Quote:
Originally Posted by Renton555
And your insanely optimistic 8:1 fat loss ratio is just as arbitrary as my 15lb..
I'm not really trying to be defensive. I'm trying to be objective about it and will grant you that you were dead on, on your bf% estimates. And you're right my goal I'm happy with is probably somewhere around 20% though maybe 18% is "ideal". But in either case that would leave me clearly in the high 170s-low 180s.
But the 8 to 1 thing I didn't just pull out of thin air. It's not arbitrary at all.
My drop from 202 to 193 I lost .5lbs of lean mass.
So I would say it's very fair and reasonable to think that an avg of 1lb lean mass loss from 193 to 183 and then again from 183 to 173 would be pretty accurate if not even on the slightly conservative side.
But for some reason you think that's an insane assumption? Care to share the reason why? I might seem snippy because you're falling into the same logic Loco did. "I can't do X so no one can. When I lose weight, this happens to me or I can no longer do X so that must be true for everyone." Remember how he was making fun of me saying I have no clue how to lose weight and I desperately need his help to accelerate things and I would lose all my strength?
It's funny how something is completely insane and impossible and then when I actually do it irl then all of a sudden there are other reasons why that weren't there before and goal posts moved.