barracks - 2
Cinderella - 3
Halloween - 4

Africa
Bark
Bear
Board
Canada
Chair
Ham
Himalayas
Mexico
Pie
Pipe
Pirate
Platypus
Police
Queen
Spider
Stock
Telescope
Triangle
Undertaker

Bed
Missile
Dance

Pumpkin
Plot

What the **** is this game

Sirius - 3

Ok, well yea what IBD said...

So, Neil just make sure you have a complete list when you bold next time. Solved itself at least, because they guessed plot (which was obviously ours lol). NBD either way, I think eb would have caught that plot should have been before queen on our list.


Having just reread all of HP recently (it wasn't at all the same, btw), I really want to see a Sirius Black reference here with this clue, anyway....Sirius is a star, it's basically the brightest star, and is part of a constellation that is a dog. Let's hope eb knows this, because if so:

Telescope - 100%
Bark - 100%

Spider kinda works as an HP reference, but how is that not part of Halloween - 4 on this board? Also, lol at the only word we get first round being the perfect blocker for a big halloween clue.
Other HP references:
Triangle: represents the cloak of the 3 deathly hallows
Undertaker: perhaps represents the fact that sirius was considered a murderer?

Chair could be the other Cinderella word. I actually like that better than Queen...didn't the prince have the women sit in a chair as they tried the slipper on?

What the **** is this game

we should actually refrain from guessing undertaker at all. force them to resolve it.

I thought it makes sense to bold consensus picks before dickering a complete list, but I'm easy on that.

The name of the star Sirius *references* a dog but is part of the constellation Ursa Major, the Great Bear, I thought. Aka the Big Dipper.

Bark/Bear/Telescope

That's fine to bold consensus picks first, but we need to list what we plan to guess next in case they aren't correct. Bold the first two, don't bold plot or queen, but definitely include it. In the case that this were our final clue with plot ours and queen theirs, he would then need to include plot in his final clue, since n-1 would hit queen. This makes it harder for us to get that clue.

I'm cool with

Telescope
Bark
Bear

What's your thoughts on make up for Cinderella?

I think I'd like Chair or Queen still, but not convinced on which to guess, if you agree

I can see Chair, as it goes to the iconic image of sitting down and having the glass slipper put on. But that's possibly a reach.

I can definitely see cluing it for Queen from the prince.

Could also be Board for boarding the carriage that the Pumpkin was made into.

I don't know what else Cinderella would be.

As for bolding, I'll just be more cautious about it in general. No sweat. Your logic is sound.

bump

bump

Let's see if these are right, and then I think I'm ok with queen

Telescope
Bark
Bear

Queen
Chair
Board

?

barracks - 2
Cinderella - 3
Halloween - 4
Sirius - 3

Africa
Board
Canada
Chair
Ham
Himalayas
Mexico
Pie
Pipe
Pirate
Platypus
Police
Queen
Spider
Stock
Triangle
Undertaker

Bed
Missile
Dance

Pumpkin
Plot
Telescope
Bark

Bear

My bad guessing Plot, what a boner.

Keystone - unlimited

Pipe
Canada
Spider
Undertaker
Pirate
Pie
Bottles

gg?

I really can't find a better answer than yhis

Pipe
Canada
Spider
Undertaker
Pirate
Pie
Bottles

Bottles indeed

Great guessing

I woulda included dance in Halloween if they hadn’t gotten it for us

Obv pumpkin was my big blocker so I did barracks first hoping he’d clue pumpkin early

I capitalized it because it’s a holiday that is always capitalized; I wasn’t thinking about plot for the movie; I shoulda left it all lower case just to be safe

Way to go team. Great clues, nich

Also was worried y’all may go police for Keystone Kops but couldn’t think of any other Canada+pipe beyond Keystone

Sorry team. Red played well there. GG.

Nice clueing, Nich! gg all

gg y'all. Can someone post the board?