Quote:
Originally Posted by Thremp
Calling dibs on women is only acceptable in the most nub social circles, along with informing people of who you're actively sexing.
I don't think that's true, I think that in this case the sentiment you're reading from those who replied to the guy in question are giving a reasonably accurate representation of the majority of social circles, whether you feel it should be that way or not. Granted, I can't quantify this, but having been friends with so many different types of people, I get the feeling that most agree with the type of sentiment talked about above.
For the record, if this is just a girl that nobody amongst a circle of friends has hooked up with or whatever, I totally agree that there is no dibs. Two or more friends like a girl? Fine, everyone go after her, let the best man win.
So, again, not talking about situations like that. Dibs in a situation like that would be dumb. I'm just talking about when a friend has been in actual exclusive relationship with a girl and/or has clearly formed a deep emotional attachment with her.
Doing something that you know is very probable to hurt your friend, whether their hurt is rational or not, is always questionable, both from a standpoint of being a good friend and from a standpoint of maximizing your own utility.
And, depending on the social circle, if it's going to hurt your rep not only with this friend but with a decent chunk of your other friends, then...it'd better be worth it. To me, this would mean that you'd better think that the situation had good long-term relationship potential rather than just being a couple of hook-ups and done. I realize that your likely stance is that if something like this would hurt your rep in the eyes of a significant number of people in your social circle, that you should just get a new social circle...but I stand by my previous assertion that you really are dealing with a majority of the population who think this way.