Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
October 8th Game Thread October 8th Game Thread

10-11-2009 , 12:25 AM
So I was playing GH2 some more trying to FC ****ing sweet child of mine while missing the hard part of the song another 30 times, while distracted about thinking about this game.

For a while back when I used to play a lack of posting by me was just a sign I didn't really care about the game. But that didn't really feel right for this game. When I signed up I decided I wouldn't join unless I cared, but I still am not really posting much.

Then I came to the conclusion that my thought process this game more closely relates to my absolute very first few long games. I really didn't have anything to say because I was lost. It wasn't until Average Speed 4 I finally decided I had a hand on people and was able to speak out on reads. Of course by then it was out of character for me and I was quickly lynched. So it goes.

The point here is I really had to get to know the people before I had anything to say, and quite frankly I don't know any of you. Nope I don't even think I know dmk. Even though I suspect he is in the exact same boat as me right now.

I was really only good at two reads, detecting changes from someone from one game to the next, and putting together the big picture at the very end. Thus not playing for a while makes me completely useless on the first read, and it seems too early for read 2.

So the question is how do I become useful? The answer is to put more faith, in reads I have no faith in. As such I have grabbed a beer, put on Who's Next and will read through this thread now, because I am not sure when I will next have a chance to. I have absolutely no plans to be around for EOD on Monday or Sunday, which kind of sucks in terms of this game. I will go under the assumption Smaug is wolf since he has given the classic quick little "I'm really a wolf, but I am going to pretend I wasn't peeked just for show" argument.
October 8th Game Thread Quote
10-11-2009 , 01:20 AM
Alright the only seer cover I left was peeking atak n0. I meant to leave something day 1 but didn't, which could also be construed as me peeking McAvoy.

Alright read through. I want some answers of my own before I give what I think.

Hitch-What were your fake peeks? Was I right?

Someone who knows OTI-Does he enjoy being a wolf?
October 8th Game Thread Quote
10-11-2009 , 02:07 AM
i would say there is almost no chance bsball didnt leave peeks so anyone not wanting to lynch bb today will have to point me to what they think was the n1 peek.
October 8th Game Thread Quote
10-11-2009 , 02:09 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by wahoopride
i would say there is almost no chance bsball didnt leave peeks so anyone not wanting to lynch bb today will have to point me to what they think was the n1 peek.
Who is trying not to lynch smaug?
October 8th Game Thread Quote
10-11-2009 , 02:11 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by semper fidelis
also i don't like the discussion nor the reasons why people are voting how they are
Quote:
Originally Posted by semper fidelis
wahoo
is irony the right word here?
October 8th Game Thread Quote
10-11-2009 , 02:11 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by chuckleslovakian
Who is trying not to lynch smaug?
semper and hitch have voted for other people.
October 8th Game Thread Quote
10-11-2009 , 02:12 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by wahoopride
semper and hitch have voted for other people.
Yeah I also said I was drinking. This is why I should look up at the thread before posting.
October 8th Game Thread Quote
10-11-2009 , 02:13 AM
ya i played poker at my friends tonight rather than drinking heavily. no worries.
October 8th Game Thread Quote
10-11-2009 , 02:14 AM
since you are drinking...any stories you want to tell us? maybe about your role?
October 8th Game Thread Quote
10-11-2009 , 02:15 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by wahoopride
since you are drinking...any stories you want to tell us? maybe about your role?
It is still villager. I am playing bridge with FCBLcomish at the moment...hmm stories. I could probably go for a beer.
October 8th Game Thread Quote
10-11-2009 , 02:16 AM
let FCBL post on your account, he is easier to read
October 8th Game Thread Quote
10-11-2009 , 02:20 AM
That is actually kind of tempting. Sounds like a crazy idea for a role in a mishmash game.
October 8th Game Thread Quote
10-11-2009 , 02:26 AM
i hope i get a mod's account for that
October 8th Game Thread Quote
10-11-2009 , 08:19 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by chuckleslovakian
Alright the only seer cover I left was peeking atak n0. I meant to leave something day 1 but didn't, which could also be construed as me peeking McAvoy.

Alright read through. I want some answers of my own before I give what I think.

Hitch-What were your fake peeks? Was I right?

Someone who knows OTI-Does he enjoy being a wolf?
Yes I enjoy wolfing
October 8th Game Thread Quote
10-11-2009 , 10:19 AM
let me substantiate my vote:

first and foremost, i do not believe that smog is the wolf peek for a fact
i find it very wolfy on chuckles/elliot/wahoo's part that they are clearly overlooking evidence that challenges their votes

if you look at bsball's posts:
there are three possible wolf peeks:

Quote:
Originally Posted by bsball8806
are you a wolf
wahoo

Quote:
Originally Posted by bsball8806
also I take responsibility for the zomg wagon yesterday. I really thought he was a wolf. Who started the wagon on him though, semper? I haven't seen a post of his that long in a while. He could be a wolf
myself

Quote:
Originally Posted by bsball8806
and bitchibee/smaug goes back into the wolf cave
and mr smog

however, i have seen no discussion on myself or wahoo being the possible peek and instead, people cherry-picking posts and voting

keeping this in mind, look at this sequence:

