Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread
View Poll Results: GOAT?
labron
182 30.43%
MJ (Michael or Maple)
319 53.34%
Therapist
8 1.34%
George Mikan
5 0.84%
Shaq Attaq
21 3.51%
Wilt the Stilt (100 pts yo)
13 2.17%
Timmy "Big Fundamentals" Duncan
20 3.34%
"Roger Murdock"
3 0.50%
Enchanted AIDS Wang (er, HIV+?)
9 1.51%
Larry Legend (+ HM to Bill Russell's laugh)
18 3.01%

04-11-2023 , 08:12 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tien
Dennis Rodman only played 38 more games after 1998. I think running it back 1 more year means no Dennis Rodman.
Pippen fell off offensively as a player, no more all-nba team, but was still all-defensive 1st team.

They had maybe 1 more year's run in them, but it would have been done on the fumes of everyone's fumes at that point.
It was a shortened season due to the lockout. That would have worked in their favor.
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
04-11-2023 , 08:18 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Montrealcorp
I don’t know about u but does it make any sense to break a team that just complete a second 3 peat with the same coach and not waiting until he actually loses ?
After all the success the team did , didn’t they deserve the respect with the actual chance of failing in an attempt to 4 peat ?

Imho Mj must of been pretty piss and didn’t agree to the “vision” of the bulls anymore .
So I guess he retired instead of chasing rings.

Krause suffer the little man syndrome at the expense of the team success.
Iirc, Jordan didn't want to come back because Krause had said publicly he wasn't renewing Phil Jackson's contract and Jordan didn't want to play for a new coach. Then the lockout happened and Jordan retired rather than getting involved in that mess.

I think had Jordan, Pippen, Kukoc, a good PF, and Phil Jackson been given another chance, they might have been able to win 1 more, but it definitely wouldn't have been easy. Rodman likely wasn't coming back, as his shenanigans were crazy that last year and everyone was fed up with him by that point.
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
04-12-2023 , 04:24 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tien
Dennis Rodman only played 38 more games after 1998. I think running it back 1 more year means no Dennis Rodman.
Pippen fell off offensively as a player, no more all-nba team, but was still all-defensive 1st team.

They had maybe 1 more year's run in them, but it would have been done on the fumes of everyone's fumes at that point.
I just think you should go until you lose it.

Short season would have helped. Being that the 500 Knicks made the Finals can't see why the Bulls couldn't have got that far.
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
04-12-2023 , 11:23 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tien
The 1994 Bulls won 55 games. Quite impossible to call those Bulls anything less than a super team when Jordan was on it. They were also 1 bad ref call away from making western conf finals.


LeBron had 1 bad series out of like 30 playoff series.

And he had the greatest final 3 game stretch of all time in the finals against a GOAT team in 2016.

I measure players in totality of their entire career, not just 1 playoff series.

You wanna nit pick 1 series, so can I.
LeBrons series against the Warriors was tremendous, but I still believe Jordan's versus the Sun's in 93, specifically games 2, 3, and 4 since you mentioned 3 game stretch is better. Very difficult to argue against it.
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
04-12-2023 , 11:31 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tien
Paul Pierce and KG flipped and have Bron at GOAT after surpassing Kareem scoring. Their reasoning was how insanely difficult of an individual feat it was to do so and stack a lot of weight on it. Even LeBron's ex haters in the league flipped.

People that know what they are talking about put Bron #1. Those that still have nolstalgic bias put Jordan 1 and LeBron 2.

Meanwhile the Matt R. types still holding on to their baby blankets narratives. He gonna need chat gpt to come up with new narratives.
Do you believe that era makes a difference? Because if so, do you really believe LeBron is more feared than Jordan was in his era? Who dominated it more?

For me, that's pretty much what matters.
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
04-12-2023 , 12:49 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tien
Rodman made all defensive first team in 1996.

GP and Kemp? 2 guys together that could barely break 20ppg is the super team? Barkley and KJ? KJ made 3 all-star teams in his entire life. What kind of super team is that?



