Quote:
Originally Posted by PairTheBoard
Not all unintended slights are all that unintended. You technically object over there so you can avoid the main point right in front of you.
PairTheBoard
It's not just a technicality, most microaggressions (at least the ones being objected to) are much more like your first example, they're honest mistakes that are blown way out of proportion. Nobody is arguing that telling anyone, much less a minority, to go home and get his shine box wouldn't be highly offensive.
Quote:
Originally Posted by PairTheBoard
This shows how the bs "victimhood" narrative is essential to your position. It ignores the fact that the insult in microaggressions is of a different nature than the normal social friction in polite society. They are just more subtle than being called the N word or the F word or the C word. You would not claim overreaction or victimhood at the response to those slurs. And you would understand if those insults were considered insults to honor.
What you refuse to recognize is that the insult in microaggressions is of the same nature only at a more subtle level. They are also an insult to honor not only for the individual but for the group. The question of intent does not change that fact. Ignorance is no excuse. A vigorous response is therefore not overreacting and neither is it playing the victim. The fact that the response is nonviolent should be praised rather than ridiculed.
PairTheBoard
Ignorance is definitely an excuse. If I made a dumb joke that ended with "but you **** one goat!" not knowing that your mother died while being ****ed by a goat, it's an unfortunate situation. I'd probably forgive you for punching me though, and we'd move on. (hey, is this where "punch line" comes from?)
The first example you gave is much more like what is being criticized about overreactions to microaggressions, ie, people looking very hard for reasons to get upset. Furthermore, in an honor culture, it would not be acceptible to shoot someone in the foot over a mixed up drink order. Tommy
dishonored himself by overreacting, making a mountain out of a molehill, and even his peers recognized it. Similarly guys like fly dishonor themselves by overreacting, often simply making **** up to be "offended" about, and most of his peers recognize that too. Then again, most of them are about as dishonorable as he is, so they cheer him on.