Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Israel/Palestine thread Israel/Palestine thread

10-11-2023 , 05:19 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Slighted
it's like you immediately believe propaganda from one side but are outraged by it from another. but yet always talk about narratives?

the woman's mother is the source in the first one.. BiBi has pulled back towards "some soldiers were beheaded" in his latest statement that i saw. and the second thing seems like a facebook boomer meme, which is legit where i saw it.
Fiery, Mostly Peaceful Pogrom.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-11-2023 , 05:25 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by campfirewest
Which side in this war is Christian?
Biden
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bobo Fett
Who is Christian, what possession of his needs to follow Christ's teachings, and how would that help?
America. We would save the Middle East from violence

Quote:
Originally Posted by ArcherOfLoaf
Incorrect. There are plenty of Christians who have murdered because God told them to. See Dan and Ron Lafferty. They cut the throat of a 15 month old child, nearly beheading the child.
Thou shalt not kill.

Quote:
Originally Posted by King Spew
One Gawd to Rule them all, amirite?
I’m not Christian but Jesus had great teachings
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-11-2023 , 05:25 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by sickhuman
Fiery, Mostly Peaceful Pogrom.
no one here has said anything of the sort. the only person cheering death here so far has been you.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-11-2023 , 05:31 PM
Jesus had some amazing teachings. He was the original socialist. It's kind of incredible that so many claim to follow him yet do the exact opposite of what he preached. One of history's most incredible contradictions.

The common thread here is monotheism. Animism / polytheism are not aggressive or expansive in nature. Animists do not preach and do not seek to convert; the plurality of their gods means that they can generally (perhaps with the exception of the Norse gods? someone who knows more should chime in) are happy to accept your god alongside their own. Perhaps we could narrow it down even further to the abrahamic religions, though I'm not aware of any monotheistic religions that aren't abrahamic.

When people say 'oh I can't believe that X happens in 2023'. Wake the **** up. Despite the enlightenment and modern technology and science and all the things that entails, people still cling to their imaginary old dude in the sky and need the threat of eternal punishment in order to be good and still do obvious bad. Despite some light existing, we are still living in the dark ages. The rest of us agnostics and atheists are waiting for you knuckleheads to catch up and stop pretending we need to pay attention to your hilarious, tragic fiction. The most intractable conflicts in the world: shia vs sunni, muslim vs jew, catholic vs protestant. Absolutely pathetic. Have some humility and keep your idiotic thoughts to yourself.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-11-2023 , 05:31 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Slighted
no one here has said anything of the sort. the only person cheering death here so far has been you.
I would never cheer death. Show me where I did so please. All Human Life is Sacred and all Death is Tragic.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-11-2023 , 05:57 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ArcherOfLoaf
None of this happens if religion is removed from the equation.
This is regularly exaggerated.

The Jewish community that settled Palestine starting in the 19th Century was mostly secular socialists. The 1967 war was launched by a Labor government. The PLO began as a secular nationalist organization. Through most of the decades the conflict has been driven just fine by rationalists. Hamas did not come on the scene until the 1980s. The Israeli religious parties did not become prominent until fairly recently.

Strident atheists greatly overestimate their resistance to nationalist bedazzlement.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-11-2023 , 06:00 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bill Haywood
This is regularly exaggerated.

The Jewish community that settled Palestine starting in the 19th Century was mostly secular socialists. The 1967 war was launched by a Labor government. The PLO began as a secular nationalist organization. Through most of the decades the conflict has been driven just fine by rationalists. Hamas did not come on the scene until the 1980s. The Israeli religious parties did not become prominent until fairly recently.

Strident atheists greatly overestimate their resistance to nationalist bedazzlement.
And yet Yitzhak Rabin was murdered by a religious extremist, Hamas regularly cite the reason they want to extinguish Israel being because they're jewish, and jewish people even itt claim that non-jewish lives are worth less than jewish lives. Just because there have been currents of atheism, or, more accurately, less extreme religiosity, and still been fighting, doesn't mean that religion isn't just the core reason, it's the only reason. If you could magically convert every person in the middle east to atheism overnight, the conflict would disappear overnight.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-11-2023 , 06:19 PM
The conflict would continue for as long as Palestinian ex-Muslims would continue to be subjugated by an Israeli government.

