Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Should pit bull owners be allowed to breed? Should pit bull owners be allowed to breed?
View Poll Results: Should pitbulls be allowed to breed
Yes
391 46.88%
No
290 34.77%
Yes but only if you have to have a special license to own one
153 18.35%

05-19-2011 , 06:32 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by gobbo
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Pit_Bull_Terrier

I do think they should be allowed to breed, but honestly I think it should be illegal for someone without a special license to breed dogs. There are way too many dogs out there already and people have no clue what they're doing.
Today my youngest sister calls me and says she found a very young Rat Terrier by the side of the road, and asks me if she can drop it off for a night.

Dog is skin and bones, and very small and probably less than 8 weeks old. ****ing ******s breed dogs and don't give a ****. And other people have to pick up their mess.

That said, can the people who like this breed in this thread explain why they like them?



They're ****ing ugly. Looks like a giant penis with legs.



These things hold the distinction for just about the only breed of dogs that I don't like. They have absolutely no qualities that are endearing; they are dumb as a rock, they aren't really that loyal (compared to a lab or other large dogs) , they are butt ugly, they were bred for something that is illegal, etc.

I've been around dozens of GSDs, Boxers, and other guard dogs, but they're the only dog that consistently growls/snarls at me (especially in the presence of their owner) when I'm trying to be friendly. Usually the other breeds are intelligent enough to tell friend from foe lol but not pitts.

Doesn't mean they should be illegal obviously, but I just don't understand why some people like them so much if not for their reputation.

Last edited by Whippersnapper; 05-19-2011 at 06:43 PM.
Should pit bull owners be allowed to breed? Quote
05-19-2011 , 10:44 PM
Ridgeback derail:

Quote:
Originally Posted by Whippersnapper
Get a real dog. Like one of these:
They can stand their ground against pits, especially the males which often weigh around 125-135lbs. Raised to track lions and other African wild game and to defend themselves (as a pack) against them. My dad had one of these growing up and related a story where a guy left two pits in the back of a pickup, they both got out and attacked his Ridgeback. The ridgeback killed one and maimed the other.

They just are far more loyal, intelligent, and way less psychotic.

This one is a female, probably weighs 75lbs and she's just shy of one year old. She's incredibly intelligent, very timid, and shy yet playful. Very stubborn though, almost like a child.

She grabs the cushions from my patio chairs and drags them into the yard so that she can sit on them and sunbathe. I went outside one morning and I saw my chair sitting in the middle of my yard with her on it, facing the sun. Total wtf moment.

She's able to open every door in my house, inward and outward, gets into my trashcan (with a push lid), and I even caught her trying to open my refrigerator door. I've seen other dogs push open doors, but I've never seen a dog that can swing a door open outward. She puts a paw on the wall, a paw on the handle, swipes the handle while pushing herself off the wall.

Well ... I take that back. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QAAigmN_mTQ

This is a picture of a male. As you can see, they're usually larger and much more muscular, usually weighing about 60-90% more than the females. The reason I got a female is their size, you think a 45lb pit bull is a problem? A 130lb dog can be a pain in the ass to deal with if you aren't living in the country.


**** pits IMO, way better choices of pets out there.
How do ridgebacks handle the cold? I was looking to get one last fall to replace my 13 yr old shepherd/wolf farm dog and I need something that can handle packs of coyotes. It frequently is -30c and occasionally dips to -40c in the winter here. I thought the ridgeback's lack of hair might make it unsuitable for this kind of work. I don't want another shepherd, as my current dog's hips are totally shot, and I don't want to deal with that again. The ridgeback was the only large dog I could find with no really common health issues, so it was at the top of my list.
Should pit bull owners be allowed to breed? Quote
05-20-2011 , 12:55 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Whippersnapper
Doesn't mean they should be illegal obviously, but I just don't understand why some people like them so much if not for their reputation.
People typically like dogs they grew up with or around and when they're kids they generally only see the good things about them. Also because of all the media hype about how vicious these dogs are, huge idiots think "oh pit bulls would be good guard dogs" so get them and treat them like ****. Pit bulls are NOT good guard dogs, they were bred specifically to not be good guard dogs. But now there are so many pit-like mutts out there that are essentially dog and people aggressive, unless people really know what they're doing the dog can be a time bomb.

