phelampt, explain why you wouldn't want a vig to shoot if he was 40% sure he had found a wolf (and we assume that 40% is actually accurate).

although this seems fine

I definitely reserve the right to be wrong but for real for real think it

his tone is too composed or something.

I dont think this is worth pursuing yet even if you are right.

Yes, otherwise why would I be voting for one of them?

that's nice hon, please make this your last post about this subject for the day, thanks

and he seems to be picking at minutia which is wolfy in general

One of three things is going on here:

1) you're a wolf, or
2) you're an insane seer (time to check whether that's possible), or
3) you're reasonably paranoid after the vanilla game in which souls were crushed, but even that shouldn't justify you having more than a "guys, you shouldn't ever clear him light this early" read that I'd actually understand

and he is a better player than that I think

I will be a lot more active from Tuesday morning onwards, it's a bank holiday here. So I will get caught up in the morning.

Just what big-picture stuff do you think I should be thinking about 4 hours into the game, luckbox? I mean, sure it's no "free flowing tone" but I think when a guy disagrees with 5 people and agrees with one in a MQ, and then 10 minutes later votes the guy he agreed with while talking about other people, that's probably the most important thing that has happened so far.

do you actually think me posting once and disappearing for 25 minutes is wolfy?

Or did you just make your post for reactions?

please say it's the latter because that is the only acceptable response

++++++++++++++

while this is relevant information, i think its wolfy to ask this. who even noticed that they are from the same site?

when i first joined 2+2 i was a wolf my first game and i made a lot of posts like this, because then it gives me data i can easily base mislynches off of. you want to get people to give a list of traits someone has as a wolf/villager and then its pretty easy to nitpick a couple and be like oh this means he's gotta be a wolf - according to someone who knows him well! and then you have no accountability

if you're a villager i feel like that was a really weird detail to notice or maybe I'm just unobservant but i have no idea who here is from each others sites. and by page 5 theres a lot else to worry about. the only time id consider asking something like this is if someone was playing truly bizarre.

Alright I just want to say all this "this sounds villagery or this sounds wolfy" talk really annoys the **** out of me. Like take a firm stance. Either you think the person is wolf or you think their town. It's early in the game, you're aloud to be wrong and you're aloud to change your mind.

Everyone who's tip toeing is immediately thrown on my watch list.

Grow a pair guys, this is supposed to be Champions.

Explain the bolded plz?

I mean....I have no idea what level these guys are on or how they think

but i have a hard time even seeing how that is level 0 wolfy...maybe level 0 but not even .5 level wolfy.

You can't agree with wolves anymore?

Nick asked what I would be lynching based off of if not tone. I answered.

Exactly what it means. To win we don't just have to have a single player having good reads. We need to organise and form lynches. That requires compromise and teamwork.
I agree. I never said anything different. I just said, it's great to form your own reads, but listen to other people too. Like you said, we're all good players so we should all have sensible reads. Some we form on our own. Some may form through listening to others.

Cory said he wanted to POE early. I said this was ridiculous.

and you follow it up with this?

come on. this just means you couldn't find anything in the thread to talk about, so you resort to things outside the thread.




i gotta start a wolfy list because I'm gonna lose track:

-pres eden
-sjg
-dwetzel

village list:

-darth punk
-wwwwombat


these are just the people who have stood out a lot to me

Calling someone villagery or wolfy isn't tip-toeing around it's, y'know, people givind their reads.

This is a good thing.

Why?

I agree with Darth's posts on you, and the fact that you're reacting like this doesn't make me feel better about you.
If you're town, you need to work harder.

What is worth pursuing?

this post is made at 11:22 am ET and we have 2 whole days to make a lynch. no one is conspicuous by absence.

What post was this about?

apparently not. some guy earlier asked me which posts I liked or agreed with because those were supposed to be villagers.