Would you give up your entire draft for Andrew Luck? Would you take someone else's whole draft? - Sporting Events and Fantasy Sports

Two Plus Two Forums Sports and Games Sporting Events

Would you give up your entire draft for Andrew Luck? Would you take someone else's whole draft?

View Poll Results: Give up entire draft for Luck? Take someone else's whole draft?

Yes, Yes

18 13.85%

Yes, No

28 21.54%

No, Yes

56 43.08%

No, No

9 6.92%

RIP GREEEEEEAAARRRRRRRR

19 14.62%

Post Reply Subscribe

...

Page 1 of 15

1 2 3 4 5 6 11

Page 1 of 15

1 2 3 4 5 6 11

10-31-2011 , 10:28 PM

ikestoys

banned

Join Date: Nov 2006 Posts: 94,424

Pretty simple questions.

Luck is the most highly rated college QB since Peyton Manning. Would you be willing to give up your first through seventh round picks for a chance at the Luck sweepstakes?

Obviously the answer changes depending on the team, so for the poll's sake let's keep it for a bottom third team. If you want to make a case a middle or top tier team should go for it in the comments.

OTOH, if your team somehow won the Luck sweepstakes, would you be willing to give up Luck for an entire draft class? If no, at what point do you make the trade? If yes, would you take less?

Quote

10-31-2011 , 10:29 PM

thedeezy

My name is Carlos

Join Date: Mar 2007 Posts: 26,261

Cam Newton

Quote

10-31-2011 , 10:30 PM

EPiPeN11

banned

Join Date: Mar 2007 Posts: 18,605

meh hes not even as good of a future prospect as cam newton

Quote

10-31-2011 , 10:30 PM

chim17

Snowboarding concerts and punk music

Join Date: Oct 2003 Posts: 56,128

He is clearly worth multiple firsts.. and a first should be well worth a 4th-7th or whatever.

So, yes, I would.

Quote

10-31-2011 , 10:31 PM

Riverman

Carpal \'Tunnel

Join Date: Apr 2003 Posts: 73,129

Quote

10-31-2011 , 10:31 PM

BASaint

Carpal \'Tunnel

Join Date: Jan 2009 Posts: 14,826

Bottom third teams are not alike, they have different problems.

I'd rather have an entire draft rather than Luck based on the 50%+ chance he doesn't become a top 5 NFL QB.

Quote

10-31-2011 , 10:32 PM

ikestoys

banned

Join Date: Nov 2006 Posts: 94,424

Quote:

Originally Posted by Riverman

LOL yeah, that's the obvious comparison. Problem with that comparison though is that running back is the least important position on the field while QB is the most important.

Quote

10-31-2011 , 10:32 PM

dkgojackets

DKGOAT

Join Date: May 2006 Posts: 86,120

better question is that cam newton would be worth a teams first round pick for the next X years (keep in mind that in about three seasons those will all be very late)

Quote

10-31-2011 , 10:33 PM

Needle77

No Longer Protecting

Join Date: Jul 2005 Posts: 43,898

Rather have Tim Tebow. Pure winners are hard to find. Luck hasn't and will not win a national title. Can't trust someone like that at the first overall pick. To be honest, this draft class has little to no winners in it. Landry Jones? Matt Barkley? I guess Kellen Moore is what you need but his epic meltdown vs Nevada last year...

Probably some elite WR that needs to go here.

Quote

10-31-2011 , 10:35 PM

#10

HesterAndEldridge

banned

Join Date: Oct 2011 Posts: 19

it seems like the dolphins are doing everything possible to get that first pick.. colts too.

Quote

10-31-2011 , 10:35 PM

#11

PocketChads

guaranteed 42-10 finish

Join Date: Jul 2006 Posts: 22,494

RIP GREEEEEEAAARRRRRRRR

Quote

10-31-2011 , 10:36 PM

#12

Needle77

No Longer Protecting

Join Date: Jul 2005 Posts: 43,898

Quote:

Originally Posted by HesterAndEldridge

it seems like the dolphins are doing everything possible to get that first pick.. colts too.

Dolphins have Chad Henne though.

Colts need Luck much more.

