Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
LORD OF THE RINGS WW GAME THREAD!! LORD OF THE RINGS WW GAME THREAD!!

10-08-2009 , 07:36 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Luckbox Inc
no, i thought coordi was villagery yesterday and see no reason to change that

i suppose he might have to die eventually, but if he is who he says he is, then i'm assuming that the evils will have to kill him

i have literally zero opinion of gf, but would like to see rf die, which i know won't happen

GF
i don't get why you would vote someone you have 0 opinion on...
LORD OF THE RINGS WW GAME THREAD!! Quote
10-08-2009 , 07:37 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by globetrotter
i don't get why you would vote someone you have 0 opinion on...
seriously?
LORD OF THE RINGS WW GAME THREAD!! Quote
10-08-2009 , 07:37 PM
why not vote one of the other wagons then?
LORD OF THE RINGS WW GAME THREAD!! Quote
10-08-2009 , 07:39 PM
well what are they?
LORD OF THE RINGS WW GAME THREAD!! Quote
10-08-2009 , 07:39 PM
^^^--- unless u are voting purely to save coordi
LORD OF THE RINGS WW GAME THREAD!! Quote
10-08-2009 , 07:40 PM
g1982 is one. idk who else is out there. who do u think is wolfy?
LORD OF THE RINGS WW GAME THREAD!! Quote
10-08-2009 , 07:40 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by XXsooted
assuming coordi is frodo, don't wolves just role-block him, so what are we actually gaining by letting him live?
On the assumption coordi is frodo...

Clearly we gain by not mislynching a villa.
We might have angels left in the game given not any or many (cannot recall too many dying) might be able to protect him at night.

And therefore we should put up our next most likely wolf candidate as substitute.

The issue is we prolly do not have any or only 1 tops more village seers left and do we want to waste a peek to determine Coordi identity when we already have one peek of him as wolf.

So part of the difficulty in keeping Coordi alive is that I find it hard to see how we can reasonably expect to be better informed tommorrow if he remains alive through the night. Given it is a reasonable assumption that either the wolves or the neutrals probably auto-nightkill him tonight.....if he somehow manages to survive then we will be arguing whether or not the wolves just angelled their outted wolf coordi overnight or did a potential village angel protect....but if the village angel protects him and he is a wolf even if the potential village angel then claimed that wouldnt ensure coordi is frodo.

Just seems a mess whichever way we act.

Which goes back to why masons are so powerful and why you should always leave a mason claim post because even a seer peek can be ignored in these circumstances.
LORD OF THE RINGS WW GAME THREAD!! Quote
10-08-2009 , 07:42 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by BombayBadboy
I'll be retiring from WW if Coordi isnt Frodo. Srsly.
come on now. I lean toward believing him but tehres at least a 1 in 3 shot that he's a woof
LORD OF THE RINGS WW GAME THREAD!! Quote
10-08-2009 , 07:43 PM
I'm just gonna say I don't think Coordi is Frodo so I think he should be lynched.

Coordi
LORD OF THE RINGS WW GAME THREAD!! Quote
10-08-2009 , 07:43 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by globetrotter
g1982 is one. idk who else is out there. who do u think is wolfy?
riverfish

i also have zero opinion of g1982 and will vote for whoever i can to save coordi
LORD OF THE RINGS WW GAME THREAD!! Quote
10-08-2009 , 07:45 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by DiggertheDog
On the assumption coordi is frodo...

Clearly we gain by not mislynching a villa.
We might have angels left in the game given not any or many (cannot recall too many dying) might be able to protect him at night.

And therefore we should put up our next most likely wolf candidate as substitute.

The issue is we prolly do not have any or only 1 tops more village seers left and do we want to waste a peek to determine Coordi identity when we already have one peek of him as wolf.

So part of the difficulty in keeping Coordi alive is that I find it hard to see how we can reasonably expect to be better informed tommorrow if he remains alive through the night. Given it is a reasonable assumption that either the wolves or the neutrals probably auto-nightkill him tonight.....if he somehow manages to survive then we will be arguing whether or not the wolves just angelled their outted wolf coordi overnight or did a potential village angel protect....but if the village angel protects him and he is a wolf even if the potential village angel then claimed that wouldnt ensure coordi is frodo.

Just seems a mess whichever way we act.

