re: cutting weight
I realize Silva walks around at 205+ and wouldn't have to cut weight. What does Jon Jones walk around at though? He's considered huge for a LHW and it's pretty much inevitable he will move up to HW soon. Doesn't he walk around at 220+?
Quote:
Originally Posted by StewiesMinion
he'd consider it because he thinks he's the best and wants the challenge and/or to prove it.
what he has to gain is competition.
i know i'd personally find it much more honorable/respectable for someone to push their limits and go out on their shield if need be. both of these fighters ducking each other certainly makes me think less of them vs someone like BJ Penn who dominated his peers so much that he fought guys at WW and even LHWs.
I could see someone doing this if they are/were in their prime, but Silva is almost 40. Can he actually win this fight? (unless Jones is smaller than I think -- there's no way right?)
Would you find it honorable/respectable for GSP to fight Junior Dos Santos? Would you find it honorable/respectable for Royce Gracie to fight Matt Hughes (scratch that -- make Matt Hughes 20 pounds bigger relative to Gracie and subtract 6 years from Hughes)?
Taking any and all comers for the challenge is respectable and all up to a point, but there is a limit to the fights you should intelligently take based on age, weight classes, and stage of your career. I think a 37 year old fighting a 25 year old who is crushing everyone in a weight class 20 pounds heavier than the one you fight at goes a little past the honorable/respectable line and is starting to approach the ludicrous territory.
Unless of course he can actually win and I'm overestimating Jon Jones either in his skill or his "true weight". Or cutting to 195 will drastically effect him... but if that's true I don't see the huge deal because we're not seeing a Jon Jones at his peak fighting ability anyway.