Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014)

11-13-2014 , 03:02 PM
btw, for the sake of my own sanity I've already disregarded thinking of GFs or otherwise borked peeks.
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-13-2014 , 03:09 PM
Floppy disk
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-13-2014 , 03:11 PM
mexi in a set up like this where there are considerable sources of confusion and trickery, the claims should be given much less weight than usual and we should play werewolf, so to speak

1. disko has not been active nor has he been villagery
2. disko's claimed role is not something that we can clear unequivocally because it's not verifiable nor is it something so strong he will die
3. disko being completely uncooperative with claims and the game is obviously wolfy

ergo, we kill him

especially considering the proportion of villagers to nonvillagers now (everyone is >rand to be a wolf, for example) and considering the varying degrees of villageriness of other guys in the POE, he is a trivial kill with very little loss to us if even he is a villager, if you want to think in that POV
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-13-2014 , 03:11 PM
Pretty sure that claiming does nothing other than satisfying mex's curiosity. I have no helpful info to give you today.

I will claim tomorrow, or maybe today if I might be lynched.
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-13-2014 , 03:19 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Outed Wolf
mexi in a set up like this where there are considerable sources of confusion and trickery, the claims should be given much less weight than usual and we should play werewolf, so to speak

1. disko has not been active nor has he been villagery
2. disko's claimed role is not something that we can clear unequivocally because it's not verifiable nor is it something so strong he will die
3. disko being completely uncooperative with claims and the game is obviously wolfy

ergo, we kill him

especially considering the proportion of villagers to nonvillagers now (everyone is >rand to be a wolf, for example) and considering the varying degrees of villageriness of other guys in the POE, he is a trivial kill with very little loss to us if even he is a villager, if you want to think in that POV
Yeah I mean I don't disagree, just trying to get as much info as possible really.
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-13-2014 , 03:20 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by iversonian
Pretty sure that claiming does nothing other than satisfying mex's curiosity. I have no helpful info to give you today.

I will claim tomorrow, or maybe today if I might be lynched.
Why would you claim today only if you might be lynched if you have no info to give us?
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-13-2014 , 03:27 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by mexineil
Why would you claim today only if you might be lynched if you have no info to give us?
Because it might be sort of clearing?
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-13-2014 , 03:33 PM
mexi, i'm inclined to leave iversonian alone for now. Call it a tone read.

Iver hopefully you don't disappoint my faith. The spectres of the hydra game loom
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-13-2014 , 03:35 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Outed Wolf
mexi, i'm inclined to leave iversonian alone for now. Call it a tone read.

Iver hopefully you don't disappoint my faith. The spectres of the hydra game loom
Why did you track me if you were reading me as a villager this whole time?
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-13-2014 , 03:38 PM
boner's role, which sounds basically the same as what disko is claiming:

Quote:
boner2 has been killed by a group led by the red priestess:
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX XXXXXXXXXXXXXX

You are Jojen Reed. At any point during the game you may sacrifice yourself to get back a role from your team that has died. You will then get that role. (Your current role and new role will be posted in the thread, but not your actual name) Your power rating is: 6. You are the Stark (Dire) Wolf Faction. You get 1 night kill. You win by reaching parity with the village and eliminating all other factions.
Bold didn't happen for disko though
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-13-2014 , 03:40 PM
Seems unlikely that there would be two roles so similar but with that particular difference.
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-13-2014 , 03:42 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Boner2
Cobra is being wolfy again
Quote:
Originally Posted by carcinoGenetecist
Or he's being cobra again
Quote:
Originally Posted by Boner2
you guys w/w?
Dunno why but this strikes me as a w/w interaction.
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-13-2014 , 03:45 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by iversonian
Why did you track me if you were reading me as a villager this whole time?
wanted to make sure you werent a wolf trying to pull a fast one with some sort of super claim
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-13-2014 , 03:46 PM
has carcino played w accobra before? seems like a silly thing to say
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-13-2014 , 03:46 PM
still no one has linked ITA shots charts? sighhhh i wont get home from school till ~4 but i'd be so grateful if someone does that
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-13-2014 , 03:47 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Outed Wolf
has carcino played w accobra before? seems like a silly thing to say
That last line just seems like a lazy attempt at anti spew from Jay to his Starkbr0
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-13-2014 , 03:55 PM
Trying to find a reason that boner was killed by Baratheons. This is the only thing I can find which looks like anything.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Boner2
Outted wolves:

Leo
Mucks
Ben
Bigger?
Mor?
Leo was 100% outed, and Ben was pretty much outed too so doubt it's anything to do with that. Bigger wasn't particularly consensus at the time.

Also later on there's this, where bigger objects to a list of clears with boner's inclusion:

Quote:
Originally Posted by mexineil
My opinion is that this is currently the clearest group of players:
mexineil
Top Tier Tom
DiggertheDog
monstrman
Boner2
Aaronk56's Son

Feel free to disagree
Quote:
Originally Posted by biggerboat
OK, I do
I think bigger as Red Priestess makes sense, and might explain his otherwise inexplicable burst of WIM, randing what I assume is a very important role in a team with a decent chance to win.
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-13-2014 , 03:55 PM
sorry guys, I had to jet out earlier. last night i tried to peek ivers, but got a "no result"...figure it was because I was getting a new PM
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-13-2014 , 03:57 PM
and FWIW, not going to be around to interact and catch up on today till after 8pm. I am sneaking these posts in while my boss is outside on the phone
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-13-2014 , 04:00 PM
So J.D. is a wolf then, cool.
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-13-2014 , 04:02 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by iversonian
Can someone recruit me pls? I really only sign up for mashes for the skype chats.

I'm a lot of fun.
Oh yeah I remember this. lol
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-13-2014 , 04:02 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Outed Wolf
wanted to make sure you werent a wolf trying to pull a fast one with some sort of super claim
Why didn't you let me try, then?
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-13-2014 , 04:02 PM
Did JD just flub his claim?
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-13-2014 , 04:04 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by J.D.
sorry guys, I had to jet out earlier. last night i tried to peek ivers, but got a "no result"...figure it was because I was getting a new PM
No way a genuine seer doesn't mention this in his initial claim.

n3 actions obviously go through before new PMs are sent out.
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-13-2014 , 04:22 PM
I don't know what to tell you guys. I really don't wanna go to in depth about it because I feel like I could get mod killed discussing PMs

But what I said happened....happened

Bbl
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote

      
m