Quote:
Originally Posted by wahoopride
agree on chuckles but we should prob lynch the wolf peek
Quote:
Originally Posted by Hitch
wtf is the wol peek?
Quote:
Originally Posted by wahoopride
really?
wahoo's audience is the village saying "we should prob lynch the wolf peek"
and again insinuating the wolf peek is obvious

wolf comfortable with the situation

Quote:
Originally Posted by wahoopride
he peeked you wolf
bsball is too scared of being blamed for stuff not to leave peeks
he wasnt even very subtle about it

but good try
i like when people fight to the death
emphasis on smog is the wolf peek
condescending at the end

Quote:
Originally Posted by chuckleslovakian
Who is trying not to lynch smaug?
again, comfortable with going with the general consensus without mention of the other possibilities

Quote:
Originally Posted by wahoopride
semper and hitch have voted for other people.
soft attack myself/hitch


here's the actual reason why i think mr smog is not the wolf peek

Quote:
Originally Posted by bsball8806
bitchibee you were a wolf in that game

how is that supposed to convince me you are a villager here
bsball's read: wolf

Quote:
Originally Posted by bsball8806
I can agree with this



I haven't played very many long games with you before, but this is something I haven't seen before: a long, drawn out response to something that wasn't a lock case. That plus your vote for zomg at 9:57.

the problem was OTI sticks on you all day long so I now have to figure out if you guys are w/w or just w/v
bsball's read: uncertain


Quote:
Originally Posted by bsball8806
and bitchibee/smaug goes back into the wolf cave
bsball's read: wolf
but notice the word choice, she says 'goes back into the wolf cave'
which means that her read had changed before making the post
that would be a read, not a peek

the argument oti had was:
"bsball was treating smog like a wolf the entire day"

this is true, however, if you put in perspective of: what if birdman was still alive and not lynched? and bsball died that night, we would be voting out birdman because of her constant reference to him
October 8th Game Thread Quote
10-11-2009 , 10:30 AM
these posts are from the northern expedition thread
where wahoo was a wolf and i was a villager

Quote:
Originally Posted by wahoopride
i reread semper and i think i see where soah is going
parroting soah, this was a double standard, [i was the easiest prey because soah was after me, however its risky as well]

Quote:
Originally Posted by wahoopride
semper is acting as though he knows certain people are villagers rather than just saying that their wolfiness does not mean anything
Quote:
Originally Posted by wahoopride
good to know i was right
Quote:
Originally Posted by wahoopride
i remember there was a post about G1982 being wolfy all the time, which would mean him being wolfy is a null tell. the way semper worded it made me think he was making it a villa tell on G and it read to me like he knew G was a villa
when i was a wagon in northern expedition, all he did was act obsessive and constantly referred to me and my wolfiness

Quote:
Originally Posted by wahoopride
i believe he is saying only another noob would think he is a wolf?

it almost makes sense but he really should discover punctuation
Quote:
Originally Posted by wahoopride
i said it almost makes sense, which is just a polite way of saying it does not really make sense
condescending

i cross-reference wahoo's posts from this game to last game and he is doing the same thing. when smog is rebuting the case on him, he says: "good try, i like when people fight" which makes me think of his post in northern expedition where he said "good to know i was right" which is condescending and shows him being comfortable. wahoo is constantly obsessing over smog being lynched which is more of a wolf with an agenda
October 8th Game Thread Quote
10-11-2009 , 10:41 AM
looking back, i think i need to explain why i think acting comfortable is relevant to why someone is a wolf

if we mislynch today, it is must-lynch next time
people acting lackadaisical and not even trying to reassess what's happened so far in the game are either stupid or wolves
October 8th Game Thread Quote
10-11-2009 , 01:32 PM
Through 493:

[0] atakdog
[1] bitchibee
[1] chuckleslovakian
[0] dmk
[0] ElliotR voted for bitchibee
[0] Hitch voted for chuckleslovakian
[0] OnThInIcE911
[0] semper fidelis voted for wahoopride
[1] wahoopride


NIGHT IN 8hrs 30 min

Last edited by gtpitch; 10-11-2009 at 01:32 PM. Reason: bump
October 8th Game Thread Quote
10-11-2009 , 04:38 PM
om nom nom
October 8th Game Thread Quote
10-11-2009 , 04:42 PM
how in the world would "are you a wolf?" be a peek

you can't possibly think he makes the post where he says i cant read wahoo so i will leave that to you guys if he has peeked me wolf.

i don't understand why you seem to try to be twisting bsball's words
October 8th Game Thread Quote
10-11-2009 , 04:48 PM
Smaug The real game begins tomorrow
October 8th Game Thread Quote
10-11-2009 , 04:49 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by bsball8806
and bitchibee/smaug goes back into the wolf cave
imo you guys are reading this wrong.

bsball is referring to the fact that bb hadnt posted in a little while. i dont think bsball ever retracts his peek
October 8th Game Thread Quote
10-11-2009 , 04:51 PM
and bitchibee/smaug goes back into the wolf cave
October 8th Game Thread Quote
10-11-2009 , 04:54 PM
heh, its almost futile, but I just have that little feeling at the back of my neck that you were peeked wolf yesterday wahoo

The whole "I can never read you", "are you a wolf" when you voted me - you see once you voted me he became uncertain about my role.

you never responded to bsball questions - looks like he was trying to leave something inconspicuous - and of course you never answered because at this point you knew you were peeked amiright? I mean you know bsball all too well.

This must be just a feather in your cap huh, getting me lynched after killing the seer who peeked you wolf.
October 8th Game Thread Quote

      
m