Which goes back to why masons are so powerful and why you should always leave a mason claim post because even a seer peek can be ignored in these circumstances.
So all we gain is avoiding one mislynch. While if he's a wolf he's a likely powerwolf and clearly wants very much to survive considering how active he's been. The possible gain does not make up for possible loss in letting power wolf survive.
LORD OF THE RINGS WW GAME THREAD!! Quote
10-08-2009 , 07:45 PM
oti
LORD OF THE RINGS WW GAME THREAD!! Quote
10-08-2009 , 07:46 PM
the coordi wagon has a huge momentum and I'm afraid that the only wagons that would be fast enough to be it at this point would be wagons on villagers
LORD OF THE RINGS WW GAME THREAD!! Quote
10-08-2009 , 07:46 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Luckbox Inc
no, i thought coordi was villagery yesterday and see no reason to change that

i suppose he might have to die eventually, but if he is who he says he is, then i'm assuming that the evils will have to kill him

i have literally zero opinion of gf, but would like to see rf die, which i know won't happen

GF
reason I would give is that he is a seer-peeked wolf and is acting like a power wolf
LORD OF THE RINGS WW GAME THREAD!! Quote
10-08-2009 , 07:46 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Luckbox Inc
riverfish

i also have zero opinion of g1982 and will vote for whoever i can to save coordi
why riverfish?
LORD OF THE RINGS WW GAME THREAD!! Quote
10-08-2009 , 07:46 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Luckbox Inc
riverfish

i also have zero opinion of g1982 and will vote for whoever i can to save coordi
i mean, i think gf is wolfy. i don't really remember g1982's posts... i just thought it was a weird thing to say, but if it is to save coordi that makes sense.
LORD OF THE RINGS WW GAME THREAD!! Quote
10-08-2009 , 07:47 PM
sooted is super wrong

o wellz
LORD OF THE RINGS WW GAME THREAD!! Quote
10-08-2009 , 07:49 PM
actually if coordi is planning on using the ring more it might not be that bad to lynch him before he turns into some kind of gollum
LORD OF THE RINGS WW GAME THREAD!! Quote
10-08-2009 , 07:49 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kukraprout
why riverfish?
he made a wolfy post. search through my posts and you'll find my thoughts on it
LORD OF THE RINGS WW GAME THREAD!! Quote
10-08-2009 , 07:49 PM
Chance that Coordi is a wolf (I don't think FCBL FPSes) most likely power wolf if so, if not ring gets passed on to another unknown person, we have 2 cleared villagers, one dead vanillager >>>> coordi is frodo, (gets roleblocked?), we have no way to confirm he actually is, wolves know hes a seer

imo
LORD OF THE RINGS WW GAME THREAD!! Quote
10-08-2009 , 07:55 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by XXsooted
So all we gain is avoiding one mislynch. While if he's a wolf he's a likely powerwolf and clearly wants very much to survive considering how active he's been. The possible gain does not make up for possible loss in letting power wolf survive.
Yeah it appears that way - unless of course there is a game mechanic we are unaware of.

My gut feeling says he turns up wolf here alot.
The intial response was very wolfy.

I think he preempts the thread on the fcbl peek.
Which I think is wolfy because he would be particulary cognisant to get ahead of the thread of it and not seen to be responsive and defensive.

Then he was wishy-washy - which I can see happening if he was in wolfchat trying to delay giving out information that might stuff up a false claim.
He has varied between the strength on whether he needs/should die or not....early on I got the impression that he thinks he will need to die - then later in the day he has been fighting like he thinks he needs to live.

He has kept talking about peeks in a third person....
i.e. I will peek vaya
then he says digger is a good peek.....
then he gives a list of possible peeks....

I mean I just dont see myself as Frodo falsely peeked.

I would do a traditionally well organised claim post.
Clearly ordered night order of peeks - what my peek conditions were, how I choose my peeks.
What my peek posts were - if I did have any then why.


I think this is in contrast to how he did it in Sealab when he was seer.
LORD OF THE RINGS WW GAME THREAD!! Quote
10-08-2009 , 07:56 PM
coordi
LORD OF THE RINGS WW GAME THREAD!! Quote
10-08-2009 , 07:56 PM
g1982 only because i feel for some reason that cordi is telling the truth about the peeking thing.

i also think that if he is a wolf then this will become more aparent as time goes by.


xx
LORD OF THE RINGS WW GAME THREAD!! Quote
10-08-2009 , 07:58 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Andrex Puppy
g1982 only because i feel for some reason that cordi is telling the truth about the peeking thing.

i also think that if he is a wolf then this will become more aparent as time goes by.


xx
Yeah, this guy is a wolf
LORD OF THE RINGS WW GAME THREAD!! Quote
10-08-2009 , 08:01 PM
gl villagers
LORD OF THE RINGS WW GAME THREAD!! Quote

      
m