11/22 X-Files Vanilla Plus Game Thread
11-21-2012
, 09:16 PM
11-21-2012
, 09:17 PM
11-21-2012
, 09:17 PM
11-21-2012
, 09:18 PM
Quote:
I just read page 1 in more detail than I've read a page 1 in a long long time, it feels good even if it took a while. I'm going to try and explain most of my reads as much as possible in an effort to be more villagery, it's a change to my meta I started implementing a few games ago...of course since then I've randed wolf every game until this one :P
Forsy villagery - he's generally more generically villagery as a wolf and more off the wall villagery as a villager
LKJ villagery - I just enjoy his sarcasm and rhetoric
Timon villagery - Seems very freeflowing and friendly, he's wolfed once and he couldn't replicate that as much
Chilltown villagery - I was a little wary of him not deciding to tank to balance his meta like he's said he would for a while, but as long as he keeps being villagery we're cool
Jim villagery - I like what he's noticing, I like his friendliness, and I like it when Jim is a villager and I'm hoping beyond hope that we're v/v for once
Anarchist villagery - I think his first post is way more in his village range than his wolf range
Ashington's opening seems a little clunky - I think Forsy mentioned this and voted him for it
Willi wolfy, although posting killing me softly with his song is pretty villagery
is basically what I got from it
I think this is a post Willi is more likely to make as a wolf, I admittedly haven't played with him in a long time and no longer have a great grasp on his metagame, but I think he's more likely to make a random isolated comment like this as a wolf. The whole first page he seemed wrapped up in his own world a little bit, compared to others who seemed more outgoing.
I actually remember you *mentioning* this exact same story in my first game
The bolded here seems a bit out of place, if he's fired up from loosekanen's post I can see it, it doesn't feel like typical villager Monte though, it seems more like something a wolf would say because it's a typically villagery thing to say. The rest of his posts have been fine so it's probably not worth worrying over yet.
Eh, I oscillate on him a lot. I was actually reading the draft thread the other day and somebody gave what I thought was a pretty accurate assessment of Boo. In that as a villager his reads are >rand but he gets mislynched a lot and he tends to tunnel villagers to a point beyond all reason/can't reconsider his wolf reads. Also he purposely doesn't try as a wolf because he doesn't find it interesting.
I can't say it bothered me overly much as I think the context for using it makes sense as a villager here. And by that I mean that villaMonte doesn't have to think that Ashington is a wolf for his post, so talking to him like he could be a villager and that what he's doing is anti-village is fine, I think.
Forsy villagery - he's generally more generically villagery as a wolf and more off the wall villagery as a villager
LKJ villagery - I just enjoy his sarcasm and rhetoric
Timon villagery - Seems very freeflowing and friendly, he's wolfed once and he couldn't replicate that as much
Chilltown villagery - I was a little wary of him not deciding to tank to balance his meta like he's said he would for a while, but as long as he keeps being villagery we're cool
Jim villagery - I like what he's noticing, I like his friendliness, and I like it when Jim is a villager and I'm hoping beyond hope that we're v/v for once
Anarchist villagery - I think his first post is way more in his village range than his wolf range
Ashington's opening seems a little clunky - I think Forsy mentioned this and voted him for it
Willi wolfy, although posting killing me softly with his song is pretty villagery
is basically what I got from it
I think this is a post Willi is more likely to make as a wolf, I admittedly haven't played with him in a long time and no longer have a great grasp on his metagame, but I think he's more likely to make a random isolated comment like this as a wolf. The whole first page he seemed wrapped up in his own world a little bit, compared to others who seemed more outgoing.
I actually remember you *mentioning* this exact same story in my first game
The bolded here seems a bit out of place, if he's fired up from loosekanen's post I can see it, it doesn't feel like typical villager Monte though, it seems more like something a wolf would say because it's a typically villagery thing to say. The rest of his posts have been fine so it's probably not worth worrying over yet.
Eh, I oscillate on him a lot. I was actually reading the draft thread the other day and somebody gave what I thought was a pretty accurate assessment of Boo. In that as a villager his reads are >rand but he gets mislynched a lot and he tends to tunnel villagers to a point beyond all reason/can't reconsider his wolf reads. Also he purposely doesn't try as a wolf because he doesn't find it interesting.
I can't say it bothered me overly much as I think the context for using it makes sense as a villager here. And by that I mean that villaMonte doesn't have to think that Ashington is a wolf for his post, so talking to him like he could be a villager and that what he's doing is anti-village is fine, I think.
has it happened?
HAS IT HAPPENED?!
11-21-2012
, 09:18 PM
Drank my scotch and took a 45 minutes nap. Now moving on to beer. Smauel Smith Old Brewery Tadcaster Oatmeal Stout... WOW this beer doesn't **** around. That's a delicious stout. One of the best I've ever had. This may become a regular shower beer 
11-21-2012
, 09:21 PM
I...I umm...I think so!
11-21-2012
, 09:25 PM
11-21-2012
, 09:26 PM
11-21-2012
, 09:26 PM
11-21-2012
, 09:28 PM
Quote:
im comfortable calling loose a likely villager now
this is a very odd thought process for a wolf to have:
- He's seeing kruze's reaction to him is to call him a wolf
- He's thinking about what makes sense for Kruze to react this way
- Thinks about it as a wolf and as a villager
- Decides it's more likely Kruze is voting him because he was right
- Deduces Kruze must be a villager
It's got a logical progression that's easy to follow, but also one that isn't the most basic one to have. It makes sense in the flow of how it happened, and the multiple posts in a row showcases excitement about thinking he has something figured out.
this is a very odd thought process for a wolf to have:
- He's seeing kruze's reaction to him is to call him a wolf
- He's thinking about what makes sense for Kruze to react this way
- Thinks about it as a wolf and as a villager
- Decides it's more likely Kruze is voting him because he was right
- Deduces Kruze must be a villager
It's got a logical progression that's easy to follow, but also one that isn't the most basic one to have. It makes sense in the flow of how it happened, and the multiple posts in a row showcases excitement about thinking he has something figured out.
still, i think if i weighed them against each other i would move you slightly villagery for this post simply because at this point i think you would think more highly of me if you were a wolf and not resort to such a base level 1 read in order to gain my trust.
boy if i'm wrong you're gonna look like a total **** head in post
11-21-2012
, 09:30 PM
11-21-2012
, 09:31 PM
11-21-2012
, 09:33 PM
11-21-2012
, 09:33 PM