There have been several poggers that were banned and are unlikely to ever come back. And those tend to be the ones who screwed up games.

MB may have been banned at his own request. I don't remember for sure. But it was not a POG ban.

Jenn was banned as much for being a nuisance to the mods as for anything else, so that's not really comparable to anything.

Several other people were "perma" banned mostly because they wanted it and not because they really did anything particularly awful -- McAvoy (the first time) and gder.

HiFi was unstable and needed a break and that ban was never intended to be permanent.

Who else was there? I'm pretty sure that no one was banned for game-related reasons and later allowed to return.

Damn. MB was an asset.

Prolly cuz you guys are the illest.

lol let the kid play, can't you see he was just missing you all.

Also lol at POG and murders comparison.

I feel like MB left because of me at least in part but I didn't do it on purpose!

Not post here ever again, would have no problem having the self-respect not to weasel my way back. Just posting this question and implying there's another reasonable option makes you an automatic weirdo in my eyes.

Tough spot to be honest. I could see this going either way. What are the current odds?

I'm counting outing yourself as a wolf in-thread under the general umbrella of non-participation.

Thread needs a (public) poll now, make it happen, wn.

edit: also rename to grievances thread 2.0

I could see from the response when I tried to come back after being banned that some people were always going to kick up a fuss and it was not going to happen.

At some point either before or after that I did contact Matt and he told me I had to take it up with the forum mods responsible.

Felt like I used all the possible options I could.

Still not saying it is right, just did not know what else to do.

He lobbied for himself to get made a mod, was passed over, and hasn't posted since.

His final post is 2 days after the new mods were picked, finishing up one of his games.

Have you been in a single game ruined by thediceman? I would like to think that speaks more than events that are over 2 years old.

I can promise you that your recollection is almost certainly pristine.

As I said I would tuck my tail between my legs and gtfo. Not going to play somewhere I wasn't wanted.

That you don't even consider "stay away" or "wait longer" as options to be considered is a sign that you really haven't changed much.

Sounds like he was pouring his heart and soul into the campaign and when it didn't work out he went off the deep end to me. God bless his heart.

What most people do when they get banned from 2+2 with no chance of being allowed back is do something else for a while and then get unbanned and come back.

Diceman, is your name a reference to the fact that your coming back while permabanned was a roll of the dice?

Like I said, in my opinion this is the best place to play, other sites range from not the worst to just terrible. That may be down to me preferring vanilla and vanilla+ games though.

Most of the people that actually play werewolf regularly are not posting in this thread.

You know is hard to stay away from werewolf?

Also

Yeah but what you did was deceiving and I could see where the ppl who were wronged by you are upset. Therefore whatever happens, happens. I would just listen to WN's advice if I were you.

we're trying to keep it that way

I did something else for a while and was not allowed back.

How long does it take people to let back someone who ruined games they were in? A year seemed to not even be close in some peoples opinion.

I like how we're all acting like discussing this means anything when the truth is we're just waiting for Moocher to show up and decide.

That seems unreasonable.