Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread
View Poll Results: GOAT?
labron
182 30.43%
MJ (Michael or Maple)
319 53.34%
Therapist
8 1.34%
George Mikan
5 0.84%
Shaq Attaq
21 3.51%
Wilt the Stilt (100 pts yo)
13 2.17%
Timmy "Big Fundamentals" Duncan
20 3.34%
"Roger Murdock"
3 0.50%
Enchanted AIDS Wang (er, HIV+?)
9 1.51%
Larry Legend (+ HM to Bill Russell's laugh)
18 3.01%

04-29-2023 , 08:58 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Onlydo2days
Obviously this could end up wrong and we won't know for awhile but I kinda think MJ/Bron are relatively safe GOAT wise, whichever side you are on.

There's just too many good players now, too many injuries, too much 3pt variance, too hard to maneuver the salary cap every year, too much parity for someone to win 6 titles in their last 6 full years of playing or for someone to go to the finals 8 straight years and basically be involved in the title picture for 14 years ('07-'20)...It isn't impossible and maybe another Heatles or KD-Warriors forms, who knows, but seems harder than ever.

I also don't know how much motivation a guy is gonna have to be a GOAT when you're now handed 200M at age 24 for being anywhere close to that type of player. The journey for these guys starts at age 15 now and almost ends with that contract, everything after that is gravy.

I mean, who under 25 right now is even in the discussion? Tatum? Luka? Pretty laughable eh?


I also think the way the NBA is going (direction of MLB/NHL in terms of more niche) that even if someone comes along and is like that, the sport just isn't as culturally relevant and thus they won't be as culturally relevant as Bron/MJ (or even Bird/Magic)
if this guy can stay healthy until early-mid 30s hes probably the GOAT, but at 7'5" thats pretty unlikely

Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
04-29-2023 , 09:03 PM
mid 30s? he probably wont stay healthy until 23
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
04-30-2023 , 01:40 AM
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
04-30-2023 , 04:15 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by AllBlackDan
Found that scary bear LeBron beat up

Spoiler:
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
05-01-2023 , 04:58 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by candybar
It's interesting how butthurt people are that Kevin Durant was ranked #21 by Ben Taylor.

It's not that surprising though that Victor and fidstar don't understand that different criteria should produce different player rankings.

For example, Kevin Durant at his best would probably go top-10 in an all-time draft assuming you get each player as they were and you're trying to compete in today's basketball. But he clearly doesn't have a top-10 career. It's almost like the league has gotten better or something. Victor doesn't seem to understand that when we rank players historically, we're not ranking them based on how good they were at an absolute level. When we rank Bill Russell ahead of Kevin Durant or Babe Ruth ahead of Aaron Judge, we're not saying Bill Russell would be a better basketball player in today's game than KD or Babe Ruth would be a better baseball player than Aaron Judge in today's game. We're evaluating them and their achievements relative to their era. This is how MJ vs Lebron is a debate at all, they aren't really comparable at all otherwise (though some batshit insane MJ-stans might argue otherwise).

Likewise, Artis Gilmore being ahead of KD in some statistical category, yet KD being a better player than Artis Gilmore overall, doesn't mean the stat itself is useless. It must take a fairly high level of idiocy to hold these thoughts, especially when fidstar himself loves to talk about all kinds of terrible stats that also contradict his own player rankings.
I’m a fan of Taylor in general and while some of his methodology has some flaws I think relatively speaking it’s quite good. His all-time ranking metrics are a bit different than most and I’m sure you’ve mentioned this previously but his alltime ranks are based on championship value added and Durant in the #20 range is not unreasonable based on that.