To me, Jordan not being good enough to get drafted at 18 eliminates Jordan from the GOAT consideration.

I can make up singular requirements too.
Ben Wallace made all defensive team in 2007. Of course, we know he was washed at 33 years old, the very next year, when he joined Lebron.
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
04-12-2023 , 12:51 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tien
No. 2015 hawks had 4 all stars. Was not a super team.





90's Bulls were a super team.

Super team = Multiple All Stars (typically)

Multiple All Star =/ Super team
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
04-12-2023 , 12:58 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tien
The 1994 Bulls won 55 games. Quite impossible to call those Bulls anything less than a super team when Jordan was on it. They were also 1 bad ref call away from making western conf finals.


LeBron had 1 bad series out of like 30 playoff series.

And he had the greatest final 3 game stretch of all time in the finals against a GOAT team in 2016.

I measure players in totality of their entire career, not just 1 playoff series.

You wanna nit pick 1 series, so can I.
Huh?! The Bulls went from 3 peat champs, to a 55 win team that got bounced in the second round ... while Pippen was in the process of blowing up the team with his temper tantrums and pouting. How did they look the next year before Jordan came back?
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
04-12-2023 , 03:24 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by VincentVega
LeBrons series against the Warriors was tremendous, but I still believe Jordan's versus the Sun's in 93, specifically games 2, 3, and 4 since you mentioned 3 game stretch is better. Very difficult to argue against it.
I don’t think it’s all that difficult to argue three elimination games on the trot to achieve something that had never been done before (while leading all players in all counting stats) as better tbh.
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
04-12-2023 , 07:03 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tien
The 1994 Bulls won 55 games. Quite impossible to call those Bulls anything less than a super team when Jordan was on it. They were also 1 bad ref call away from making western conf finals.


LeBron had 1 bad series out of like 30 playoff series.

And he had the greatest final 3 game stretch of all time in the finals against a GOAT team in 2016.

I measure players in totality of their entire career, not just 1 playoff series.

You wanna nit pick 1 series, so can I.

I just learned something new today btw!

2019 Raptors with Kawhi won the championship ... he leaves the next season AND THEY STILL WON 53 GAMES WITHOUT HIM!!!! SUPER TEAM!! Quite impossible to call them anything less!
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
04-12-2023 , 11:32 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by VanceAce
I just learned something new today btw!

2019 Raptors with Kawhi won the championship ... he leaves the next season AND THEY STILL WON 53 GAMES WITHOUT HIM!!!! SUPER TEAM!! Quite impossible to call them anything less!
Scottie Pippen in 1994 = 1st team all-nba and 1st team all defence. Was also 3rd in MVP votes.
Horace Grant made all-star in 1994

Super team with Jordan on it.


Any other top 5, top 10 players on that 2019 Raptors team? No? Ok.

Last edited by Tien; 04-12-2023 at 11:43 PM.
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
04-12-2023 , 11:34 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by VanceAce
Huh?! The Bulls went from 3 peat champs, to a 55 win team that got bounced in the second round ... while Pippen was in the process of blowing up the team with his temper tantrums and pouting. How did they look the next year before Jordan came back?
The team only won 55 games without Jordan and made the 2nd round! Bounced in the 2nd round = taking the Knicks (who made the finals) to 7 games, with 1 bad ref call away from making ECF.

What a bunch of scrubs Jordan had to play with!

Philly has the MVP Joel Embiid and James Harden and only managed to win 54 games this year!
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
04-12-2023 , 11:38 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by VincentVega
LeBrons series against the Warriors was tremendous, but I still believe Jordan's versus the Sun's in 93, specifically games 2, 3, and 4 since you mentioned 3 game stretch is better. Very difficult to argue against it.
Literally no one will ever put the Suns in the same stratosphere as the 2016 Warriors.

One of them was just a good team in the 90s, the other won 73 games and was 5 points in game 7 finals from being crowned the greatest team of all time.
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
04-12-2023 , 11:40 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by VincentVega
Do you believe that era makes a difference? Because if so, do you really believe LeBron is more feared than Jordan was in his era? Who dominated it more?

