Ok wrt to this whole Mattchew thing:

Options are he's either the role he claims, a villa trying to confuse the wolves or he's a wolf. In all of these scenarios he isn't going to tell the truth about what he did last night or he's going to tell the truth in such a way that the wolves won't know it's the truth. If he wants to elaborate later on then so be it but rootling around at his claim is:



I think it's a lot more likely that what Matt is doing comes from a villa perspective and we should prolly leave it at that atm.

Im reading some old D1 stuff working on a theory, and came across this, which just feels so NOT J wolf with guild wolf. Same w/ Moocher and guild btw. Not that anyone was doubting that, really.

Wanna be thrown for a loop?






.....







I agree on this point.

Dils you had a hardon D1 for SJG. Where you at with that now?

MP, I'm reading that whole thing about dils being a wolf martyr and it looks like extreme tinfoil to me, I need to avail myself of vittles and tracklements before thinking on it further but it looks like you're going off the deep end imo.

I had a brief theory that maybe the DP/Guild counter was manufactured D1 and they just said they were against each other when in fact they barely posted. That was NOT true on my reread. I started building a case why DP could be a wolf with Guild, and to be honest, the reread shows the opposite. The below is probably a bunk post therefore, but Ill include it anyway for viewing pleasure.

This is DP's early post in response to Guilds J'accuse of DP. Guild literally makes the one post (his first post) about being DP and hasnt commented on him once more until this post.
Guild ignores the comment. Then this:

Make upsies.
Hm but DP does still go HAM.


Then back to insults after DP doesnt want to be friends.

sorry, I should have quoted it but I was replying to that.

Given guild was trying to bus tatter, I kinda doubt he did much other bussing this day.

Ya it's way more common for wolves to do it in our games but you and I almost exclusively play large mish-mashes with hidden rolesets where the wolf team will have day-angels that protect from the lynch, tough wolves with extra lives and even unlynchable wolves etc.

I thought his tone was pretty damn pure during EOD.

This interaction with DJarm is direct and makes me think not w/w

here he questions Luckboxs wolf reads. The only one of luckboxs wolf reads that is still alive? CDL.

I thought we were done with Guildspew

Dude, Moocher. Nailed it.

I have no idea at this point. I mostly scroll past his posts because too long, don't wanna read.

MP has gone way off the deep end.

At the end of yesterday, you were saying I was quite townie. Where are you on that now?

i was damn right about ''gamerdude (to a lesser extent)'' because his aggression has dropped off a cliff lately

@DP

Still think you were villagery but we have guys like you on this site and I always like them in my games* because they keep the action moving which means I can take my foot off the gas occasionally and observe how people react to those lightning rod players.

*i'm waaaaaay in the minority on that score tho

This is from a longer post of Matt's that I think is quite good but I literally laughed out loud reading this paragraph.

First reads back to thread.

What reads have you gotten off of my posts and others' responses to them?

The Dwetzel and Luckbox thing suggests to me that they are maybe not dichotomous like this.

i'm going back through everything now and will update when i'm done

Here Pres Eden (YG) pushes a bunch of people that I suspect are good.

I've only seen poisoner a couple of times. It was not announced by the GM. If the player was town, they would say that they were poisoned the previous night. If they weren't healed the next night, they were dead the following dawn. If scum were poisoned, they would keep quiet about it if they didn't think they would be targeted for healing and attempt to draw the lynch or be bussed.