Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Atlanta Braves: Win More Games Than The Hawks? Atlanta Braves: Win More Games Than The Hawks?

11-17-2014 , 11:59 PM
I was already s/mad and I came in here for some comfort and what do I see? You guys all talking about average, homers and RsBI.

Atlanta Braves: Win More Games Than The Hawks? Quote
11-18-2014 , 12:09 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by PocketChads
I was already s/mad and I came in here for some comfort and what do I see? You guys all talking about average, homers and RsBI.

It's really just TJ and JH

I'm not sure what the RBI talk is about. Is he trying to dumb down to his audience because I'm insulted. 😟
Atlanta Braves: Win More Games Than The Hawks? Quote
11-18-2014 , 12:25 AM
hahaha sorry.

I'm used to gently trying to explain newer stats to my dad, who's pretty old school in his stats.

I remember a few years ago I was going to try to explain FIP, and he thought Tim Hudson was having a better year than a peak-Roy Halladay season because of lol pitcher wins.
Atlanta Braves: Win More Games Than The Hawks? Quote
11-18-2014 , 01:05 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by TJ Eckleburg12
I'm angry, but I see why the organization did it. I guess the question is if you think Heyward can take a big step forward. I think he can, and will, but if he is what he is, about a .270 hitter with 15 home runs with all-world defense, then I can see why they did it.

4 years of team control for Shelby Miller vs 1 year of Heyward, who as mentioned is probably getting $100M thrown at him by the Yankees or the Red Sox this time next year.

I thought if the organization had to choose between Justin and Jason that they'd choose Jason. Guess not.

I just stubbornly believe in Jason, I think he has Hall of Fame upside if his power ever matches his frame.
I think they're expecting Heyward to have a big season which would move him wayy out of our price range. He's gonna be getting 100mil min on the open market. Maybe approach 200mil if he improves offensively.

But I don't like the way Hart and co. handled it. I heard in passing that they didn't even approach Heyward about an extension..wtf? The guy has made it clear he wants to be here...

I dunno. The whole him being a Georgia boy thing makes it tough, too. And knowing we spent so much money on Uggla/BJ while at the same time unable to lock up Heyward just kills me.

Oh and it just has to be the Cards doesn't it..jfc

Quote:
Originally Posted by TJ Eckleburg12
Who's gonna play in the outfield if we move Justin?

The only thing in Justin's favor over Heyward is that he's already about a 30/100 guy, and Heyward only has the potential to fill out into that.
Gattis apparently..which is gonna be hilarious to watch. But if Justin is traded too then fuggit not like it matters..rebuilding year anyway I assume

Quote:
Originally Posted by AngerPush
From tweets today only ones safe are Freeman Simmons Kimbrel and "top 3 pitchers".
Not sure why Kimbrel would be safe. Dude is amazing but yea yay 2 war I guess. We'd get some dumb team to give us way more than he's worth

Last edited by hard2tel; 11-18-2014 at 01:11 AM.
Atlanta Braves: Win More Games Than The Hawks? Quote
11-18-2014 , 01:19 AM
Argh the more this gets to me I think this organization is going to rue the day they got rid of Jason
Atlanta Braves: Win More Games Than The Hawks? Quote
11-18-2014 , 08:28 AM
why exactly couldn't they keep him? I understand the Braves don't have Yankee money bu t I think they can afford to lock him up at 15 mil a year for 5-6 years. BTW Lastella is gone to.
Atlanta Braves: Win More Games Than The Hawks? Quote
11-18-2014 , 10:49 AM
I was OK with the Heyward trade when I first heard about it, but after reading that they didn't even pursue a long-term contract, I'm pretty annoyed. Possible home-town discount on a fan favorite with elite defense and solid hitting? GTFO MOAR PITCHERS
Atlanta Braves: Win More Games Than The Hawks? Quote
11-18-2014 , 10:59 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by bobman0330
I was OK with the Heyward trade when I first heard about it, but after reading that they didn't even pursue a long-term contract, I'm pretty annoyed. Possible home-town discount on a fan favorite with elite defense and solid hitting? GTFO MOAR PITCHERS
Homers and rbis tho!
Atlanta Braves: Win More Games Than The Hawks? Quote
11-18-2014 , 11:07 AM
GOD ****ING DAMMIT BRAVES I WILL KILL ALL OF YOU