Like all conflict, it's about a power imbalance materialised as shortages (of equality, land, health, opportunity etc).

Last edited by jalfrezi; 10-11-2023 at 06:27 PM.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-11-2023 , 06:24 PM
are Countries not permitted to value the live of its citizens more highly than Citizens of enemy countries?

Biden traded Brittney Griner for the #1 arms dealer in the world during a war w Ukraine, so clearly her life was valued more highly than the average Ukrainian soldier.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-11-2023 , 06:33 PM
He was gonna be released like two years later anyway
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-11-2023 , 06:37 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by PointlessWords
He was gonna be released like two years later anyway
I wonder if the EV of having Viktor Bout help source weapons for you for two years during a war is greater than one Ukrainian Solder.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-11-2023 , 06:43 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bill Haywood
This is regularly exaggerated.

The Jewish community that settled Palestine starting in the 19th Century was mostly secular socialists. The 1967 war was launched by a Labor government. The PLO began as a secular nationalist organization. Through most of the decades the conflict has been driven just fine by rationalists. Hamas did not come on the scene until the 1980s. The Israeli religious parties did not become prominent until fairly recently.

Strident atheists greatly overestimate their resistance to nationalist bedazzlement.
One need not be an atheist to recognize the absurdity of religion.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-11-2023 , 07:16 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by wazz
And yet Yitzhak Rabin was murdered by a religious extremist, Hamas regularly cite the reason they want to extinguish Israel being because they're jewish, and jewish people even itt claim that non-jewish lives are worth less than jewish lives. Just because there have been currents of atheism, or, more accurately, less extreme religiosity, and still been fighting, doesn't mean that religion isn't just the core reason, it's the only reason. If you could magically convert every person in the middle east to atheism overnight, the conflict would disappear overnight.
Overnight? You think all the Israelis living in Palestinian homes seized in 1948 would walk away? The diaspora of expelled Palestinians would be let back home? No way. The main points of contention would endure.

The Neocons are not religious, yet they organized the preposterous invasion of Iraq. Henry Kissinger isn't religious to speak of, yet he's a war criminal. The 1979 war between China and Vietnam had no religious angle. The crimes of Stalin were not religiously motivated.

Israel/Palestine is first a struggle over land, which some people experience in religious terms. Religion has become important in the Palestine war, but it didn't start out that way.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-11-2023 , 07:18 PM
There is no oil or any resources to speak of in that land. No One would have ever cared about Israel, if it were not for religion.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-11-2023 , 07:21 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by sickhuman
There is no oil or any resources to speak of in that land. No One would have ever cared about Israel, if it were not for religion.
A couple million people seems like a resource.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-11-2023 , 07:26 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Victor
A couple million people seems like a resource.
or a liability.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-11-2023 , 07:27 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Victor
A couple million people seems like a resource.
How? Are we making Soylent Green?
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-11-2023 , 07:28 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by sickhuman
or a liability.
the Israeli psychos dont keep them around bc they view it this way. they serve an invaluable purpose.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-11-2023 , 07:39 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bill Haywood
Overnight? You think all the Israelis living in Palestinian homes seized in 1948 would walk away? The diaspora of expelled Palestinians would be let back home? No way. The main points of contention would endure.

The Neocons are not religious, yet they organized the preposterous invasion of Iraq. Henry Kissinger isn't religious to speak of, yet he's a war criminal. The 1979 war between China and Vietnam had no religious angle. The crimes of Stalin were not religiously motivated.

Israel/Palestine is first a struggle over land, which some people experience in religious terms. Religion has become important in the Palestine war, but it didn't start out that way.
I think the premise is that religion will always be a source of conflict .
Always been .

I don’t think anyone said abolishing religion would entirely eradicate wars .
Wars have many reason on why it happens .
Religion is just one reason shrug .

Last edited by Montrealcorp; 10-11-2023 at 07:46 PM.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-11-2023 , 07:41 PM
Hamas and the Israeli billionaires and the American arms companies need this war, in the same way rich people need poor people to exist. That is a large part of why this keeps happening.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Bill Haywood
Overnight? You think all the Israelis living in Palestinian homes seized in 1948 would walk away? The diaspora of expelled Palestinians would be let back home? No way. The main points of contention would endure.

