Quote:
Originally Posted by RainierWolfcastle
Maybe I'm incredibly sexist, but I think Perry comes across smarter than Bachmann. I know he's messed up terribly in debates in the past as well, but I don't see his gaffe from Wednesday being evidence of stupidity as much as evidence of a guy who isn't particularly adept at debates in general and who's mind went completely blank at the worst possible time. Had Rick Perry been able to list that third agency, would it be reflective of an entirely different level of intelligence?
Re: Perry, I agree that the gaffe from the other night is probably wrongly being attributed to a lack of intelligence when I think it's more about being somewhat bad at public speaking and also to an extent might be akin to an athlete whose slump gets into his head. That may not have ever happened if he wasn't dealing with a series of bad debate performances. It wouldn't kill someone if it was a stand-alone...if Romney had a forgetful moment like that one time, he would rightfully get a pass because everyone is fully aware that he knows his stuff. But there is precedent for Perry, he had already come off as pretty unintelligent at times, and when something like that happens to perpetuate your image you're screwed. Eloquence does too quickly get interchanged with intelligence in our society, but I still have a hard time seeing Perry as a bright guy.
If a person is going to question Bachmann's intelligence I'm surprised they don't question Santorum's in the same breath. His crazy statements have been more egregious than hers. I generally see him as a pretty bright guy though, just not one I possibly want in the White House.
I just see Bachmann a different way. I see her as crazy like a fox, knowing just how to pander to the audience she's speaking to. She has chosen to pander to one of the more odious parts of the right wing at times, which really doesn't reflect well on her, but it doesn't reflect on a lack of intelligence either IMO. I think on some level my opinion of Bachmann was boosted by really low expectations...before I became familiar with her, I heard multiple people compare her to Palin (a very surface-level comparison that I don't think holds water at all). Once I thought I would be seeing a mouthbreather talk and she came off as knowledgeable and well-spoken, I guess I sort of quickly slotted her under the category of "Republicans that lefties call stupid that aren't really."
Quote:
Originally Posted by Case Closed
I don't think this helps. Or at least, I don't think this should.
I think the idea was right, but the execution sucked. Perry wasn't funny in it and seemed to not have any knack for comedy. I had more hope for him being funny before watching that clip than I would have had for John McCain before doing that roast of Obama at the press dinner in '08, when McCain turned out to be surprisingly funny.