Quote:
Originally Posted by fraleyight
There is, its been a while since ive looked at the photos but there is a coat hanging on a door near the slippers. One theory I heard was that the keys fell out of the pocket of the coat when the coat was removed from the door during the search.
While that is an interesting theory, there is no evidence that key was ever in Steven's coat.
Quote:
If the key is lodged in the back of the shelves backboard its easy to see how the key could have fallen out of the back while being moved around and fallen on top of the slippers.
It may be easy for you to imagine the key somehow falling out of the back of the shelf and somehow bouncing to the side. My imagination isn't so vivid.
As it is we have no evidence the key was ever on those shelves either.
I'm quoting the relevant material. Kurchaski admits he was not watching what Lenk & Colburn were doing, as he was supposed to be doing.
Why was Kurchaski babysitting them? Because of the admitted conflict of interest due to Steven's lawsuit against their department.
Quote:
As he goes on:
Kratz:"is that in the sense that anything is possible"
Kurchaski: "thats in the sense that its possible aliens put it there I guess"
Clearly Kurchaski was saying its possible in a Cartesian doubt sort of way.
The obvious question is whether Kurchaski observed any aliens in the room when the key suddenly materialized on the floor.
Is there anyone who thinks
aliens planting the key is equally likely as
humans planting the key? Then why not think aliens abducting Teresa is equally likely?
Quote:
Either way all of this is sort of avoiding the question that it doesnt make sense for a key to be planted on the second trip to averys room. Oddly enough, the more times the same member of LE enters the room the less likely it becomes the key was planted in the way it was discovered.
I disagree.
As I have already pointed out there is no reason to assume Colburn & Lenk must have had the key in their possession during the search on the 5th.