he just said there was drama! why didn't he comment on the supposed drama? he just "observed" the drama.

he's had time to acclimate himself to what's going on but he's not doing that

i'm not calling him a wolf right now. i'm saying - this is wolfy behavior. it's how a wolf enters the thread. he has every opportunity to change that by responding to the game.
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-10-2014 , 01:01 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by lilrascal
Do you actually want to engage in conversation or just harass me?

I haven't played with you before, so we don't know each others meta. Do you normally harass people?
We've played before

Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-10-2014 , 01:02 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by mexineil
lilrascal is another one I practically always find wolfy.
You know I always see posts like this and I have to wonder why that happens.

What is it about certain people that makes other people always read them wolfy?
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-10-2014 , 01:02 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gadarene
gonna Sun Tzu this *****; some p1-2 stuff

#1

I believe VMF is telling the truth about his claim, which (in a vacuum) makes him slightly >rand to be villa in a multifaction game

his ease of posting is also villagery

#2



yes

to a certain extent, he always sounds like that, but this is him doing it self-consciously

#3



would you say that the ones who didn't seem to know that there were multiple factions are more likely to be villagers or wolves?

hint: this is a trick question

also interested to see if you follow up on this question if people don't answer

(and through p2 you do not; why ask a question to which you don't appear to be actually interested in the response?)

#4





however, Bremen's overall output from these pages has been a lot of conversational posts that don't say much about anything

#5







toedder's post is the kind of thing a wolf does to willfully misread someone's post to make it look like they're being game-solvey

fake wolfhunting by "gotcha" nittery

#6







Vagos/Redd/baudib seeing something similar makes them >>>>rand not to be in toedder's faction, and thereby somewhat >rand villa

aside from that sequence, baudib has been by far the most villagery of the three; Redd being in active try-hard mode after multiple games of doing literally nothing as a villager has me squinty-eyed at him

#7



more self-conscious meta stuff in lieu of actually being a villager

#8

reads and junk from the first two pages

Villagery
baudib
VMF

Kinda Villagery
Vagos

Moocher
Moocher

Kinda Wolfy
Redd
younguns

Wolfy
Bremen
iversonian
toedder

let's see if I can do this for future pages faster than people make new ones

it'll be a race!
Interested to see if Gad had toedder as a wold before this post as his reason here feels pretty made up in my opinion.

If you look at the post gad quoted it seems like sarcasm to me, not a wolf trying to "catch" someone out.
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-10-2014 , 01:02 PM
well just from this page TTT seems like a villa to me, chatting with 4 or 5 ppl irt maybe cuz it s a mash but im taking it as TTT doing work
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-10-2014 , 01:02 PM
Alrighty here's where I stand aorn

>>Rand villas

Digger
CT
YG
Tommy
Zdye
UofU
TN

Wolf leans :

Baudib
Killer
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-10-2014 , 01:02 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by monstrman
based on that post and my experience with her irt her meta I'd call that a fairly accurate assumption
hurry and clear yourself so that we may bring back the #alliance
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-10-2014 , 01:03 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Top Tier Tom
I'm not making anything up. I'm giving you real time opinions of your posting. I don't think your posting sounds particularly genuine or is helping to solve the game.

Feel free to change that.
i don't care what you think tom, please stop telling me your opinion, if you say something i find interesting i'll talk to you about it
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-10-2014 , 01:03 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by monstrman
You know I always see posts like this and I have to wonder why that happens.

What is it about certain people that makes other people always read them wolfy?
Monstr is a wolf
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-10-2014 , 01:03 PM
If Mario Chalmers tried lecturing lebron about how unorthodox his play style was he'd be laughed out of the association


Only in WW can someone like moocher lecture me about my play style

And its not just him its someone new eery game

"We don't care that your reads are crazy accurate and you're constantly pushing wolves, wed like more from you"
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-10-2014 , 01:03 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by mexineil
lilrascal is another one I practically always find wolfy.
I as well

which is why I try to steer clear of those type of people early in mashes and concentrate on people I have higher success rates with.
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-10-2014 , 01:04 PM
Based on page 17 I'd call Redd in his villager range

believe it or not there is a difference between his two games
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-10-2014 , 01:04 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Boner2
Monstr is a wolf
No I'm not. Didn't you see my first post?
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-10-2014 , 01:05 PM
Gamer I'm going to ignore you for today and hope someone else kills you
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-10-2014 , 01:05 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by monstrman
You know I always see posts like this and I have to wonder why that happens.

What is it about certain people that makes other people always read them wolfy?
No idea. I always think killer and rascal are wolfy, and on the other side, VMF always thinks I'm a wolf.
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-10-2014 , 01:05 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by TheNothing
this post however, is about as wolfy as you can be after coming in and whining about how many posts there are to read. aside from not reading, it tells me zero. "i noticed some drama with several people". lol! who? what drama? what did you notice? who did you agree with?

you know what?

i came in at about 1300 posts. i said immediately i wasn't gonna read. i started playing the game. i started interacting with people. when they referenced something wolfy about someone else, i kinda searched for what they were talking about. then i decided if i agreed or not. i shared my thoughts.

i did not do what you just did

that's the difference between a villager coming up on a ton of posts (me) and whatever you did.
I noticed some drama between tom and gad, plus mooch and redd. Didn't have much to say because it appeared to be going on for some time based on back and forth content.

I only have a short lunchbreak and I'm trying to catch up to be able to contribute and instead I am defending myself for coming and and not having a lot of time.
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-10-2014 , 01:05 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Top Tier Tom
Yeah? Why do you say this? Have We even played together before?
Quick tone read from seeing a couple of your posts.
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-10-2014 , 01:05 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Boner2
Gamer I'm going to ignore you for today and hope someone else kills you
love you too jay
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-10-2014 , 01:05 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Boner2
Why dont you mention ttt in this?
Because I did not find any objection to his posting.
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote

      
m