For me, that's pretty much what matters.
Jordan did not dominate the 80s when there were super teams galore.

Individually he was all time. But his team sucked. Then he got a great team around him in the early 90s and took off and there were no other great teams to challenge him like in the 80s or early 2000s.
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
04-13-2023 , 12:37 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tien
Scottie Pippen in 1994 = 1st team all-nba and 1st team all defence. Was also 3rd in MVP votes.
Horace Grant made all-star in 1994

Super team with Jordan on it.


Any other top 5, top 10 players on that 2019 Raptors team? No? Ok.
but mj wasnt on it when that happened in 94 ?
and u told me all stars means nothing for super team previously ?

u cant say they suck and are great at the same time ?
ie: orlando 1995 (with grant as a third option being an all star in 94) and they got swept in final but yet its a weak era ?

ps: fwiw pipen made all stars in 1990 (with no other accolade like 3rd team defensive or w.e) but no all star in 1991(tho he end up 2nd all nba defensive) when bulls won.
pippen really started to shine in 1992 but mj already won a ring vs team like lakers and beat detroit post season prior....
pippen and grant just got better over time

Last edited by Montrealcorp; 04-13-2023 at 12:45 AM.
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
04-13-2023 , 01:46 AM
Quote:
There has to be a point when this stops, right? When LeBron James stops looking like the best basketball player in the world? He’s 38, when most players are already years into making their own podcasts.


Yet there was James, hitting a game-tying 3 late in LA’s 108-102 overtime win, capping a monumental comeback for the Lakers. He then found Dennis Schröder for what should’ve been the game-winning 3 with just 1.4 seconds left. This was all part of James keeping the Lakers together after Anthony Davis inexplicably fouled Mike Conley Jr. — while shooting a 3 — with less than a second left, allowing the veteran guard to send the game to OT. Sheesh.
The Athletic
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
04-13-2023 , 02:17 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by anatta
The Athletic
Yeah look, I find this thread wild (I mean I always did, but it’s particularly mad these days) as one side of the coin refuses to moderate its position even a little bit despite watching a 38 year old LeBron be still one of the top transition scorers in the league. Still bringing a large bulk of his athleticism to the floor, at 38. And we can compare this to Jordan at the same age, and the difference is clear.

It’s just that it doesn’t dent things for the Jordan crew, at all. They just go back to talking about the stuff they’ve been talking about for years. ‘Who cares that LeBron got the scoring title and is gritting out 45 mins to lead the first ever 2 - 10 starting team to the playoffs; what about that Dallas series in 2011?’

They’re so dug in they’re missing it. And there can’t be much of it left.
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
04-13-2023 , 02:47 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by LuckyLloyd
Yeah look, I find this thread wild (I mean I always did, but it’s particularly mad these days) as one side of the coin refuses to moderate its position even a little bit despite watching a 38 year old LeBron be still one of the top transition scorers in the league. Still bringing a large bulk of his athleticism to the floor, at 38. And we can compare this to Jordan at the same age, and the difference is clear.

It’s just that it doesn’t dent things for the Jordan crew, at all. They just go back to talking about the stuff they’ve been talking about for years. ‘Who cares that LeBron got the scoring title and is gritting out 45 mins to lead the first ever 2 - 10 starting team to the playoffs; what about that Dallas series in 2011?’

They’re so dug in they’re missing it. And there can’t be much of it left.
i might be wrong but when i look with mj at 38 1st season with wizard years he played around the same amount of games and minutes per game as lebron this year.

relatively speaking mj would of been around 9th best scorer ppg in the league (in the year MJ played) while lebron would be around 7th this year.

now would mj had a better performance if he would have 1-2 hof on his team ? who knows.

Last edited by Montrealcorp; 04-13-2023 at 02:53 AM.
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
04-13-2023 , 04:24 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tien
Scottie Pippen in 1994 = 1st team all-nba and 1st team all defence. Was also 3rd in MVP votes.
Horace Grant made all-star in 1994

Super team with Jordan on it.


