Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
6/23 Community Mishmash Game Thread 6/23 Community Mishmash Game Thread

07-01-2014 , 11:26 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gadarene
in retrospect it would've been pretty fun to have Evil Abed in the mix somewhere

maybe even as a w/v or n/v mason with Troy

Also: Community is coming back for a sixth season! That's unexpected and true!
i thought maybe there could be some forced conversion mechanic or something (I was force converted in Disney, I think, when I was Iago or some ****)

great flavor, though
6/23 Community Mishmash Game Thread Quote
07-01-2014 , 11:28 AM
glad you guys ended this one early

now we can enjoy the full day of SOCCERBALL without worry
6/23 Community Mishmash Game Thread Quote
07-01-2014 , 11:30 AM
yes, Bloo's flavor was consistently

(and I need to figure out how to get Fennec Fox working on my new laptop, because that's pretty annoying)
6/23 Community Mishmash Game Thread Quote
07-01-2014 , 11:31 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gadarene

Also: Community is coming back for a sixth season! That's unexpected and true!
I assume Joel and Chevy won't be on there?
6/23 Community Mishmash Game Thread Quote
07-01-2014 , 11:31 AM
good game duck

you played great

the rest of us didn't do anywhere near enough to win i apologize. i was surprised you left ashington alive. sorry for sucking so bad one of my worst wolf games in a while. good job village

ty mods

i thought the game was well balanced and fun
6/23 Community Mishmash Game Thread Quote
07-01-2014 , 11:33 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ashington
I assume Joel and Chevy won't be on there?
Joel definitely will; Chevy wasn't on last season and I highly doubt he'll be returning.

Don't know whether Jonathan Banks will be back as Buzz -- I hope so, because he had such a natural dynamic with everybody that he fit right in. Great character.
6/23 Community Mishmash Game Thread Quote
07-01-2014 , 11:33 AM
Bloobird:

Pretty okay game IMO.
6/23 Community Mishmash Game Thread Quote
07-01-2014 , 11:36 AM
Also, I'm sure Bloo will do a more detailed post mortem if he wants, but for all of Duck's WIM one of the big wolf equity swings came from him on n0.

BATM wanted to have the wolf watcher target DWetzel with his n0 action. This was the action they submitted initially. If it had stayed that way, the wolves would have seen Donk (seer) visit DWetzel.

Instead, Duck decided to change the watcher's n0 target at the last minute to Telc.

Things might have played out somewhat differently had the wolves known that Donk was likely to be the seer from the beginning.
6/23 Community Mishmash Game Thread Quote
07-01-2014 , 11:36 AM
(That being said, BATM's plan to use their fakepoison on a villager n1 was...perhaps too subtle and clever for my appreciation. In general, I thought the wolves' killing power got minimized/neutralized almost entirely, both for reasons within their control and without.)
6/23 Community Mishmash Game Thread Quote
07-01-2014 , 11:38 AM
yeah sorry batm but that plan wasn't really a good one at all
6/23 Community Mishmash Game Thread Quote
07-01-2014 , 11:39 AM
One more early and obvious equity swing, and this one is a doozy.

If Xkf answers Ohio in the sheep, then:

1) Xkf is elected student body president

2) So he picks the entrants to the bottle episode

3) And he isn't forced to claim and then consider himself virtually outed

4) And a villager almost certainly dies in the bottle episode (rather than nobody)

5) And Xkf is the one who gets to see the true EOD vote counts

6) So Gamer Dude doesn't out the wolf triple voter/backup

Pretty huge swing based on one sheep answer.
6/23 Community Mishmash Game Thread Quote
07-01-2014 , 11:42 AM
I thought the fakepoison/realpoison role mechanic was a very cool one overall. I'm toying with a way to do it that isn't quite as contingent on whether the villa healer is alive or not for it to be effective for the wolf team.
6/23 Community Mishmash Game Thread Quote
07-01-2014 , 11:43 AM
lot of tough modding decisions, some of which I bitched about in DVC (probably too harshly)

