Quote:
Originally Posted by JohnnyFondue
Ok, I'm interested. I think someone weak like me can go hard for a long time before becoming over-trained.
Why do you think that? Is it because you're not really "going hard"?
Quote:
Originally Posted by JohnnyFondue
But I think someone like you has to balance the heavy lifting a lot more carefully.
So you think our CNS can tell the difference between me pulling 700 and you pulling 400?
Quote:
Originally Posted by JohnnyFondue
I mean, if I DL 95% of my '1RM' for reps every week, I have a feeling I could keep that pace up for a long time.
Then, firstly, I suspect you're not DLing your true 95% for reps. And I'm less talking about once a week, and more talking multiple times per week. If you'd have said the latter, then I would say no, you can't keep that up regardless of training age or strength level.
Quote:
Originally Posted by JohnnyFondue
Can you keep up that pace? Seems like the weights that you lift are just wayyy more taxing on your body.
While I do agree that larger more muscular people need increased recovery, I suspect that me lifting/taxing my body at 100% is the same as you lifting and taxing your body at 100%, we're just using different weight to achieve that.
I don't think you're confused, but I'm of the opinion that if you are say...squatting, 3x per week, then two of your squatting sessions probably suck and probably aren't providing much benefit outside of form check or whatever.
Anecdotally, my training partner from 2007-2009 started out a complete novice. He was 160lbs body weight, former high school cross county runner, and had never lifted in his life. In the two years we lifted together he did exactly what i did as far as exercises, sets, reps, no more, no less. That meant squatting and pulling at a maximum once per week, and usually just twice a month. In that time frame he went from 160lbs to 230lbs bodyweight, his deadlift went from 275 to 505, and his front squat from pathetic to 405. I couldn't even count how many times he puked during training, and I couldn't count how many times he would talk about stumbling around or his legs giving out while walking around after squatting. I remember him texting me once saying that he fell down in this kitchen and was stuck on the floor after squatting. Do I think he could have squatted 3x per week during that time? No, not the way we were squatting. Do I think he could have made more progress another way? Maybe. The one thing he didn't do, however, was miss a training session in that time frame and he never stopped lifting until he had given 100%+, and I made sure it was really 100%+.
Lifting and getting big and strong is so simple.