I think if we go off peaks he’s higher and if we go with a “build a 5 man lineup” rather than an all time draft picking guys you could make an even better case for him as being paired with Curry/Bron would be superior to him has the alpha star.
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
05-01-2023 , 05:53 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ILOVEPOKER929
As far as Warriors vs Lakers, haven't been this fired up for a 2nd rd series in awhile. Looney is gonna destroy Davis and it's gonna be glorious. Then we get to watch the #2 player of all time, Curry, square off against LeBron, the #3 player of all time. LETS GO
Quote:
Originally Posted by muttiah
Oh great we get still got people pretending Lebron isn’t the goat
Quote:
Originally Posted by Hellmuth was right
Lebron's got a better supporting cast than Curry this year and somehow the Warriors are still favored. the market knows who the better player really is.
Quote:
Originally Posted by mullen
And yeah Curry at 35 is > Lebron at 38.5 with a ****ed up Lisfranc lol. Most guys wouldn’t be playing at all let alone at his age. It’s insane he’s even out there tbh. Warriors are favorites for a reason and it’s not because Curry > LBJ all time lol. 2p2 LeBron haters continue to shovel paste in their mouths at a record pace.
And this is why Lebron is clearly the GOAT - no one in the history of the game was asked to do more and delivered. Keep in mind that this is Curry's age 34 season. Lebron won a title as the best player and was 2nd in MVP voting in his age 35 season, while missing just 4 regular season games. The last time Curry missed 8 or fewer regular season games was 16-17, his age 28 season. Lebron's played almost twice as many minutes in the NBA as Curry at this point.

Also MJ during his age 38 season wasn't just worse than Lebron at 38 - he was worse than some of his own peers. 2001-2002 BPM ranking for players 38 or older:

1. John Stockton (age 39): 5.3 BPM, 2566 MP
2. Karl Malone (age 38): 3.7 BPM, 3040 MP
3. Michael Jordan (age 38): 3.1 BPM, 2093 MP
4. Terry Porter (age 38): 1.7 BPM, 1294 MP
5. Hakeem Olajuwon (age 39): -0.4 BPM, 1378 MP
6. Johnny Newman (age 38): -2.6 BPM, 724 MP
7. Kevin Willis (age 39): -3.0 BPM, 865 MP
8. Patrick Ewing (age 39): -3.1 BPM, 901 MP
9. Sam Mitchell (age 38): -3.8 BPM, 726 MP
10. Charles Oakley (age 38): -5.1 BPM, 1383 MP

2022-2023 BPM ranking for players 38 or older:

1. Lebron James (Age 38): 6.1 BPM, 1954 MP
2. Andre Iguodala (Age 39): -2.8 BPM, 113 MP
3. Udonis Haslem (Age 42): -12.1 BPM, 71 MP

In other words, in MJ's age 38 season, he was one of 10 players that were playing regular minutes aged 38 or older and was 3rd in BPM. This season, Lebron was the only player his age or older playing regular minutes
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
05-02-2023 , 05:47 AM
That last stat is amazing. Also of note that Lebron beats everyone in both groups for the rate stat, although Stockton and Malone crushed at still putting in the volume.

Stockton pretty damn underrated historically.
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
05-09-2023 , 07:00 PM
twog being back talking about ball movement reminded me of this again:

https://www.sun-sentinel.com/1989/04...riple-doubles/

Quote:
During breaks in games, Jordan has been wandering over to the scorer's table to get updates on how many rebounds, assists and points he needs to fill his three double-figure quotas.

"The guys at the scorer's desk let me know what I need," he said. "They tell me, 'You need three assists; you need two rebounds."'


Jordan also has been double-checking the figures with Chicago assistants.

"They keep me in tune," he said. "They keep reminding me when I come back to the huddle, how much I need."

Last Sunday, at home against New Jersey, the 10th assist was Jordan's final goal.

"I knew I had nine assists," he said, "and I looked at (forward) Brad (Sellers), and said, 'Brad, can I count on you for my 10th?' And he said, 'yeah' and hit a jumper from the baseline."

The push for the elusive triple-double is part of Jordan's push for greater respect.

