Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Israel/Palestine thread Israel/Palestine thread

10-10-2023 , 12:09 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by d2_e4
Nah. What possible purpose does it serve? Pretty sure he is not attempting to look like a dumbass on purpose.
It doesn't matter if he looks like a dumbass or not, the goal is the flood the zone with so much bullshit that any adult conversation about politics is impossible.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-10-2023 , 12:09 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by PointlessWords
Israel has complete control over their water. Since this is true, we know Gaza is not autonomous. If Gaza is subservient to Israel and they have complete control, whyÂ’re they turning off the water? If there is no water for a month, how many kids die, 500k?
Yeah, they don't have any good options left: return the hostages and surrender or leave the area. And it's not just the water, it's the sewage too. I mean, imagine the Bronx without sewage for a month, not to mention air quality, disease, etc. And their tunnel system isn't going to save them because by the looks of things last night Israel has already started clearing them out with napalm runs. So the area won't be fit for normal human habitation for a while, as with most war zones.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-10-2023 , 12:22 PM
Hamas was really savage killing the civilians in these manners
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-10-2023 , 12:36 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Slighted
just to be clear, shutting off the power/water and starving Gaza is a war crime, anyone even considering that is a horrible person. and if the Israeli government actually does it, they should be held responsible for that war crime by the rest of the world, no matter what the provocation.
A lot of them don't see their enemy as people - that obviously includes the higher ups and is why this fighting will get worse.

Quote:
We are fighting human animals, and we act accordingly,” Israeli Defense Minister Yoav Gallant said on Monday. “As of now, no electricity, no food, no fuel for Gaza.”
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-10-2023 , 01:47 PM
Is this actually true??
https://nbcmontana.com/news/nation-w...onflict-attack

Quote:
KFAR AZA, Israel (TND) — Dozens of babies were reportedly found dead, including some that had been beheaded, in an Israeli kibbutz Tuesday after the terrorist organization Hamas stormed the community.

Several journalists were let in to the Kfar Aza kibbutz, located just outside the Gaza Strip, to see the aftermath of the attacks by Hamas. At least 70 residents of the kibbutz were killed by Hamas terrorists, according to Indian news website OpIndia.

Nicole Zedeck, a correspondent for Israeli television channel i24NEWS, described the scene as "truly horrific."

"No one could expect that it would be like this, the horrors that I'm hearing from these soldiers," Zedeck said. "As I mentioned earlier, about 40 babies, at least, were taken out on gurneys ... you continue to see just cribs overturned, strollers left behind, all of these doors left wide open."
Words fail me, if so.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-10-2023 , 01:55 PM
Some entire families have been killed after retreating to their safe rooms, which were breached.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-10-2023 , 01:58 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Trolly McTrollson
It doesn't matter if he looks like a dumbass or not, the goal is the flood the zone with so much bullshit that any adult conversation about politics is impossible.
Or changed the mind of some fools by brainwashing .
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-10-2023 , 02:05 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by jalfrezi
Some entire families have been killed after retreating to their safe rooms, which were breached.
This is a pogrom plain and simple.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-10-2023 , 02:15 PM
Nothing new under the sun from terrorist .
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-10-2023 , 02:17 PM
Two groups of terrorists - Hamas and the current state of Israel.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-10-2023 , 02:30 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by corpus vile
Is this actually true??
https://nbcmontana.com/news/nation-w...onflict-attack



Words fail me, if so.
The Israelis don't seem to have given an official count yet of the number of people murdered at Kfar Aza. You need to be a bit careful, bearing in mind the improbable atrocity stories of German troops 'crucifying Belgian babies' in 1914. But Hamas are far worse than the Kaiser's troops, and it does seem to be clear that whole families were murdered, and this includes children and even infants.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-10-2023 , 02:54 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by washoe
like the Irish I reckon. The Irish freedom fighters?
The IRA, who were never freedom fighters (they always had the vote like everyone else), committed numerous appalling crimes, but nothing quite like this.

