Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
6/1 Vanilla 13er Arrested POGvelopment 6/1 Vanilla 13er Arrested POGvelopment

06-02-2015 , 07:15 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by q_q
that’s not a "push" on md but siu
Quote:
Originally Posted by ShipItUp
Things that I would do a higher percentage of the time as a villager or a wolf. I've never been known to make joking contradictions specifically as a villager or a wolf and making that contradiction certainly isn't wolfy in a vacuum. But if you want to believe incorrect things feel free, I've tried to show you the light but if you'd rather live in the shadows then by all means.
This one?
6/1 Vanilla 13er Arrested POGvelopment Quote
06-02-2015 , 07:15 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ShipItUp
You don't just come in to a sheriff's office and jack off on his toilet seat, have some class.
6/1 Vanilla 13er Arrested POGvelopment Quote
06-02-2015 , 07:16 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by RAORoman
I don't buy that Lord, as a wolf, would spend most of his time whining and making awkward posts about policy and theory than he would make game-solving posts.

Or I'm expecting too much.
Lord seems like a detailed and analytical thinker. It's hard to fake that amount of content. He has posted detailed and analytical thoughts about game theory, but his reads are just simple sentences with no justification. I want to see detailed, analytical posts about other players in the game.
6/1 Vanilla 13er Arrested POGvelopment Quote
06-02-2015 , 07:16 PM
the tell on siu was that he would constantly say why would i do that as a wolf about things which a wolf has plenty of motives to do, basically i thought siu would be smarter as a villager to use that defense

the post which md quoted was kind of similar however siu has been pretty aggressive which he really wasn’t in that game i think he was like constantly catching up

you can say however many times you want that this is soft push but at the end of the day i’m just a boy playing werewolf who’s posting his thoughts
6/1 Vanilla 13er Arrested POGvelopment Quote
06-02-2015 , 07:18 PM
Love affair betweein MD and SIU on page one is notable for it being pretty hard to understand why it even happened.
6/1 Vanilla 13er Arrested POGvelopment Quote
06-02-2015 , 07:18 PM
i actually think there’s no way lord is wolf nevermind the previous stuff that is the read on page 5-6
6/1 Vanilla 13er Arrested POGvelopment Quote
06-02-2015 , 07:19 PM
this is kawamii all over again
6/1 Vanilla 13er Arrested POGvelopment Quote
06-02-2015 , 07:19 PM
If I'm seer qq is a villager.
6/1 Vanilla 13er Arrested POGvelopment Quote
06-02-2015 , 07:20 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by LordJvK
Vaimes for putting No Lynches on two
LordJvK, never ever changing, he did this complete bull**** to me as a wolf in the last mishmash, this is not a real thing that he believes because it is completely idiotic and also a completely obvious, demonstrated tell that I ranted about in that game and will rant about here. This is who we are lynching, full stop, I don't even need to read the rest of the thread.

This is, literally, EXACTLY what he did last time. This is not a thing.
6/1 Vanilla 13er Arrested POGvelopment Quote
06-02-2015 , 07:20 PM
oh boy
6/1 Vanilla 13er Arrested POGvelopment Quote
06-02-2015 , 07:21 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Evene
on pg 4, I like how SIU is rereading while arguing with jcohen. If he was just post padding, he wouldn't bother with the reread, when he could just stir drama.
This is a pretty good read, didn't even think of that.
6/1 Vanilla 13er Arrested POGvelopment Quote
06-02-2015 , 07:21 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by MD1616
And...you crossed the line.
Quote:
Originally Posted by ShipItUp
MD bro do you have a problem with me? I thought we were friends and now you're coming at me. I even offered you dental dood like wtf.
Quote:
Originally Posted by MD1616
I like you too!

I have no idea why I'm TWing nonsense, btw, but I'm tired and don't feel like going to bed...
Also this continues to make literally zero sense.
6/1 Vanilla 13er Arrested POGvelopment Quote
06-02-2015 , 07:23 PM
To be clear I am in fact going to finish reading the thread but we're lynching LordJvK for lying about how he makes reads again.
6/1 Vanilla 13er Arrested POGvelopment Quote
06-02-2015 , 07:23 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by LordJvK
Diceman's interrogation act is getting old quickly.
lol
6/1 Vanilla 13er Arrested POGvelopment Quote
06-02-2015 , 07:24 PM
I'm full throttle on LordJvK must die and that it's embarrassing if he lives.
6/1 Vanilla 13er Arrested POGvelopment Quote
06-02-2015 , 07:24 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by LordJvK
I think there's no way that evene, md and diceman can all be villa. They are all playing a similar game, but I put at least one wolf in that grouping.
Explain the ways that our games are similar.

