Quote:
Originally Posted by Luckbox Inc
Why assume he was randomly selected?
I fully understand what you're saying of course...sometimes million to one shots do hit.
I'm not saying it's a million to one shot. I'm saying you're calculating the probability as a million to 1 shot after the fact.
Example: let's say the chances of whatever (friend, friend's son having a negative reaction to COVID) are 1000:1. Let's say he's selected out of 1000 people. You're calculating that as a million to 1.
I'm saying that's wrong. Chances of him being selected are 1000:1, yes, assuming selection is random. However, once selected, he could come up with one of any number of stories which are individually 1000:1. You can't then just take the two probabilities and multiply them after the fact. If there are 1000 possible such stories, then the chances of a randomly selected person in an audience of 1000 having one is about 1-1/e or 63% (that's the formula for the limit of hitting a 1 in n shot in n trials). Given the "eccentric" bunch that Trumpers are, there is a pretty good shot that a random one will say something amazingly stupid or that stretches the bounds of credulity (i.e. a "low probability story").
I'm not explaining this very well, but hopefully you get my gist.
Last edited by d2_e4; 06-21-2020 at 10:42 AM.