"If the way I'm playing now doesn't convince them I'm a complete player," he said, "then nothing will."
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
05-09-2023 , 07:06 PM
And I've already summarized this whole ball movement makes MJ better nonsense here:

Quote:
Originally Posted by candybar
3ball, I'm kind of curious, do you apply this way of thinking to everything in life or just basketball? I think it would be epic to see this, I don't know what to call it, specialness?, applied to other areas of life. Your argument adds up to something like: "The ball movement system is superior to ball dominance but its success was a pure carry-job by MJ who had to score all the points to carry his teammates and he did that in a nothing offense that actually sucks with most players and requires certain players but Lebron wouldn't fit in this nothing offense, so that makes him a bad player and oh yeah and the key to this superior ball movement nothing offense is a high number of tightly contested mid-range jumpers you must take in order to achieve the #1 offensive rating. Lebron doesn't take these shots and passes to his teammates instead, which is the kind of ball dominance that wouldn't fit in a ball movement system." - there aren't words in the English language to describe the level of incoherence at display here.
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
05-09-2023 , 10:57 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Hellmuth was right
if this guy can stay healthy until early-mid 30s hes probably the GOAT, but at 7'5" thats pretty unlikely

He's basically Michelle Wie. Awesome tools, not gonna happen in a big way as anticipated and dreamed about.

Last edited by FellaGaga-52; 05-09-2023 at 11:16 PM.
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
05-10-2023 , 08:57 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by FellaGaga-52
He's basically Michelle Wie. Awesome tools, not gonna happen in a big way as anticipated and dreamed about.
I'll tweak that to a combination of Michelle Wie, Yao Ming, Zion Williamson, Chris Washburn. Jamarcus Russell, Tony Mandarich, etc.
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
05-11-2023 , 02:15 AM
New data:

LeBron with his 19th All NBA Selection from his 20 seasons.

Duncan, Kobe and Kareem joint 2nd with 15
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
05-13-2023 , 01:35 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by candybar
Lebron at his peak ran the team's offense and ran the team's defense, was simultaneously a matchup nightmare, while being able to plug all kinds of matchup issues on his own team's lineup due to his defensive versatility.

Versatility is especially important in the playoffs because it limits the opposing team's ability to exploit matchup weaknesses. This is why despite Lebron rarely having a top-tier coach on his side and often having supporting casts with clear weaknesses (not enough shooting and lack of bigs on the Heat, and defensive limitations for his teammates with the Cavs), Lebron's teams have won extremely consistently in the playoffs.
Playoff Lebron still seems to be a thing despite all that mileage and the foot injury. In terms of evaluating Lebron, it's important to understand that he can't give 100% all the time because he's good at too many things - his overall production is limited by the fact that he doesn't have unlimited stamina, which is why his overall production is still reasonably comparable to other all time greats. But in the playoffs, the fact that Lebron is simultaneously the most versatile scorer ever, one of the most complete playmakers ever and one of the versatile defensive players ever, simultaneously gives Lebron's teams more options, while limiting their opponents'. Most people don't seem to understand the value of optionality.

Peak Lebron probably could've been a legitimate MVP-caliber player (in terms of true impact) while scoring around 12-15 points per game, by simply putting all of the energy on defense, rebounding and being a secondary/tertiary playmaker, while only ever scoring on layups, dunks and wide open 3's. In fact it's easy to construct many versions of Lebron, each only being capable of far less than what actual peak Lebron was capable of, and yet being able to play at an MVP-level. For instance, if Lebron never had the advanced passing skills and the incredible court vision that made him one of the best passers in NBA history and was more like a standard wing in that regard, he'd have scored quite a bit more in his career and would've led the league in scoring many more times. A lot of casuals would probably rate that version of Lebron higher than the actual Lebron.
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
05-13-2023 , 03:46 AM
Gotta give it to bron in this series, playing like the 2nd best player oat
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
05-13-2023 , 11:59 AM
He's played well but he's clearly lost a few steps.
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
05-13-2023 , 02:18 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by LuckyLloyd
New data:

LeBron with his 19th All NBA Selection from his 20 seasons.

Duncan, Kobe and Kareem joint 2nd with 15
Don't worry.

If LeBron loses this post season the morans will be back here gloating about how year 20 and 38 year old LeBron couldn't get it done.

Meanwhile Year 13 Jordan at 35 got it done! They will never compare age 38 Jordan to 38 Bron.

The goat posts will change.
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
05-13-2023 , 02:20 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by AllBlackDan
Gotta give it to bron in this series, playing like the 2nd best player oat
Give it up?


What the hell was age 38 jordan capable of?



