Yeah I'm not avout to vote for you.

But earlier today you were my most clear player and I'm dialling that back.

The world's worst case of confirmation bias?

If nothing else, if I really do call you a wolf day 1 every game, maybe you should adopt it as a villager tell.

Because I promise, I would never target you day 1 as a wolf. Executing you is too much work. (That's a compliment.)

VR's followup post wasn't a change of mind that Dustin was more wolfy. It was a thought. That is my interpretation now at least

You’d have been honorary, babe

just in case my random bolding of stuff has messed up the vc

esooa

this is getting so deep into layers of "he said she said he said she said he said she said" that it is hurting my brain and is definitely not worth discussing any more

i am almost positive it's just a flaw of text based communication between two people not trying to fool the other, though. so i will politely bow out of this conversation and keep my villager reads on both of you

Let those two work out each other's roles. Just because you think both are villa doesn't mean you're right. If they think there's value still to be had from their conversation I'll trust their judgement on it.

that's fine. I'm just a little annoyed re:comments like SIU saying I'm in "commentary mode" or whatever on the same page I wrote pretty clearly why I thought Birdman was a wolf, which received ~no comments from the people town reading him btw, and had also been asking people about that

On catch up this whole VR-Birdman-Essoa-BSball is so hard to catch up on because no one seems to be on the same page.

As likely as it is that its a bunch of villagers attacking each other, I think its much more likely there's at least 1 wolf in there with an agenda

I am still not sure where you are getting this impression that I have a strong wolf read on you.

Correct.

it's really much simpler and straightforward than this but whatever

VR clearly said I was omgussing her, I said that is not supported by the facts

and that's it

It sounded nice to be able to have you as a strong town I can base my game slightly around considering you know people a lot more than me and seem to also know what you're doing

I'm not really here rn to try and say "these are people's alignments and here's why;" not entirely at least. I like to push things around too.

"Pockety"

I randed seer so I feel you're pain lol.

I still remember you owning me in an anniversary game as a wolf, you were on a team with Binkles. I had a vig and was going to shoot you and you basically punked me out of it and then stayed alive until the end and won. One of the only games I distinctly remember from that time period because of how hard you and binkles wrecked me.

Also

I think moving on from the Birdman stuff does sound good tbh

I feel like we are speaking different languages here. You continue to quote my posts and say I've said things that I didn't say.

I just don't have an explanation for it other than you being a wolf.

I've disliked that crossnerd seems to be catching up but is primarily quoting posts with the intention to talk about non-game related things. I think it's wolfy.

I don't always equate different with wolfy, just felt it was worth noting.

I love this 13er crew that we have now btw especially getting to know some of the newer players like Zeus and now Esooa-- it's been a lot of fun.
Only person in this lineup that I still am sort of clueless on reading is Kami but I can get there.

you being wrong and then refusing to admit it is NAI

so me showing that is not me calling you a wolf

at the time I was asked I gave your name as a 'gun to my head' barely anything to go on read

which is why I didn't vote you and also "nexted" (as you said) to something actually useful

oh yeah I said this in wolf chat before we left

"6 word most sad story meme:

I NEED TO RERAND THIS GAME, APOLOGIES"

The issue with this for me, and it will be hard to put into words, is that if you understood her follow-up post about dustin being potentially being wolfier than birdman, it would be really hard for you to have misinterpreted her first post.

Your stated interpretation of this is that "if there's a more likely wolf in this bunch, it's dustin" - which would mean that the way you're reading this post is either

1. "i think they're both villagers, but if i'm wrong about on one, it's dustin"

or

2. you literally misread "dustin" and replaced him with birdman in your head

we know it's not #2, because when I called you out on it earlier, you didn't seem to understand my point, which you would have if it was literally a mix-up of names in your mind. so i think it has to be #1 for it to make any logical sense for you.

The issue is that we know clearly you didn't actually think VR made a post saying "Dustin and birdman are both villagers" because the entirety of the thread has been about VR thinking might both be wolves. Which kind of makes me think that you were making up your "mix-up" and thus makes me question whether you're making reads at all, or are instead just talking about posts and hoping no one catches on to your fake reads.