Any other top 5, top 10 players on that 2019 Raptors team? No? Ok.
Siakam did make All NBA second team the following year and finished Top 10 in the MVP. Lowry also an all star. So not the best post to prove a point.
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
04-13-2023 , 04:27 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by anatta
The Athletic
LeBon's still playing very well, but he obviously doesn't look like the best player in basketball anymore and no sane person would say otherwise.
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
04-13-2023 , 04:32 AM
MJ at 38 obviously not as good as LeBron at 38, though he was playing well before he got injured.

How much of that is modern science is a good question. Like there's a half dozen players in the NBA who shouldn't be doing what they are doing at their ages at the moment.

e.g. Steph at 6 foot nothing shouldn't be doing what he's doing at 35.
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
04-13-2023 , 07:28 AM
I’ll preface this by saying that there was nothing wrong with MJ’s Wizard return, really. He held his own and was capable of getting hot as a late career Kobe like chucker. MJ is incredible and coming back in his late thirties and playing like he did added to that greatness.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Montrealcorp
i might be wrong but when i look with mj at 38 1st season with wizard years he played around the same amount of games and minutes per game as lebron this year.

relatively speaking mj would of been around 9th best scorer ppg in the league (in the year MJ played) while lebron would be around 7th this year.

now would mj had a better performance if he would have 1-2 hof on his team ? who knows.
But like it’s a weird stretch here in terms of trying to draw MJ’s age 38 season as close to LeBron’s. Minutes were similar, which allows for a relevant comparison.

In terms of per game totals:

LeBron per game (MJ in brackets): 28.9ppg (22.9) 6.8apg (5.2) 8.3trb (5.7) 0.9spg (1.4) 0.6bpg (0.4)

Advanced metrics:


LeBron (MJ) PER: 23.9 (20.7) TS%: .583 (.468) USG: 33.3 (36) VORP 4.0 (2.7)

So yeah, MJ was asked to carry the load a little more than LeBron, but was less efficient and productive in every way we can measure that. He was managing half a steal more than LeBron per game and had more defensive win shares (3.4 MJ to 2.4 LBJ) - however that wasn’t contributing to a better overall team outcome as Washington were 21st of 29 teams in DRTG, LA have surprisingly been 11th of 30 this year.

But like I shouldn’t even need to list all of this. The eye test tells you what you need to know about these players at this age. LeBron is much more like what he was at his best, including the completely mad reality of being second in transition scoring only to Giannis before his ankle injury against the Mavs. At 38. Get out of here.

This should matter to the debate, that seems obvious to me. You can choose to prioritise peak if you like and you can focus on that unbeaten record in the finals. But LeBron objectively has the better overall career, superior longevity. Indeed he’s redefining what we might expect from a multiple league MVP as they age towards 40. That we’re getting to see these players compare at age 38 should be highly relevant to this conversation. It’s new data in a debate that has needed new data for years.
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
04-13-2023 , 07:42 AM
I would say that MJ was more like a higher volume Larry Hughes at 38. 468ts had to be a net negative on the team.
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
04-13-2023 , 08:52 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tien
Scottie Pippen in 1994 = 1st team all-nba and 1st team all defence. Was also 3rd in MVP votes.
Horace Grant made all-star in 1994

Super team with Jordan on it.


Any other top 5, top 10 players on that 2019 Raptors team? No? Ok.
Ahh yes, it always comes back to good old 1 time career all-star Horace Grant! How could Jordan not win with all that "talent"!

If you like all-nba's, all-defense, and MVP votes -- you must have LOVED that 93 Suns team!

MVP Barkley
4X All-NBA, Kevin Johnson (also finished 7th in MVP votes in 91)
All-Defense, & 3X all-star Dan Majerle
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
04-13-2023 , 09:01 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by fidstar-poker
Siakam did make All NBA second team the following year and finished Top 10 in the MVP. Lowry also an all star. So not the best post to prove a point.
Did the Raptors have 1 time all-star Horace Grant, though?!

No Horace Grant = No Super Team

Those are just the facts!
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote

      
m