I personally don't mind much since I got seer again anyway.

By the way, this is WHY Birdman is such a good werewolf player. He is EXTREMELY hard to vote off in any role because he just doesn't stop. He lets nothing go. He litigates everything until his accusers just throw up their hands.

I let him do it to me once and we handed him the game. I can be just as stubborn, but unfortunately I can't be in the thread all day. If we're going to get him, villagers who think he IS wolfing need to be resolved and determined.

If we aren't going him, I'll look around for another vote, but I need to make lunch first.

"If I'm wrong about one of them, it's almost certainly Dustin"

I read this as, if I'm wrong about wrong, the wolf is almost certainly Dustin still.

I read her followup as her thinking out loud of more reasons Dustin might be a wolf.

I changed my mind when you pointed out I was wrong about the first post

These are definitely a good time, I like almost all the regulars who play these now. Definitely hasn't always been the case.

Cross is like that but she also has a way of being strangely villagery. I think what you're referring to is NAI though.

Salient point by bsball.

Esooa is hereby downgraded to Wonder Bread.

ya this is basically why mets was so good a long time ago

he made it so lunching him was such a chore that no one ever wanted to do it

and it's definitely a compliment - but also speaks to how just putting in effort makes you good at this game

[QUOTE=Esooa;57154493]"If I'm wrong about one of them, it's almost certainly Dustin"

I read this as, if I'm wrong about wrong, the wolf is almost certainly Dustin still.
/QUOTE]

"if I'm wrong about wrong" can you elaborate what you mean by this?

[QUOTE=bsball8806;57154501] lmao oops

"If I'm wrong about one, the wolf is almost certainly still Dustin"

Is what I tried to say

Rofl.

Okay, I can see how that phrasing was ambivalent.

Esooa, you are now sourdough bread. And I'm hungry. Back in a bit.

this is gaslighting

you were wrong and it was YOUR choice to argue about it instead of just saying "yeah I was wrong"

this is what I mean about how admitting you are wrong is so much easier and less stressful than what you did

after 100 posts of arguing you finally admitted you were wrong

don't act like it is my fault

I'm sure the food analogies are helping

ok you just compared me to mets

i'm done

gl everyone

[QUOTE=Esooa;57154504] I don't think anyone talks like this but I can't really make the argument that you didn't read it that way because I'm not you

But from a semantics/linguistics point of view I'm having a hard time seeing someone phrase a sentence like

"if i'm incorrect about [fact A and fact B], [fact A is the correct one]"

people almost always say

"if i'm incorrect about [fact A and fact B], then [explanation about why fact B is wrong]"

and i think because of that, people's reading comprehension usually follows that same pattern

and i know this is well into things no one cares about but i'm having a hard time getting past it. maybe i should take my own advice and move on.

i mean it is what any good ww wolf does

makes it hard to lunch them

i did it back when i was good, you do it now

you can't seriously claim you aren't aware of this

[QUOTE=bsball8806;57154519] the way I see it

"It's almost certainly Dusin"

Tells me, the wolf is Dustin

Usually imo in phrases like this, the person who "it is" is the wolf

It's probably dumb to read it like that. But that's what u get

fair enough, i'm noting it and moving on

I actually remember this game LOL! I think that was the big Pixar game. Wow, seems like ages ago. Sorry for being so jerky back then

I don't think that's a fair characterization of my posting, but I'll let the village decide.

Votes from post 7 to post 445
Night in 4:59:57
---

Votes	Lynch	Voters
4	Birdman10687	aaronk56 (7), Esooa (98), VoraciousReader (33), Crossnerd (7)
1	Montecore	Doctor Zeus (31)
1	iraisetoomuch	ShipItUp (42)
1	Esooa	Birdman10687 (83)
1	aaronk56	filthyvermin (12)
4	not voting	iraisetoomuch (20), Kawamii (0), Luckbox Inc (50), Montecore (0)
1	Error	bsball8806 (48)

To quote MY octopus teacher,

Omg yes it was 100% the pixar game, that was such a fun one, I liked how all the character roles were randed and the characters that randed wolf were given an evil spin in their flavor.

Also no need to apologize, relative to a lot of people that posted back then you were a saint lol.

Just to beat this horse dead-- it's all about what the referent "it" is referring to.

"If X (A or B) then it's Y", then "it" there should likely just refer back to what X is-- which was "if I'm wrong about one of them", and not some extra-contextual considerations that are hard for me to grasp too.
Almost certainly NAI though.

I actually legitimately don't understand that post by Birdman upon reflection. I admit I hate to be wrong. But I didn't think I was wrong here and just refuse to admit it. I didn't think I was wrong. I still don't.