Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Objectively judging the best ww players Objectively judging the best ww players

08-29-2014 , 03:13 PM
Already booting up the next werewoalf draft
Objectively judging the best ww players Quote
08-29-2014 , 03:29 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Hurp Durpington
Already booting up the next werewoalf draft
new rule this time

drafters must play at least 5 games in the year of the draft. turbos not included.
Objectively judging the best ww players Quote
08-29-2014 , 03:56 PM
Or just do a turbo draft
Objectively judging the best ww players Quote
08-29-2014 , 03:56 PM
why have we not done that?
Objectively judging the best ww players Quote
08-29-2014 , 07:06 PM


3 captains draft 3 teams of 9 and we play 3 simultaneous turbos
Objectively judging the best ww players Quote
08-29-2014 , 07:09 PM
Would be down to captain
Objectively judging the best ww players Quote
08-29-2014 , 07:10 PM
in to draft
1. younguns87
2.
3.

in to play
1. Sun Tzu
Objectively judging the best ww players Quote
08-29-2014 , 07:11 PM
Seems tough to draft the best and convince them all to play though.
Objectively judging the best ww players Quote
08-29-2014 , 07:27 PM
like all ww game drafts, you're not drafting the best of all time, just the best of those playing
Objectively judging the best ww players Quote
08-29-2014 , 07:34 PM
this would be a fun rail. fill it up!
Objectively judging the best ww players Quote
08-29-2014 , 08:33 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Aksdal
RankNameLynched as Villager %NK % NK/lynch
1Chips Ahoy0%68% undefined
2traz0%69% undefined
3JimHalpert3%43% 14.79
4rebonkulous4%57% 13.14
5metsandfinsfan10%55% 5.55
6Monkey Banana11%43% 4.01
7wdcbooks12%46% 3.76
8MDoranD14%50% 3.68
9derm11%37% 3.50
10Luckbox Inc16%55% 3.50
11Swiitch14%48% 3.33
12karnelchik15%45% 3.00
13well named16%46% 2.92
14atakdog16%42% 2.60
15vixticator19%49% 2.58
16captain binkles22%56% 2.57
17soah22%56% 2.55
18Zurvan19%48% 2.51
19Montecore13%33% 2.50
20OnThInIcE91117%42% 2.50
21Larry Legend15%35% 2.33
22CPHoya20%46% 2.33
23bsball880616%37% 2.33
24shortline9925%56% 2.25
25MrGatito17%38% 2.25
26LKJ24%52% 2.20
27aao22%46% 2.13
28XXsooted19%40% 2.11
29Andynan17%33% 1.99
30Sun Tzu20%38% 1.94
31VarianceMinefield21%41% 1.89
32Felix the Cat24%43% 1.80
33VoraciousReader24%43% 1.80
34FCBLComish28%50% 1.80
35Crossnerd18%32% 1.75
36HerbieGRD26%44% 1.71
37Aksdal29%48% 1.67
38dmk22%35% 1.63
39DonkDonkDonkDonk27%42% 1.57
40derwipok25%39% 1.57
41Nez47724%35% 1.50
42ScottHoward30%44% 1.50
43chuckleslovakian23%35% 1.50
44Nicholasp2728%41% 1.47
45younguns8716%21% 1.34
46Forsythio25%33% 1.33
47bhuber201018%24% 1.33
48fnord_too29%35% 1.20
49ShipItUp31%38% 1.20
50magic_gazz26%30% 1.16
51UAW71025%28% 1.16
52globetrotter32%35% 1.08
53Birdman1068737%40% 1.08
54hardcoreUFO30%30% 1.00
55ZomgHax26%26% 1.00
56McAvoy33%33% 1.00
57BitchiBee38%38% 1.00
58chrisrjdk32%32% 1.00
59LuckayLuck36%35% 0.95
60wahoopride32%27% 0.86
61Anarchist38%31% 0.81
62CalledDownLight25%20% 0.80
63gtpitch31%24% 0.78
64ElliotR44%32% 0.73
65Duckburg50%36% 0.73
66TimeLady33%24% 0.71
67kyro33%24% 0.71
68xxaceshigh77xx30%22% 0.71
69Toganim50%35% 0.70
70sixfour39%26% 0.67
71J.D.39%25% 0.64
72tappokone44%26% 0.60
73Telcontar33%19% 0.58
74Systolic46%27% 0.58
75HiFi40%20% 0.50
76Xkf32%16% 0.50
77PlzBeALevel42%17% 0.40
78Nofear383839%15% 0.40
79Titanrulez47%18% 0.38
80Perdition64%23% 0.36
81KruZe42%13% 0.30
82chrja63%17% 0.27
83clowntable71%14% 0.20
Looks correct
Objectively judging the best ww players Quote
08-29-2014 , 11:02 PM
With a stable set up, a lot of games played, we could figure out a VORP for Werewolf, using not just win rates, but what day people were lynched/NK'd and other kinds of stuff.

