im not complaining at all

im not trying to be the best

im trying to win this for the village

unlike you who just said 20 minutes ago

"i want to lynch VMF for fun"

ye ur a real big team player

it doesn't matter,

your trying to judge / find roles for people based on seer hunt stuff which is stupid



JUDGE THE PEOPLE IN THE GAME BY THEIR POSTS / ACTIONS,

not by who the wolves nk'd.

That is being a team player.



You just don't understand it. Sometimes lynching a villa over a known wolf is better for the village. But most people won't do that, cuz its labelled an anti village play.

Thats the problem with sticking with "arbirtrary rules".

You can label me lynching you for fun as anti village i fyou want, but I can prove post game, that is the best pro village play for different reasons, even if I say its just for fun.

ill judge the game on everything

i just think the night kills have been extremely interesting this game

okay u lynch me and i flip villa

then what ?

what did we learn

Can you explain why? I don't see a situation where that makes sense. Like I can see how throwing around various village wagons can help give the village information about who the wolves might be, and voting on an outed wolf doesn't give much information - but NOT lynching that wolf... I don't really get it.

Variance who are your top wolves / top villas?

We learn that lynching people for fun = profit.

You probably don't realize why though.

Wow you did this on d2 too with sun. I'll quote it when I get hime

nah i dont

thats why i asked u the master of village why

varianceminefield

this is for you akspartan

i forget eadgbe

hes probably a wolf

i think the team is in nofear/thenothing/eadgbe

I just hope I'm alive tomorrow to explain why its important.

My bad, forgot you made that post.

vmf,

Look at how people voted annie in the American Gods game.

The villagers voted him in an entirely different fashion than the wolves did.

When you vote out a known villager, wolves can't fake the reasoning of why villagers would vote out a known villager like teh way villas' can.

Its also why I kept saying this game, for villagers not to vote for the outted wolf.


wolves can't resist voting for an outted wolf, they don't have the balls to not be on the wagon.

yeah i mean i understand that

i just think its more important to try to vote a wolf

This game is exhausting me. Is there any worry if I drop a vote now with regard to maj? Are there wagons already?

I'm gonna be honest with you guys, I'm finding it tough sat here watching Mac and VMF going back and forth at each other.

Does wolf vmf level like this

You can always bus yourself or TheNOthing ftw

Taking off to watch some football. Likely will be back later. No maj til tomorrow night!

i could but im not

Will laugh at you in post game. I'm not voting thenothing today. Going to stand up for my game long read. If you think that makes me a wolf, wagon me. If you are sure it makes me a wolf, I'll self vote.

Another pointer to Noah being villager:

Post 1805, Supine engages Noah. Now knowing Supine is wolf, Supine mentions that he and Noah wolfed together in the past, states that Noah's game "should have evolved more" since then, but implies so far he's still looking like the same wolf with more posts than previously.

I interpret this as Supine trying to set up Noah for a future argument that they wolfed together before and Noah is playing the exact same game so must be wolf.

So yeah, up to that point, Noah's game may have been higher on commentary and less on analysis (remember at this point most of the thread was a jumbled mess), it is somewhat unlikely that a known wolf would potentially out a partner this early in the game.

Done re-reading Noah for now.

Rereading TheNothing. this the first 1k posts of the thread

i don't put as much credence into entrance posts as most ppl, but I think this one is wolfier than average

annie said he pointed out something bad about one of VMF's cases then he disappeared making vmf wolfy. This is a thing I see wolves do quite a bit, where they give someone a lean in one direction but point out or agree with evidence that should sway their lean the other way. It makes justifying switching wagons easier.

I think this is a good flowy interaction with villager gad, prob more role neutral than anything

Sun interacting with TheNothing in a meaningless way makes me think that w/w is more likely than w/v. It looks like Sun is trying to get information, but it's a very easy question to answer and might even be sort of jokey.

this is important because this post was made after Sun likely knew he was peeked. Could be TheNothing trying to get cred for picking up on Sun's scent early.

below was my initial reaction to this list, and I still get the same feeling. Something I just noticed however is that TheNothing has me as a villager in this list, but in her comments on Noah's list like 3 posts earlier, she said she agreed that she had "minor concerns" about me.


I put what anarchist was talking about in red above

looking more like a wolf than a villager so far. gonna continue