https://twitter.com/Buster_ESPN/stat...18078886891520
@Buster_ESPN
The Braves have a meeting with Jon Lester this week.
Atlanta Braves: Win More Games Than The Hawks? Quote
11-18-2014 , 11:10 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by dabrian 2.0
why exactly couldn't they keep him? I understand the Braves don't have Yankee money bu t I think they can afford to lock him up at 15 mil a year for 5-6 years. BTW Lastella is gone to.
Really think it's closer to 20. But yeah we paid a 37 year old Hudson 15million lol (forgive me if my numbers are a bit off)
Atlanta Braves: Win More Games Than The Hawks? Quote
11-18-2014 , 11:44 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Benholio
Homers and rbis tho!
ok I get it, defense is important and I'm glad they quantify it

http://espn.go.com/blog/sweetspot/po...-mvp-candidate

you'd think with him and simmons we would have been contenders with their MVP level WARs. so what happened? BJ's LVP war offset all of that? He plays decent defense tho, doesnt he?

Last edited by JudgeHoldem; 11-18-2014 at 12:01 PM.
Atlanta Braves: Win More Games Than The Hawks? Quote
11-18-2014 , 12:17 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by mmbt0ne
GOD ****ING DAMMIT BRAVES I WILL KILL ALL OF YOU

https://twitter.com/Buster_ESPN/stat...18078886891520
@Buster_ESPN
The Braves have a meeting with Jon Lester this week.
haha I have no idea what's going on
Atlanta Braves: Win More Games Than The Hawks? Quote
11-18-2014 , 12:44 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by JudgeHoldem
ok I get it, defense is important and I'm glad they quantify it

http://espn.go.com/blog/sweetspot/po...-mvp-candidate

you'd think with him and simmons we would have been contenders with their MVP level WARs. so what happened? BJ's LVP war offset all of that? He plays decent defense tho, doesnt he?
BJ's defense is surprisingly bad.
Atlanta Braves: Win More Games Than The Hawks? Quote
11-18-2014 , 01:21 PM
BTW, thread clearly needs a new title.
Atlanta Braves: Win More Games Than The Hawks? Quote
11-18-2014 , 01:33 PM
The Braves need an individual owner to buy the team and start spending some ****ing money.
Atlanta Braves: Win More Games Than The Hawks? Quote
11-18-2014 , 01:34 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by JudgeHoldem
ok I get it, defense is important and I'm glad they quantify it

http://espn.go.com/blog/sweetspot/po...-mvp-candidate

you'd think with him and simmons we would have been contenders with their MVP level WARs. so what happened? BJ's LVP war offset all of that? He plays decent defense tho, doesnt he?
Simmons didn't have an MVP-level WAR. He had no bat at all to go with his glove, so his WAR was only 2.3.

Braves batters combined for 16.5 WAR, putting them 19th in the majors. Heyward accounted for 5.1 of that, or just over 30% of the total.
Atlanta Braves: Win More Games Than The Hawks? Quote
11-19-2014 , 09:07 AM
"Too: MY ATLANTA, GEORGIA

Braves fans, coaches, teammates, #BravesCountry
While it may not have worked out long term I'm very blessed to have played at HOME for the same Organization I was invested in as kid growing up in McDonough, Ga. Played for The Great Bobby Cox, said farewell to a first ballot Hall Of Famer Chipper Jones after an unbelievable career. I made many great friends and became as close as family with most. Thank you for that. Thank you for applauding my effort and passion for the game of baseball. Thank you for acknowledging my love for rockin The "A" on my work hat. Been a pleasure to have called HOME my workplace. As we part ways know that the memories will be carried with me for the rest. Reaching out to say that I won't forget where I'm from and you'll always see me playing the game I love with passion and heart. Knowing and appreciating the fact I had the pleasure of creating heartfelt memories with so many people the past 5 years. Thank you again for your heart, thank you for the motivation and excitement.

