Open Side Menu Go to the Top

06-18-2025 , 06:35 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Chilltown
Alberta has let the nation down once again.

Just join as the 51st state and boom, cup drought is over. Pretty simple.

The NHL Thread Quote
The NHL Thread
$25m Guaranteed WPM on CoinPoker
Join the action now
Daily Rewards • Splash Pots • CoinRaces
The NHL Thread
06-18-2025 , 06:41 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by MEb
Wayne Gretzky ain’t walking through that door.


How is he overrated? Is he not the best player in the league? Has he not been for years? Tell me how he’s overrated. What should his rating be?
The NHL Thread Quote
06-18-2025 , 06:55 PM
his name is mcbust, because he's a bust. terrible draft pick, they should have gone with eichel instead obv
The NHL Thread Quote
06-18-2025 , 07:07 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by NhlNut
Used to post on 2p2

El Diablo?
The NHL Thread Quote
06-18-2025 , 09:20 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Malucci
How is he overrated? Is he not the best player in the league? Has he not been for years? Tell me how he’s overrated. What should his rating be?

lol McOverrated is such a loser

Mark Messier ain’t walking through that door.
The NHL Thread Quote
06-18-2025 , 09:22 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Malucci
How is he overrated? Is he not the best player in the league? Has he not been for years? Tell me how he’s overrated. What should his rating be?

The NHL Thread Quote
06-18-2025 , 09:23 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Malucci
How is he overrated? Is he not the best player in the league? Has he not been for years? Tell me how he’s overrated. What should his rating be?

Imagine being such a gigantic loser like McOverrated that the media feels so bad for hyping you so much that they give you the conn smythe as a loser.
The NHL Thread Quote
06-18-2025 , 09:25 PM
https://soundcloud.com/andrewstreete...egs-exonerated Stream MCOVERRATED (GREG'S EXONERATED) by andrewstreeter | Listen online for free on SoundCloud
The NHL Thread Quote
06-18-2025 , 09:32 PM
Jari Kurri ain’t walking through that door.
The NHL Thread Quote
06-18-2025 , 10:01 PM
I'm bored.


More hockey, please.
The NHL Thread Quote
06-18-2025 , 10:07 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Malucci
How is he overrated? Is he not the best player in the league? Has he not been for years? Tell me how he’s overrated. What should his rating be?

If he wants to get traded to the Ice Cats, I’m sure they’ll let McOverrated skate on the 3rd line so he can ride their coattails to a ring.
The NHL Thread Quote
06-18-2025 , 10:08 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by MEb
Imagine being such a gigantic loser like McOverrated that the media feels so bad for hyping you so much that they give you the conn smythe as a loser.
10 points more (33%) than the next highest, and 20 points more (nearly 50%) than the highest cup winning player. Stats kinda speak for themself.

Led playoffs in points 2 years in a row. McOverrated/McBust are just jealous people talking. He's clearly the best player in the league.
The NHL Thread Quote
06-18-2025 , 10:10 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by housenuts
10 points more (33%) than the next highest, and 20 points more (nearly 50%) than the highest cup winning player. Stats kinda speak for themself.

Led playoffs in points 2 years in a row. McOverrated/McBust are just jealous people talking. He's clearly the best player in the league.

The NHL Thread Quote
06-18-2025 , 10:11 PM
Paul Coffey ain’t walking through that door
The NHL Thread Quote
06-18-2025 , 11:34 PM
The NBA thread is already unreadable. Must you also Tard up this thread with who ain't walking thru that door. We dgaf.
The NHL Thread Quote
06-19-2025 , 12:05 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by housenuts
10 points more (33%) than the next highest, and 20 points more (nearly 50%) than the highest cup winning player. Stats kinda speak for themself.

Led playoffs in points 2 years in a row. McOverrated/McBust are just jealous people talking. He's clearly the best player in the league.

nah, bad player. born loser
The NHL Thread Quote
06-19-2025 , 12:14 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by CowboyCold
The NBA thread is already unreadable. Must you also Tard up this thread with who ain't walking thru that door. We dgaf.
I'll allow it fwiw especially considering both finals have had clear big favorites who are going to win.

SO...any extra relevant posts we can get in MY NHL thread are a net positive for all of us NHL fans!

Spoiler:
sorry for running a power trip on u CC, just want to see this thread get more action
The NHL Thread Quote
06-19-2025 , 12:24 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Malucci
How is he overrated? Is he not the best player in the league? Has he not been for years? Tell me how he’s overrated. What should his rating be?
Quote:
Originally Posted by MEb
lol McOverrated is such a loser

Mark Messier ain’t walking through that door.
if VGK were given a choice of draisaitl or mcdavid, I'd snap take draisaitl. He is the better player. So, by default imho, no mcdavid is not the best player in the league.


wayne gretzky won 4 SC in his 9 full years in Edmonton. McDavid has won none. But the NHL media (i.e. Canadians other than 72off) will still claim he has been the best player in the NHL for the last decade.
The NHL Thread Quote
06-19-2025 , 01:37 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by 702guy
if VGK were given a choice of draisaitl or mcdavid, I'd snap take draisaitl. He is the better player. So, by default imho, no mcdavid is not the best player in the league.


wayne gretzky won 4 SC in his 9 full years in Edmonton. McDavid has won none. But the NHL media (i.e. Canadians other than 72off) will still claim he has been the best player in the NHL for the last decade.
Cups don't = best player.

The far and away best player could be a 200 ppg player with a team full of scrubs. Don't even make the playoffs. Dude is still the best.

McD is the best player in the league. I don't think that's very controversial and would be > 50% over the field. Next highest rated might not even crack 10%

Drai is great, but doubt he ranks 2nd. Possibly gets 3rd highest tally.
The NHL Thread Quote
06-19-2025 , 03:34 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by 702guy
if VGK were given a choice of draisaitl or mcdavid, I'd snap take draisaitl. He is the better player. So, by default imho, no mcdavid is not the best player in the league.


wayne gretzky won 4 SC in his 9 full years in Edmonton. McDavid has won none. But the NHL media (i.e. Canadians other than 72off) will still claim he has been the best player in the NHL for the last decade.
gretsky's oilers were absolutely stacked, even won the cup after trading away gretsky

and... they had goaltending

5 of his oiler teammates went on to the HHOF, and not just casual hall of famers either, like some of the best players of their generation to boot

how many on McDavid's team goes other than him and Drai?
The NHL Thread Quote
06-19-2025 , 06:16 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by 702guy
I'll allow it fwiw especially considering both finals have had clear big favorites who are going to win.

SO...any extra relevant posts we can get in MY NHL thread are a net positive for all of us NHL fans!

Spoiler:
sorry for running a power trip on u CC, just want to see this thread get more action
So you are saying " green name 702guy ain't walking through that door"
The NHL Thread Quote
06-19-2025 , 06:25 AM
Also Toronto was the team that did best against Florida?,WTF.
The NHL Thread Quote
06-19-2025 , 08:02 AM
Only two defensible choices for best player itw

A) McDavid
B) Bennett
The NHL Thread Quote
06-19-2025 , 09:14 AM
Drai isn't even the best player on his own line!

So Edmonton runs it back next year until the deadline, when they either blow it up or make a run. Then all hell breaks loose.
The NHL Thread Quote
06-19-2025 , 09:16 AM
And if McD signs anywhere for longer than 2 years, I'm going to have a conniption fit.
The NHL Thread Quote
The NHL Thread
$25m Guaranteed WPM on CoinPoker
Join the action now
Daily Rewards • Splash Pots • CoinRaces
The NHL Thread

      
m