A 38 year old bran can still GOAT it up. Maybe you fools need to redo your number 1 ranking.
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
05-13-2023 , 04:18 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tien
Give it up?





What the hell was age 38 jordan capable of?







A 38 year old bran can still GOAT it up. Maybe you fools need to redo your number 1 ranking.
2023 bro, surely I dont need to tell you the advances in science over the last 20 years?

Massive narcissism, talent, a no defence league and the most refined roids and programs known to man equals very high performance into older age, who knew?

Jordan in this era would have destroyed even harder imo
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
05-13-2023 , 04:25 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by AllBlackDan
2023 bro, surely I dont need to tell you the advances in science over the last 20 years?

Massive narcissism, talent, a no defence league and the most refined roids and programs known to man equals very high performance into older age, who knew?

Jordan in this era would have destroyed even harder imo
How many ****ing times are we going to get this counterfactual nonsense from Jordan-stans, who are completely ignorant about sports history? Lebron's longevity is even more impressive if you adjust it for era:

Quote:
Originally Posted by candybar
The thing that's truly amazing about Lebron's longevity, especially as it relates to his GOAT case, isn't just about the athleticism and taking care of your body and being great for so long. Dwight Howard is one year younger than Lebron and has aged fairly well physically. Yet, he went from a perennial MVP candidate to a role player who was benched for an entire playoff series. Even if you brought back peak Dwight Howard from the Orlando days, he would not be one of the top 30 players in the game right now. Not because peak Dwight Howard wasn't amazing but because the game has evolved.

If you look at other stars from his age cohort, part of the reason why most of them aren't even average players today has a lot to do with how the game has changed. Dwyane Wade can neither shoot 3s nor run a modern offense, which makes it difficult to build around him. Carmelo Anthony's iso-ball isn't efficient enough and his size-skill combination has become commoditized, while the evolution in defensive schemes made both his inability to read defenses and his own lack of defensive effort and skills quite problematic. Likewise, some of Dwight Howard's defensive skills have become obsolete due to the change in the game and Dwight Howard at his best never had the skills to run an efficient modern offense.

A lot of players that are much younger than Lebron that have already declined significantly also owe their declines more to the change in the game. Peak Westbrook relied on pushing pace and other players providing spacing, but now nearly every team pushes pace for extra efficiency and knows how to space and also defend against spacing, taking away Westbrook's strengths and leaving his own inability to shoot a glaring weakness. Kevin Love was one of the earlier versatile bigs to embrace 3-ball, which made him quite dangerous offensively, but his offensive value declined once everyone else could shoot 3's and his versatility became unimportant as the continued evolution of the game made his post game quite marginal without the advanced playmaking abilities which he lacked.

Conversely, many top players in MJ's age cohort played well into their mid-30's. The season after MJ retired (which would've been MJ's age-35 season), Karl Malone led the league in VORP at age 35, David Robinson was 7th at age 33, John Stockton was 13th at 36, Charles Barkley was 16th at 35, Reggie Miller was 20th at 33 and Hakeem Olajuwon was 21st at age 36 and Scottie Pippen was 23rd at 33. Out of top 50 players in 98-99 season, 17 were 32 or older and 8 were 35 or older. On the other hand, in the 2020-21 season, out of the top 50 players in VORP, just 4 were 32 or older and only Lebron was 35 or older.
Quote:
Originally Posted by candybar
Also MJ during his age 38 season wasn't just worse than Lebron at 38 - he was worse than some of his own peers. 2001-2002 BPM ranking for players 38 or older:

1. John Stockton (age 39): 5.3 BPM, 2566 MP
2. Karl Malone (age 38): 3.7 BPM, 3040 MP
3. Michael Jordan (age 38): 3.1 BPM, 2093 MP
4. Terry Porter (age 38): 1.7 BPM, 1294 MP
5. Hakeem Olajuwon (age 39): -0.4 BPM, 1378 MP
6. Johnny Newman (age 38): -2.6 BPM, 724 MP
7. Kevin Willis (age 39): -3.0 BPM, 865 MP
8. Patrick Ewing (age 39): -3.1 BPM, 901 MP
9. Sam Mitchell (age 38): -3.8 BPM, 726 MP
10. Charles Oakley (age 38): -5.1 BPM, 1383 MP