I think we've now established that "giving people lots of flavor in their PMs which they absolutely can't use to claim" is like, the worst (ucwidt?) both because of the inevitable butthurt that ALWAYS ensues when someone kinda sorta maybe character claims but not really and puts people in impossible spots. (and this isn't a criticism of this game specifically even, it's just how these sort of themed games go)


and oh yeah

WE WON

6/23 Community Mishmash Game Thread Quote
07-01-2014 , 11:44 AM
Limited heals would be the way, I think (three?). Or a healer that can only heal every other day.
6/23 Community Mishmash Game Thread Quote
07-01-2014 , 11:46 AM
also also, the game mechanics just overtly trolled me this entire game, I just want to say that

d1: HAHAHAHA there's no way a watcher would ever have a n0 action, they said to the tracker with a n0 action

n1: track wolf vig TN (good!) to domer (ooh!), who doesn't die, thereby giving me the strong impression that TN was not the wolf vig

in short, lol me
6/23 Community Mishmash Game Thread Quote
07-01-2014 , 11:46 AM
i agree with wetzel


i'm not a mod and i'm stupid so i'm sure there are good reasons but i dont know them for why character claims can't happen in games like this
6/23 Community Mishmash Game Thread Quote
07-01-2014 , 11:47 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dan Harmon
Limited heals would be the way, I think (three?). Or a healer that can only heal every other day.
Shhh
6/23 Community Mishmash Game Thread Quote
07-01-2014 , 11:48 AM
Solution to character claiming is to give wolves fake claims, both characters and roles.

That's what I do
6/23 Community Mishmash Game Thread Quote
07-01-2014 , 11:48 AM
I definitely think the next game I run will allow character claiming and just go full mental with character affiliations and flavour.

Was thinking of looking at doing a Simpsons mash as it appears there hasn't been a Simpsons themed game for ages and there's so much great flavour to use. But if it does happen it won't be for ages - this **** is time consuming!
6/23 Community Mishmash Game Thread Quote
07-01-2014 , 11:49 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by DWetzel
lot of tough modding decisions, some of which I bitched about in DVC (probably too harshly)

I think we've now established that "giving people lots of flavor in their PMs which they absolutely can't use to claim" is like, the worst (ucwidt?) both because of the inevitable butthurt that ALWAYS ensues when someone kinda sorta maybe character claims but not really and puts people in impossible spots. (and this isn't a criticism of this game specifically even, it's just how these sort of themed games go)


and oh yeah

WE WON

This is no ideal, but seems that same players are causing trouble with modkills.
6/23 Community Mishmash Game Thread Quote
07-01-2014 , 11:52 AM
scoured the game for a village MVP and could not determine one....team win y'all

i guess it could be wilverine
6/23 Community Mishmash Game Thread Quote
07-01-2014 , 11:54 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gadarene
One more early and obvious equity swing, and this one is a doozy.

If Xkf answers Ohio in the sheep, then:

1) Xkf is elected student body president

2) So he picks the entrants to the bottle episode

3) And he isn't forced to claim and then consider himself virtually outed

4) And a villager almost certainly dies in the bottle episode (rather than nobody)

5) And Xkf is the one who gets to see the true EOD vote counts

6) So Gamer Dude doesn't out the wolf triple voter/backup

Pretty huge swing based on one sheep answer.
oh yea totally forgot about this!

who answers OHIO?!?!?! are you kidding me?!

like ask anyone who speaks english above a 3rd grade level to pick a vowel. who is picking O? nobody. want to know why? becuase it's like right in the middle-back of the vowel-order. everyone picks A ewrupioqweuropiweuropiweurpo hahaahahweohahahaha

alabama DUH

ohio wtf come on nothing's even in ohio, alabama is literally first alphabetically
6/23 Community Mishmash Game Thread Quote
07-01-2014 , 11:55 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by domer2
scoured the game for a village MVP and could not determine one....team win y'all

i guess it could be wilverine
who's neutral role was supposedly designed to be pro-wolf afaik
6/23 Community Mishmash Game Thread Quote
07-01-2014 , 11:57 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Xkf
oh yea totally forgot about this!

who answers OHIO?!?!?! are you kidding me?!

like ask anyone who speaks english above a 3rd grade level to pick a vowel. who is picking O? nobody. want to know why? becuase it's like right in the middle-back of the vowel-order. everyone picks A ewrupioqweuropiweuropiweurpo hahaahahweohahahaha

alabama DUH

ohio wtf come on nothing's even in ohio, alabama is literally first alphabetically
yup

everyone not answering first in the alphabet there should have been modkilled
6/23 Community Mishmash Game Thread Quote
07-01-2014 , 11:59 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Xkf
oh yea totally forgot about this!

who answers OHIO?!?!?! are you kidding me?!

like ask anyone who speaks english above a 3rd grade level to pick a vowel. who is picking O? nobody. want to know why? becuase it's like right in the middle-back of the vowel-order. everyone picks A ewrupioqweuropiweuropiweurpo hahaahahweohahahaha

alabama DUH

ohio wtf come on nothing's even in ohio, alabama is literally first alphabetically
counterpoint: alabama is alabama
6/23 Community Mishmash Game Thread Quote

      
m