Quote

10-31-2011 , 10:43 PM

#13

AtThe Aquarium

banned

Join Date: Jun 2005 Posts: 5,602

If I'm the Dolphins I'm trading the draft for Luck.

They're not that bad, except at QB.

Quote

10-31-2011 , 10:50 PM

#14

Franchise 60

deliciously angry

Join Date: Jun 2007 Posts: 42,744

If you don't have a good QB then yeah, this is a pretty easy decision.

Think the team trading Luck would rather have multiple first round picks + some other picks though.

Quote

10-31-2011 , 10:51 PM

#15

Bitchface

banned

Join Date: Oct 2010 Posts: 6,917

Quote:

Originally Posted by ikestoys

running back is the least important position on the field

lol

Quote

10-31-2011 , 10:52 PM

#16

BadBoyBenny

Carpal \'Tunnel

Join Date: Dec 2003 Posts: 7,799

New York Jets should offer Sanchez + this year's draft + next year's first.

I doubt Polian would take that TBO. Dolphins might

Quote

10-31-2011 , 10:56 PM

#17

rakemyblind

centurion

Join Date: Mar 2010 Posts: 145

Quote:

Originally Posted by ikestoys

running back is the least important position on the field

No, it's not the least important position. But RB's are a dime a dozen so I agree giving up the draft for one is LOL.

Quote

10-31-2011 , 10:57 PM

#18

tschubauer

Carpal \'Tunnel

Join Date: May 2010 Posts: 7,458

Quote:

Originally Posted by PocketChads

RIP GREEEEEEAAARRRRRRRR

this

Quote

10-31-2011 , 10:58 PM

#19

deej_0607

veteran

Join Date: Dec 2007 Posts: 3,136

Quote:

Originally Posted by Needle77

wat? nominated for worst post ever

Quote

10-31-2011 , 10:59 PM

#20

HesterAndEldridge

banned

Join Date: Oct 2011 Posts: 19

Quote:

Originally Posted by Needle77

Dolphins have Chad Henne though.

Colts need Luck much more.

look at the last two games for the dolphins.. they are def not trying to win these games.

Quote

10-31-2011 , 11:02 PM

#21

Zimmer4141

Wet

Join Date: Oct 2005 Posts: 33,726

Quote:

Originally Posted by deej_0607

wat? nominated for worst post ever

Quote

10-31-2011 , 11:04 PM

#22

ogallalabob

veteran

Join Date: Jun 2008 Posts: 2,448

I would be willing to make the trade if I was a team a long way away from contention. You can over turn your roster in 4 years and that a good QB can be around for 15 years. (Washington, Denver, Seatle) A team thats window is now, would be harder to pull the trigger. Hard to give up the depth you get in the draft and harder still to win with a rookie QB.

Question is what do the Colts do if they get the first pick? Would look at trading him and would be pressured by Manning to do so butI think they take him.

Quote

10-31-2011 , 11:08 PM

#23

chim17

Snowboarding concerts and punk music

Join Date: Oct 2003 Posts: 56,128

I would give the entire Broncos draft, all 4 of our QB's, and a kidney.

Quote

10-31-2011 , 11:09 PM

#24

Victor

Carpal \'Tunnel

Join Date: Jul 2003 Posts: 77,653

Quote:

Originally Posted by BASaint

Bottom third teams are not alike, they have different problems.

I'd rather have an entire draft rather than Luck based on the 50%+ chance he doesn't become a top 5 NFL QB.

man if hes 5050 to be a perennial top 5 qb id say that makes the trade pretty damn close.

Quote

10-31-2011 , 11:12 PM

#25

five4suited

Carpal \'Tunnel

Join Date: Jun 2005 Posts: 9,026

no college player is worth an entire draft. you build depth and take fliers in the later rounds. luck is still just one guy.

just curious, what's the scouting report on luck?

wrt leadership, pocket presence, arm strength, reading defenses/audibling, mobility, and toughness?

how does he respond when he gets frustrated or has a mostly bad game? my impression is that they just crush, what would he do against lsu or alabama?

Quote

Page 1 of 15

First

1 2 3 4 5 6 11

Last

Post Reply Subscribe

...

Page 1 of 15

First

1 2 3 4 5 6 11

Last