2022-2023 BPM ranking for players 38 or older:

1. Lebron James (Age 38): 6.1 BPM, 1954 MP
2. Andre Iguodala (Age 39): -2.8 BPM, 113 MP
3. Udonis Haslem (Age 42): -12.1 BPM, 71 MP

In other words, in MJ's age 38 season, he was one of 10 players that were playing regular minutes aged 38 or older and was 3rd in BPM. This season, Lebron was the only player his age or older playing regular minutes
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
05-13-2023 , 05:46 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by AllBlackDan
2023 bro, surely I dont need to tell you the advances in science over the last 20 years?

Massive narcissism, talent, a no defence league and the most refined roids and programs known to man equals very high performance into older age, who knew?

Jordan in this era would have destroyed even harder imo
Massive narcissism.....

His hall of fame speech shitting on all his coaches and teammates?

Jordan's apparent last dance documentary about 1998 season but somehow manages to bring 1994 season to crap on Pippen?

Punching Kerr in the face because Kerr told Jordan to go **** himself after Jordan bullied Kerr?

Ending his friendship with Charles Barkley because Charles rightfully criticized him for being an awful owner.

Lmfao. Narcissism.


Now his fan base will rewrite history and make 38 year old Jordan another mystique MVP level player in today's game.
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
05-13-2023 , 05:58 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tien
Jordan's apparent last dance documentary about 1998 season but somehow manages to bring 1994 season to crap on Pippen?
It was about every season from 1984 to 1998.
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
05-13-2023 , 07:08 PM
Candyblah

Of course scrubs dont have the narcissism level of Lebald or the talent in most cases, this is a big reason why they fizzled out early or didnt have the hunger to keep up their super-modern hormone schedules

You remind me of an obtuse Lebron sack-licking TWog with your red herring 'muh evidence' posts.

Last edited by AllBlackDan; 05-13-2023 at 07:14 PM.
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
05-13-2023 , 07:13 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tien
Massive narcissism.....

His hall of fame speech shitting on all his coaches and teammates?

Jordan's apparent last dance documentary about 1998 season but somehow manages to bring 1994 season to crap on Pippen?

Punching Kerr in the face because Kerr told Jordan to go **** himself after Jordan bullied Kerr?

Ending his friendship with Charles Barkley because Charles rightfully criticized him for being an awful owner.

Lmfao. Narcissism.


Now his fan base will rewrite history and make 38 year old Jordan another mystique MVP level player in today's game.
Tien

Nobody said Jordan was not a massive narc... This is one of the traits they both share and why they are numbers 1 and 2 in their fields. That was my point, with Leb's generational talent and narcissism coupled with modern tech, its expected he should perform at a high level till hes 40

His massive ego almost guarantees it..

Also if someone says Le'ego is not narcissistic, 2 words. The Decision

Last edited by AllBlackDan; 05-13-2023 at 07:22 PM.
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
05-13-2023 , 07:43 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by AllBlackDan
Of course scrubs dont have the narcissism level of Lebald or the talent in most cases, this is a big reason why they fizzled out early or didnt have the hunger to keep up their super-modern hormone schedules
In other words, you have no ****ing idea what you're talking about and concede that indeed, the gap in longevity between MJ and Lebron is larger once you adjust for context, given that MJ's peers have aged much better than Lebron's peers. Actually I'm not 100% sure that you were even able to process that. You don't sound particularly capable in that regard.

Quote:
You remind me of an obtuse Lebron sack-licking TWog with your red herring 'muh evidence' posts.
I am curious if you're this bad at processing information in real life or just on the internet.

Edit: I guess MJ was just a scrub that didn't have the hunger or the talent of John Stockton or Karl Malone that's why MJ wasn't as good as them at age 38.

Last edited by candybar; 05-13-2023 at 07:48 PM.
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
05-13-2023 , 07:52 PM
Candyblah the insufferable cherrypicking lesacklicker strikes again...

I do enjoy reading your delusional wanting posts though, adds to the glorious aids of this thread
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote

      
m