I don't think we are playing similar games at all.
6/1 Vanilla 13er Arrested POGvelopment Quote
06-02-2015 , 07:24 PM
Also <3 EVENE
6/1 Vanilla 13er Arrested POGvelopment Quote
06-02-2015 , 07:24 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Evene
Lord seems like a detailed and analytical thinker. It's hard to fake that amount of content. He has posted detailed and analytical thoughts about game theory, but his reads are just simple sentences with no justification. I want to see detailed, analytical posts about other players in the game.
It is day 1. I have always done wagonomics and analyse patterns of action, not "tone".

As in, I'm looking at actual output not how someone comes across.

I think you, Md and diceman are all putting other players to scrutiny about their reads and their behaviour without really making a lot of firm reads or anything. On the one hand, it could mean we have an excellent village who is taking this investigation seriously. That's all good.

On the other, I find it hard to believe there isn't one wolf stirring the pot in there.

Also, the votes have been static for hours now. Know what that means? Wolves are happy with the current state of play. The lack of real movement supports my idea that me and cohen are v v.

Since the three of you are all kind of taking shots from the fringes, offering advice about how to move things on without .... Actually moving things on, suggests to me there's a wolf in there.

The village would be much better off trying to find a wolf in evene / md / diceman than focusing on me or Cohen.
6/1 Vanilla 13er Arrested POGvelopment Quote
06-02-2015 , 07:25 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by LordJvK
No. Me putting Vaimes on two was not the same as Vaimes putting No Lynches on two. The crucial bit of information missing is that when Vaimes cast his vote, he made NL a 2-0 vote leader.

Over years of playing this game, stastistics have shown, time and again, that that -- the early joke vote that makes someone vote leader -- is always a wolfy move.


Think about the danger that Vaimes was putting NL in there. I've explained this before, when you make a vote leader like that, you more or less strap a target to that player's back. You're asking each and every player who comes to the thread from then on to look at them and make a desicion. Daniel Kahneman might call this the anchoring effect. So it's no longer coming to the thread with no info, it's coming to the thread with this question:

"No Lynches has 2 votes and is the vote leader, how will you proceed"

Now, it hasn't actually happend in this game, but many times it does pan out like that. The first person put on two is then part of the wagons all day. I've caught wolves by focusing on that early d1 joke vote that puts someone else on two many times.

I'll also say this: I hate day one and its randomness. There is so little info to go on. My game is not about making soul reads. Ironically (given my profession), I tend to look past the words and focus on deeds. On the actions. So for example, in my last game here, I was the seer. I knew Benneh was a wolf because of his willingness to make votes and pushes that only a wolf would make, I won't get sucked in by "villagery" tone and think people too readily clear others for "tone" in the meta on this site. So I'd ask you to reconsider this vote because if you let me stay alive, I will conduct my own investigation which can yield results.

Oh, and I only "popped in" last night because it was 5 or 6am here in the UK and a man has to sleep at some point!
NO HUMAN IS STUPID ENOUGH TO BELIEVE THIS AND THIS IS EXACTLY WHAT HE SAID WHEN HE WAS LYING

LIKE THIS IS HANDS DOWN THE DUMBEST THING EVER SAID BY ANYONE ABOUT ANYTHING IN THE HISTORY OF MAN, JUST LYNCH HIM
6/1 Vanilla 13er Arrested POGvelopment Quote
06-02-2015 , 07:25 PM
Don't talk, just get lynched, lol@u.
6/1 Vanilla 13er Arrested POGvelopment Quote
06-02-2015 , 07:25 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by CPHoya
LordJvK, never ever changing, he did this complete bull**** to me as a wolf in the last mishmash, this is not a real thing that he believes because it is completely idiotic and also a completely obvious, demonstrated tell that I ranted about in that game and will rant about here. This is who we are lynching, full stop, I don't even need to read the rest of the thread.

This is, literally, EXACTLY what he did last time. This is not a thing.
hehe
6/1 Vanilla 13er Arrested POGvelopment Quote
06-02-2015 , 07:26 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by MD1616
**applause**

That was a great post, JVK. Now that you mention it, I've noticed that trend on BGG, but I couldn't have articulated it nearly as well.

My vote in Vaimes is more solid.
Oh my GOD just lynch both of them, I've already solved 2/3s of the game, get rid of these clowns.
6/1 Vanilla 13er Arrested POGvelopment Quote
06-02-2015 , 07:26 PM
XD
6/1 Vanilla 13er Arrested POGvelopment Quote
06-02-2015 , 07:27 PM
cphoya can i be the third wolf?
6/1 Vanilla 13er Arrested POGvelopment Quote
06-02-2015 , 07:27 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by CPHoya
LordJvK, never ever changing, he did this complete bull**** to me as a wolf in the last mishmash, this is not a real thing that he believes because it is completely idiotic and also a completely obvious, demonstrated tell that I ranted about in that game and will rant about here. This is who we are lynching, full stop, I don't even need to read the rest of the thread.

This is, literally, EXACTLY what he did last time. This is not a thing.
keep reading

it gets better (worse?)
6/1 Vanilla 13er Arrested POGvelopment Quote

      
m