The Neocons are not religious, yet they organized the preposterous invasion of Iraq. Henry Kissinger isn't religious to speak of, yet he's a war criminal. The 1979 war between China and Vietnam had no religious angle. The crimes of Stalin were not religiously motivated.

Israel/Palestine is first a struggle over land, which some people experience in religious terms. Religion has become important in the Palestine war, but it didn't start out that way.
Neocons might not be religious themselves, but they frequently make them their allies. A lot of neocons are religious too, even if they're not making it their platform. Look at Jordan Peterson and the symbiotic relationship he has with Ben Shapiro. William F Buckley has been described as the original neocon, and while religion wasn't the thing he put front and centre in all his words, it is there in the background, sometimes in the foreground as he moralised. I think you'd be hard-pressed to find prominent neocons that are atheist or agnostic, or at least ones that wear their atheism / agnosticism as one of their main things.

And yes, overnight, if you could deradicalise everyone in the middle east, the situation would be less... radical. How could it not?
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-11-2023 , 07:42 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by sickhuman
There is no oil or any resources to speak of in that land. No One would have ever cared about Israel, if it were not for religion.
We have the documents. We know why the Truman administration in 1948 chose to back Israel no matter what. It was to have a strong ally astride the oil lanes. Truman got a political boost from the Jewish vote, but that's not why the security complex got behind Israel, despite the embarrassment of Israel refusing to allow 750,000 refugees to return.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-11-2023 , 07:42 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by wazz
Jesus had some amazing teachings. He was the original socialist. It's kind of incredible that so many claim to follow him yet do the exact opposite of what he preached. One of history's most incredible contradictions.

The common thread here is monotheism. Animism / polytheism are not aggressive or expansive in nature. Animists do not preach and do not seek to convert; the plurality of their gods means that they can generally (perhaps with the exception of the Norse gods? someone who knows more should chime in) are happy to accept your god alongside their own. Perhaps we could narrow it down even further to the abrahamic religions, though I'm not aware of any monotheistic religions that aren't abrahamic.

When people say 'oh I can't believe that X happens in 2023'. Wake the **** up. Despite the enlightenment and modern technology and science and all the things that entails, people still cling to their imaginary old dude in the sky and need the threat of eternal punishment in order to be good and still do obvious bad. Despite some light existing, we are still living in the dark ages. The rest of us agnostics and atheists are waiting for you knuckleheads to catch up and stop pretending we need to pay attention to your hilarious, tragic fiction. The most intractable conflicts in the world: shia vs sunni, muslim vs jew, catholic vs protestant. Absolutely pathetic. Have some humility and keep your idiotic thoughts to yourself.
U sir, are a sad shame of life
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-11-2023 , 07:44 PM
Fwiw trying to find who’s right or wrong in this conflict is absurd .
They both did terrible things for decades and both are lead by extremists .
There is no issues before extremist thinking gets eradicated on both sides .
Extremism do not bring people together in a long lasting social existence .
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-11-2023 , 07:46 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bill Haywood
We have the documents. We know why the Truman administration in 1948 chose to back Israel no matter what. It was to have a strong ally astride the oil lanes. Truman got a political boost from the Jewish vote, but that's not why the security complex got behind Israel, despite the embarrassment of Israel refusing to allow 750,000 refugees to return.
Meyer Lansky dropping off 2 Million in Cash didn't hurt.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-11-2023 , 07:46 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by wazz
Hamas and the Israeli billionaires and the American arms companies need this war, in the same way rich people need poor people to exist. That is a large part of why this keeps happening.



Neocons might not be religious themselves, but they frequently make them their allies. A lot of neocons are religious too, even if they're not making it their platform. Look at Jordan Peterson and the symbiotic relationship he has with Ben Shapiro. William F Buckley has been described as the original neocon, and while religion wasn't the thing he put front and centre in all his words, it is there in the background, sometimes in the foreground as he moralised. I think you'd be hard-pressed to find prominent neocons that are atheist or agnostic, or at least ones that wear their atheism / agnosticism as one of their main things.

And yes, overnight, if you could deradicalise everyone in the middle east, the situation would be less... radical. How could it not?
YEAH. Let's just all be complete turd's and everything will be ok. Liberal's, like yourself, are the quack to society.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote

      
m