Quote:
Originally Posted by callipygian
Rules question: dealer doesn't move the button, I post BB twice in a row but notice it just as he finishes dealing.
"Wait," I say, "I was the BB last hand. I should be the SB."
SB agrees.
"Oh, ****, you're right," dealer agrees, and he now stops the action.
Two people have now folded, one raised, and a coldcall.
1. Hand is a misdeal even with the action?
2. Hand would have been a misdeal without the raise, but is no longer since the raise occured?
3. Hand would have been a misdeal without the folds, but is no longer a misdeal since people acted?
4. Hand would have been a misdeal only if dealing hadn't finished yet?
On top of this, does it matter when I started objecting (i.e., when I first opened my mouth, dealer had just pitched the last card, but EP may have folded already) or is it only when the dealer calls for action to stop (after raise before coldcall), or does it only matter when action does stop?
This happened to me twice in 3 hours on Tuesday at Oaks 15/30.
First scenario I was asked to post the big blind by the dealer twice during the rotation of the dealing and I never posted chips, half paying attention while talking to a player to my right.
The player to my right posted his small blind and once he realized that the he had posted his small blind last hand, there had been a raise and a call.
After the dealer was unnecessarily rude about the situation, the floor was called and it was ruled that the house would "make the pot right" with house money and pay for my big blind, while small blind was forced to pay again.
Pretty wacky ruling.