It's a very hard game to do a rating system for, just because there are so many different formats, different players, and the fact that it's not a symmetric game.
Objectively judging the best ww players Quote
08-29-2014 , 11:16 PM
Obv in to play
Objectively judging the best ww players Quote
08-29-2014 , 11:33 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by lastchance
With a stable set up, a lot of games played, we could figure out a VORP for Werewolf, using not just win rates, but what day people were lynched/NK'd and other kinds of stuff.

It's a very hard game to do a rating system for, just because there are so many different formats, different players, and the fact that it's not a symmetric game.
You still read this forum?

Grats on the marriage.
Objectively judging the best ww players Quote
08-29-2014 , 11:50 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by chuckleslovakian
You still read this forum?

Grats on the marriage.
Thanks Chuckles. Did not expect to be married 4 years ago or so (damn, it's been a while).

I got a job where I press execute and then wait for hours, so I decided to start playing werewolf again.
Objectively judging the best ww players Quote
08-29-2014 , 11:51 PM
i'll play the turbo draft game
Objectively judging the best ww players Quote
08-29-2014 , 11:59 PM
someones gotta draft you tho
Objectively judging the best ww players Quote
08-30-2014 , 12:01 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kaze13
someones gotta draft you tho
yeah according to that list i'm not in the top 83

Objectively judging the best ww players Quote
08-30-2014 , 12:20 AM
you're in my top 83, Leo

Objectively judging the best ww players Quote
08-30-2014 , 12:35 AM
ill play if it happens this weekend
Objectively judging the best ww players Quote
08-30-2014 , 12:37 AM
In
Objectively judging the best ww players Quote
08-30-2014 , 01:06 AM
Those list should really exclude players who have not played for 2 years.

Surely we are only interested in the quality of current players relative to each other than players who are no longer on the site.

Or

Just do an annual ranking - statistics filtered for 2014.


Yes, yes I realise I am arguing for a thing that would radically improve my own standing.

But really some of the players on that list have not played a game in 3 years or if they have played it is like once.


POG werewolf community is a living changing thing - players who have only recently joined should get recognised in rankings - these sorts of systems make it harder than it otherwise would be by comparing them to the whole history of the game.

Try and get a filter working for 2013+2014 or a rolling 12months or 24 months...so that new players can get a feel for where they sit vs each other (taking into account all of the problems of varaince and everything)

I think it would be great to see how good Reddboiler is vs how good domer2 is vs how good insanity...

As much as I like wdcbooks or shorty or traz - who cares anymore? other than in some abstract reminescence?
Objectively judging the best ww players Quote
08-30-2014 , 01:21 AM
I"m currently watching ESSENDON destroy CARLTON


just thought you should know that digger
Objectively judging the best ww players Quote
08-30-2014 , 01:29 AM
fark the bombers Carn the blues
Objectively judging the best ww players Quote
08-30-2014 , 02:00 AM
Exactly Digger.

WW is like Poker in the way that you would not want to read a strategy article from Mike Matusow, Howard Lederer, Annie Duke, etc. or whichever other clowns beat up on the soft games and lineups back in the day.

The players considered good at Poker years ago, as well as the players considered good at WW years ago, are mostly no longer good in todays climate.


Both sports have changed dramatically. All the old articles on WW are a bit outdated. New players have come in and thrashed the old style of playing WW with new strategies.

Wolves are bolder.
Villagers wiser.


Some joe schmo who beat up on the same players every game in 2008 would probably get stomped if they played in today's mash and vanilla lineups.


So forget yesteryear and march forward. Be innovative, dont reminisce about the days of old.


Else WW has passed you by.


You dont stop playing because you get old, you get old because you stop playing.

Thats WW folks
Objectively judging the best ww players Quote

      
m