THANK YOU for the LOVE
22"
Atlanta Braves: Win More Games Than The Hawks? Quote
11-19-2014 , 10:00 AM
I thought time would heal some of this but I'm just getting madder.

How ****ing dare whoever is calling the shots these days do this.





Separately, Judge, it's like you aren't paying enough attention to comment on the value of different individual players' contributions to the team's success. Like you don't understand just how bad the offense from 3b, SS, 2b and CF really were last year in Atlanta. Just how much they crippled the team. It's like you think Heyward's offensive performance was only marginally better than, say, Chris Johnson's, rather than the orders of magnitude that it was. How often do you even look at OBP? Do you understand how much further the offense will implode when you remove one of the only guys on the team who doesn't kill offensive chances through giving away outs by the gross?

How do you think Heyward's offensive performance last year compared to the league aggregate?
Atlanta Braves: Win More Games Than The Hawks? Quote
11-19-2014 , 10:18 AM
From grantland

Of course, if he were perfect, the Braves would’ve kept him. Heyward has been an erratic hitter throughout his five-year career, with particularly big problems against lefties, who’ve limited him to a .221/.301/.349 line. And while his defense has been phenomenal by both statistical measures and the eye test, Heyward’s disappointing offensive numbers relative to expectations have made him a one-man argument for moving away from WAR as baseball’s go-to catch-all stat, since it rates him so favorably despite his limitations.
Atlanta Braves: Win More Games Than The Hawks? Quote
11-19-2014 , 10:26 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by grantland
Heyward’s disappointing offensive numbers relative to expectations have made him a one-man argument for moving away from WAR as baseball’s go-to catch-all stat, since it rates him so favorably despite his limitations.
That doesn't make a lick of sense.
Atlanta Braves: Win More Games Than The Hawks? Quote
11-19-2014 , 10:31 AM
JH - you are embarrassing yourself on the topic of JH.

Edit: just kidding.

Last edited by AngerPush; 11-19-2014 at 10:50 AM.
Atlanta Braves: Win More Games Than The Hawks? Quote
11-19-2014 , 10:45 AM
By reposting what grantland said?

The other thing I did was ask the question, how do we suck so bad with a MVP WAR candidate. Simmons WAR was 6+ in 2013. Seemed to have been answered by PocketChads above, that the rest of the team was just that more horrendous. OK, I'll buy that, but my gut still says JH's WAR isnt what it seems (personal opinion)
Atlanta Braves: Win More Games Than The Hawks? Quote
11-19-2014 , 02:40 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by JudgeHoldem
The other thing I did was ask the question, how do we suck so bad with a MVP WAR candidate. Simmons WAR was 6+ in 2013.
And in 2013 we didn't suck.
Atlanta Braves: Win More Games Than The Hawks? Quote
11-19-2014 , 02:55 PM
Nm
Atlanta Braves: Win More Games Than The Hawks? Quote
11-22-2014 , 06:22 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by JudgeHoldem
By reposting what grantland said?

The other thing I did was ask the question, how do we suck so bad with a MVP WAR candidate. Simmons WAR was 6+ in 2013. Seemed to have been answered by PocketChads above, that the rest of the team was just that more horrendous. OK, I'll buy that, but my gut still says JH's WAR isnt what it seems (personal opinion)
There's a decent argument that we really aren't anywhere close to as certain about defensive value as offensive, particularly for corner outfielders.

Still, you really can't overstate how much difference there is between league-bottom and league-solidly-above-average OBPs -- Chris Johnson's and Jason Heyward's.

The Billy Butler deal is pretty instructive on how valuable it is to have any one guy who is even like 65% to OBP what Heyward did last year in this post roid era, and Butler can't even field.
Atlanta Braves: Win More Games Than The Hawks? Quote

      
m