Quote:
But here these thugs just follow orders from the top imo. From Iran or whatnot. We are talking about an Arabic Muslim country afterall.
I think you may have just done a racism. And Iran, of course, is not an Arab country, and it's Shia and not Sunni, and Iran's leaders don't give a damn about Palestine, they're just playing regional power games. Hamas don't really give a damn about the Palestinian cause either, and they certainly aren't interested in the West Bank (which is Israeli-occupied, unlike Gaza). They just like killing people.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-10-2023 , 02:55 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Trolly McTrollson
Why would he bother? He makes no effort to disguise his posting and the powers that be are fine with it. I'm pretty sure the handwaive thing is deliberate.
That decision was made before my time. I have learned since agreeing to be a mod that more users have multiple accounts than I had imagined. And a decent percentage of people with multiple accounts have had previous accounts that were banned. The poster formerly known as Kelhus is far from the only one.

My personal view is that it is pathetic to have multiple accounts unless the sole purpose of the second account is to ask anonymously for advice on a sensitive issue.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-10-2023 , 02:58 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by corpus vile
Is this actually true??
https://nbcmontana.com/news/nation-w...onflict-attack



Words fail me, if so.
I don't know whether this specific story is accurate or not. Wartime reports on stuff like this are often unreliable. But it seems very likely that some entire families were deliberately killed.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-10-2023 , 03:04 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by corpus vile
Murdering three year olds like Jonathan Ball and 12 year olds like Tim Parry in Warrington isn't freedom fighting Washoe. Or murdering 21 people in Birmingham. Or attempting to use Protestant civilians as proxy suicide bombers. You commit atrocities like that and you have no justification claiming oppression or highlighting your communities grievances, however legitimate you may think your grievances are. I feel repulsed such things were done in Ireland's name as does any other normal thinking Irish person.

You commit mass slaughter of people in Kibbutz's and wilfully target civilians just because they're Jewish and you have zero credibility claiming oppression. Hamas have zero credibility in my eyes.
I did not know you felt this strong about Ireland. maybe a bad example, I thought you were going to acknowledge that the brits messed with the Irish first but of course you are right in that it wasnt justified how they reacted.

Hamas? who is hamas? Just s bunch of guys, the footsoldiers of the middle East.. right? The ss troops of the leaderships. so they don't have to have credibility. All they are doing what someone told them to do. And these someone's sit in mosques and parliaments all over the middle east. good luck singling anyone out. this is a mass collective thinking/ convincement, right? Not anything the foot soldiers come up with.

So this is a such complex issue that is not solvable by taking out Hamas. They already tried. every time they try to cut off the head off this Dragon, 7 new heads appear.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-10-2023 , 03:06 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Rococo
That decision was made before my time. I have learned since agreeing to be a mod that more users have multiple accounts than I had imagined. And a decent percentage of people with multiple accounts have had previous accounts that were banned. The poster formerly known as Kelhus is far from the only one.

My personal view is that it is pathetic to have multiple accounts unless the sole purpose of the second account is to ask anonymously for advice on a sensitive issue.
Trolly's not one to talk anyway. Pretty sure he used to post as joe6pack.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-10-2023 , 03:10 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by 57 On Red
The IRA, who were never freedom fighters (they always had the vote like everyone else), committed numerous appalling crimes, but nothing quite like this.



I think you may have just done a racism. And Iran, of course, is not an Arab country, and it's Shia and not Sunni, and Iran's leaders don't give a damn about Palestine, they're just playing regional power games. Hamas don't really give a damn about the Palestinian cause either, and they certainly aren't interested in the West Bank (which is Israeli-occupied, unlike Gaza). They just like killing people.
Why racism? It is Muslims that attacked Israel. Like it always is. Right? where the leaders are from doesn't matter. But they are spread across everywhere there. It's a feature not a bug.

What happened is that Lebanon attacked Israel from the Lebanese side with Lebanese people and then Hamas claimed the attack.

