here is his most recent post which also happens to be villagery. You can probably read backwards and find some more.

I'm not actually saying he's not a wolf I'm saying if someone in that group isn't one its probably him. And we have to remember its actually ivers not willi as well as who knows why people do what they do.

Confirmed lurking and not reading?

So I've left my thoughts over and over about the game and possible wolf teams.


I think CDL and SOah are connected in a way. I think Latvian Willi made a weird response in saying "I think IHCJay is the villa here." I think that connects him and Willi.



Something I noticed - Soah kept pushing Jay all day and as soon as Well Named swooped in and caleld him a likely villager Soah immediately droppped it and said "Yeah thats what I'm starting ot figure out" as if he realized its no longer acceptable to push Jay for being wolfy.


Combine that with the AIDS observation Soah just made. Its like he is now trying to buddy up to Jay since pushign him as a wolf is no longer acceptable so he jumps on Jay's posts about me. The guy who supposedly has written multiple lengthy articles on teh strategy of finding wolves is willing to say "Redd is lurking in a wolfy manner" or whatever as the most simplistic observation you can make.

2 + 2 isnt making 4 with Soah.

I've only played one game with you that I can even remember. What do you mean you've never known me as a type who has never shared my thoughts?

We dont really even know each other at all. Unless you want to claim you've read multiple games of mine which I can accept but thats an odd statement considering I'm not really familiar with you at all other than your condescending posts in this game and the first posts I played with you

Jay

I'm on the brink of going full Boiler on you. If you are a villager can you do me a favor?

will you please STFU? THank you

Here's another person making blatantly false statements about my posting in order to attack me.

I can't take all this negativity! We're here to have fun aghhasrdhpuasdhg

This is a really week response. You just said it would be more difficult to find a wolfy post from Soah than a villagery one. You should have at least 5 in mind that you remember thinking "whoa; this dudes a villager!" since you have such a strong villa lean on Soah.

And the best you can do is quote me his most recent post, which I think looks bad because it's an opportunistic jab and reductionist argument.

Soah is implying that lurking and responding to criticism is inherently wolfy -- while ignoring the fact that Redd stated he wanted to maintain his available post count, something YOU more than anyone cannot argue is wolfy.

So why do you agree with it? Why do you like that post? What's villagery about it? And why can you not find me any more but just tell me to "read the thread" which is a standard wolf go-to response to questioning? (One that Soah has used, btw).

Soah is a wolf and Jay is a villager

Soah just piggybacked Jay's observation on me to make himself look better in Jay's eyes.


That is exactly waht just happened. I dont know how to prove this but this is what is happening to me

also, there is literally only one other person in this game that has been agreeing with me at all about jay being wolfy, so a huge LOL at the notion that one post suddenly clued me into the fact that other people have been defending jay for like... the entire game

it would be impossible to stop attacking jay at any point in this game without it coming at some point relatively recently after someone else had posted something to the effect of not having jay as a wolf


oh, I see there is another new post -- funny that you can question how I can be familiar with your typical posting and claim we don't hardly know each other at all, yet just a couple of posts ago you were quite confident that I'm absolutely terrible at werewolf. Wouldn't that imply that you know something about me?

Soah I dont like the way you play. You have a level or arrogance that is unwarranted and your posts reek of condescension - as if everyone is beneath you and not worth your time to answer their questions.

I dont care how many ****ing strategy posts you've made, playing WW with that attitude has to be the most miserable way to play ever and I dont see how someone can get that much enjoyment out of being this negative all the time.

I dont think lurking is wolfy. I do it all the time as a villager. I never said it was.

I don't have any specific posts in mind, but I have read probably half his posts and thought "that is villagery" and very few and thought "hmmm...he might be a wolf" over the past 3 days.

LOL That doesnt make any sense. I dont need to be familiar with you to tell you your reads are either AIDS or wolf driven.

I'm just going to troll you every time you mention me in a post.


I'm working on a new #WhiteMagic strategy post, leave yoru email in my inbox and I'll be sure and send it to you when I'm finished.

I see it too. Hence my comment on the opportunistic jab.

Soah's primary offensive strategy: reduction to defeat a straw man and trying to point out holes in other people's arguments (and asserting that flaw is inherently wolfy) rather than making his own. He's letting people trip on their own laces instead of boxing them out.

Soah's primary defensive strategy: sarcasm, condescension and hypocrisy -- with a smattering of ridiculously black and white "wolves never do that."

Soah is making himself into an obvious wolf. There's so little chance of him just being an obtuse and useless villager that he has to be a wolf. He should be far more interested in seeking out his own solves rather than toying with consensus and spreading paranoia.

LOLSoah

WHY DO YOU THINK THAT POST YOU QUOTED FROM SOAH IS VILLAGERY IF YOU DISAGREE WITH ITS ENTIRE PREMISE?

WTF

Stop dodging my questions.

CDL since I'm a wolf to you which of these best describe me this game?




These



This


This


Because that must be what you think of my wolf game here.

lol at me dodging the question. I think that soah explaining his thought concisely and in a manner that seems natural for him as a villager (over like 5 years of playing WW with him) is a villagery trait.

In before CDL is confused.

i dont even know what that post is or what its supposed to mean

SO well Named comes in and tells Soah that Jay is likely a villager. Soah immediately concedes that Jay is likely a villager and a conclusion he's made too.


LOLwhat?

So Soah - were you just trolling Jay today or what? All those posts you made with Jay was just you wasting posts because you had already concluded Jay was a villager?

OMG too perfect


It means I must have giant wolf balls to go after you and then Soah and then cast suspicion on Redd in the way I have.

I remember reading that sequence of posts and thinkign it was odd but it never fully dawned on me until what just happened where Soah took the opportunity to jump on a push Jay was making. Its like he is trying to get back in good with Jay after he's been trying to get him lynched and he was shut down.

Wolves:

Soah the Boah
CDL

Votes from post 997 to post 1524
Night in 6:00:57
---

Votes	Lynch	Voters
4	soah	Top Tier Tom (78), ReddBoiler (60), Latvian Willi (15), Perdition (14)
2	Hero Value	ihcjay (79), soah (73)
2	Latvian Willi	CalledDownLight (49), bhuber2010 (58)
1	Top Tier Tom	well named (46)
1	bhuber2010	XXsooted (30)
1	not voting	Hero Value (11)