Quote:
Originally Posted by TiltedDonkey
The main problem on the left is that Fold'n thinks there is a problem on the left. This reasoning will break down if you assume that Fold'n is some kind of far right fringe lunatic (and I know that is a somewhat common view in this forum) but I don't believe that is the case. Fold'n probably represents someone approximately in the middle of the right-left political spectrum in America (think 35th to 65th percentile) and is of at least average intelligence.
Fold'n clearly believes that the left has become radical; that people we have never heard of or would consider radical ourselves have become "mainstream" on the left. To be clear, I think he's wrong. But the problem is that view is both common and sincere.
"Liberals caused Trump by being too mean and calling everyone and everything racist" has become a bit of a meme but I think conservatives are being a bit honest with us here. I mean, they are missing an important point which is, again, I think their perception of the left is wrong, but it is sincere.
Everyone (including me) points and laughs when Fold'n posts his YooToob about white genocide or whatever but his post speaks to a point that the alt-right has basically flooded platforms like YouTube with **** like this and I think pointing and laughing at Fold'n for being pulled in by YouTube is off base. His point (and I think Jiggy made a similar point in the Trump thread) that YouTube reaches a large audience is correct, and it is creating a branding problem that is going to make it much, much harder to reach "moderate republicans" in the future.
And the other problem is that many here are actually a part of that
radical left mindset, like Fly, et al, ie, who slurp down jugs of the critical theory, everything is about power, white privilege, no nuance accepted kool aid, and then there's a sort of slow gradient of those who only drink cups and sips, who will dismiss those posters as not important while simultaneously cheering them on and often seriously freaking out about the alt-right and nazis taking over the country, never, ever considering opening a link from one of the ever growing lists of suspected hate sites that will soon encompass half the internet (youtube is on the chopping block I see), and never acknowledging what a bubble they've created for themselves by doing this. And of course the same thing in reverse is prevalent in parts of the right, no doubt. There's a sort of protective wall put up in some factions, the iron law as previously described, that promotes a sort of self censorship not only of speech, but of thought, disallowing one tribe from interacting with the ideas of the others.
And then there is the shrinking middle, who look at all of this and wonder where it is leading, and where it's already taken us. I was actually surprised, and depressed when Well Named, someone who I thought was able to both understand the budding social justice theories of intersectionality, critical theory, etc, but also held a more rational and introspective view that was willing to engage criticism, then so quickly dismissed even viewing a video, presumably because it can be nothing but alt-right wing propaganda. Still nobody here is even willing to consider the idea it might be more than just that.
I mean, I can try to find a source that any of you might briefly consider is not simply propaganda to dispute Well Named's sadly incorrect claim that no serious civil rights activists "are attempting to justify their position on discrimination on the basis of their race." ,
like Vice, but it will be ignored. I can promise you David Pakman is nowhere near Alt Right, but after
viewing this video, you'll either add him to the list, or dismiss this evidence as anecdotal. Continued sources will be labeled gish gallup. Yall have a bevy of tools at your disposal to
enforce the iron law.
I'm happy to admit there is plenty of alt-right propaganda on youtube, but there is also plenty of valid criticism, and lots of stuff in between. You might consider it's just your walled off minds and the iron law leading you to believe it's just propaganda. Anyhow, I don't know how much more evidence you guys need that identity politics is a dangerous game that leads to tribalism, and that tribalism is not a friend to the causes many of you champion.