So I don't know why we are talking about Palestine so much. It was an attack by Hamas from Lebanon.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-10-2023 , 03:10 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Slighted
just to be clear, shutting off the power/water and starving Gaza is a war crime, anyone even considering that is a horrible person. and if the Israeli government actually does it, they should be held responsible for that war crime by the rest of the world, no matter what the provocation.
Starvation is not supposed to be used against the general population in a siege situation, so Israel will probably back off on it. However, besieged forces are not supposed to put military assets in civilian areas, or in fact in any area of dense population at all, and Hamas does not observe any such rules, and of course Western 'liberals' think the law applies only to Israel and not to good old Hamas.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-10-2023 , 03:13 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by washoe
Why racism? It is Muslims that attack Israel. Like it always is.

What happened is that Lebanon attacked Israel from the Lebanese side with Lebanese people and then Hamas claimed the attack.

So I don't know why we are talking about Palestine so much. It was an attack by Hamas from Lebanon.
No, the attack came from Gaza. (Hamas doesn't really exist outside Gaza.) We still don't know if Hezbollah, Iran's catspaw in Lebanon, will join in. You seem a bit confused.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-10-2023 , 03:17 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Metod Tinuviel
Not saying it will be easy, but the Gaza strip is not a big place. They don't have to solve every problem, just the one that lives next door. Not saying that it will become a democratic paradise, but at least they won't have a terrorist group ruling.
They are surrounded by Lebanon etc. these are all 'enemies' of israel since it is all Muslim countries that surround them. why gaza? the attackers came from Lebanon.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-10-2023 , 03:21 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by 57 On Red
No, the attack came from Gaza. (Hamas doesn't really exist outside Gaza.) We still don't know if Hezbollah, Iran's catspaw in Lebanon, will join in. You seem a bit confused.
well the news say the attack oriniated from Lebanon with Lebanese fighters from Lebanese territory.

Even the first missiles came from lebanese headquarters which are always under schools kindergarden, and mosques. They use human shields.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-10-2023 , 03:21 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by 57 On Red
Starvation is not supposed to be used against the general population in a siege situation, so Israel will probably back off on it. However, besieged forces are not supposed to put military assets in civilian areas, or in fact in any area of dense population at all, and Hamas does not observe any such rules, and of course Western 'liberals' think the law applies only to Israel and not to good old Hamas.
I don’t think many Western liberals are defending Hamas right now to be fair. Seems to be universal condemnation from all major Western party leaders. Some fringe lefty types are, but they are fringe for a reason.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-10-2023 , 03:22 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by 57 On Red
No, the attack came from Gaza. (Hamas doesn't really exist outside Gaza.) We still don't know if Hezbollah, Iran's catspaw in Lebanon, will join in. You seem a bit confused.
Hezbollah is already involved.
Attack came from Lebanon as you can read anywhere.

https://www.reuters.com/world/middle...es-2023-10-10/


Last edited by washoe; 10-10-2023 at 03:30 PM.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-10-2023 , 03:29 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by 57 On Red
Starvation is not supposed to be used against the general population in a siege situation, so Israel will probably back off on it. However, besieged forces are not supposed to put military assets in civilian areas, or in fact in any area of dense population at all, and Hamas does not observe any such rules, and of course Western 'liberals' think the law applies only to Israel and not to good old Hamas.
yes. i do think the laws and norms should be applied more heavily against governments than rogue terrorist organizations. no one is defending hamas, the israeli government should be able to attempt to target hamas without starving and dehydrating a million kids under 18 though.

but again there are no "good" actors in this conflict. both the israeli government and hamas are bad. it's a shame that millions of citizens are subject to this.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-10-2023 , 03:46 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by 57 On Red
The Israelis don't seem to have given an official count yet of the number of people murdered at Kfar Aza. You need to be a bit careful, bearing in mind the improbable atrocity stories of German troops 'crucifying Belgian babies' in 1914. But Hamas are far worse than the Kaiser's troops, and it does seem to be clear that whole families were murdered, and this includes children and even infants.
I'm aware this might not be true and as you said, there are numerous false accounts throughout history of enemy barbarism. It sounds almost like hysteria. But again if true, then I really don't know what to say. I'm hoping it's fake news.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote

      
m