I’ll preface this by saying that there was nothing wrong with MJ’s Wizard return, really. He held his own and was capable of getting hot as a late career Kobe like chucker. MJ is incredible and coming back in his late thirties and playing like he did added to that greatness.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Montrealcorp
i might be wrong but when i look with mj at 38 1st season with wizard years he played around the same amount of games and minutes per game as lebron this year.
relatively speaking mj would of been around 9th best scorer ppg in the league (in the year MJ played) while lebron would be around 7th this year.
now would mj had a better performance if he would have 1-2 hof on his team ? who knows.
But like it’s a weird stretch here in terms of trying to draw MJ’s age 38 season as close to LeBron’s. Minutes were similar, which allows for a relevant comparison.
In terms of per game totals:
LeBron per game (MJ in brackets): 28.9ppg (22.9) 6.8apg (5.2) 8.3trb (5.7) 0.9spg (1.4) 0.6bpg (0.4)
Advanced metrics:
LeBron (MJ) PER: 23.9 (20.7) TS%: .583 (.468) USG: 33.3 (36) VORP 4.0 (2.7)
So yeah, MJ was asked to carry the load a little more than LeBron, but was less efficient and productive in every way we can measure that. He was managing half a steal more than LeBron per game and had more defensive win shares (3.4 MJ to 2.4 LBJ) - however that wasn’t contributing to a better overall team outcome as Washington were 21st of 29 teams in DRTG, LA have surprisingly been 11th of 30 this year.
But like I shouldn’t even need to list all of this. The
eye test tells you what you need to know about these players at this age. LeBron is much more like what he was at his best, including the completely mad reality of being second in transition scoring only to Giannis before his ankle injury against the Mavs. At 38. Get out of here.
This should matter to the debate, that seems obvious to me. You can choose to prioritise peak if you like and you can focus on that unbeaten record in the finals. But LeBron objectively has the better overall career, superior longevity. Indeed he’s redefining what we might expect from a multiple league MVP as they age towards 40. That we’re getting to see these players compare at age 38 should be highly relevant to this conversation. It’s new data in a debate that has needed new data for years.