I see it as pretty much impossible to happen but I really wish they'd make it illegal to sell dogs unless you get approved by something like the AKC.
Should pit bull owners be allowed to breed? Quote
05-20-2011 , 03:48 AM
Gobbo, the best way I know how to put it is that the concept of certain breeds being naturally 'dog-aggressive' or 'human-aggressive' is outdated and refuted science and it not so coincidentally falls in line with how people in the early 1900s and before viewed genetics in all species, mainly humans. Even the pro-pitbull and pro-big-scary-dog people have been slow in catching up. Basically their hands have been forced in trying to defend breeds against breed-specific-banning legislation and the people saying all along that 'nurture has much more do to with dog disposition than nature' have found out that nature has even less impact that they previously thought.
Should pit bull owners be allowed to breed? Quote
05-20-2011 , 04:08 AM
Suzzer,

This thread led me to read more about dog legislation in non-US countries and it seems like the US is the only place with this pit-bull type dog fixation. Other countries just lump the pitbull in with all the other big, strong and potentially dangerous dogs.
I know this thread started with you talking about pitbulls specifically but I believe your stance changed to reflect all potentially dangerous dogs? (correct me if I'm wrong) If so, it can't be denied you have a point, in the sense that if a toy poodle decided to spaz out the damage would be far less than a pitbull/rottweiler/mastiff/presa/husky/etc doing the same. I was frustrated with the 'pro-pit' people earlier using comparisons with poodles and the like. It's not that they don't have a point, it's that the point is not the one being debated. Obviously a pitbull should be compared to other dogs of equal and greater size and strength.
I am the proud caretake of a half staffordshire/rhodesian ridgeback (definitely a pitbull-type-dog) but I would not be opposed to legislation banning all big strong dangerous dogs, especially if it cut down on the abuse and neglect of all these dogs out here with broken homes and no homes. My frustration is of a very fundamental scientific nature when seeing pitbulls singled out for pseudo-scientific reasons, and I'm sure most 'pro-pit' people would agree.
Should pit bull owners be allowed to breed? Quote
05-20-2011 , 04:22 AM
p.s. I was being playful with my phrasing, "Plus, 'pitbull' is not even a real thing," and didn't bother to edit when I read the topic had already been discussed. To clarify, I mean 'pitbull' is an unofficial grouping name for a handful of specific breeds and countless other half and quarter breeds. The fact that there is a breed called the 'amercian pit bull terrier' causes some confusion but APBTs are only a fraction of the total pitbulls.
Plus, like you say there are many pitbulls mixed with bigger and scarier dogs but just as many mixed with 'nice dogs', and they are all called pitbulls. For example, scroll down to Enumclaw, Washington on this page,
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Breed-s..._Legislation_2
and you'll see this,
Quote:
“Pit bull dog” means any dog over the age of six months known by the owner to be a Pit Bull Terrier. Pit Bull Terrier shall mean any Bull Terrier, American Pit Bull Terrier, or Staffordshire Bull Terrier or American Staffordshire Terrier breed of dog or any mixed breed of dog which contains as an element of its breeding the breed of Bull Terrier, American Pit Bull Terrier, Staffordshire Bull Terrier or American Staffordshire Terrier so as to be identifiable as partially of the breed Bull Terrier, American Pit Bull Terrier, Staffordshire Bull Terrier or American Staffordshire Terrier.

It is unlawful to keep, or harbor, own or in any way possess a pit bull dog within the city.
That's basically every snub-nosed dog.


Quote:
Originally Posted by gobbo
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Pit_Bull_Terrier

I've followed this discussion over on the somethingawful forums and the summation from it I've gathered is this.

Pitbulls/APBT were originally bred to be dog fighting dogs and have absolutely no chance whatsoever to bite a human. The second any of them attacked a human they would be killed and they were always breeding the least human aggressive ones of the bunch, so eventually the breed itself was one of the safest dogs you could have around humans. They are, however, bred to be dog aggressive so that instinct is still there.

The problem was that idiots started breeding them with little or no selection and so the human aggressive ones were still breeding, AND they would purposefully crossbreed them with dogs that were bred to be guard dogs that are human aggressive like rottweilers and mastiffs. It doesn't help when most people who want some badass pitbull guard dog leave them outside, don't socialize them, beat them, malnourish them, and don't train them whatsoever and expect them to be perfect little angels.

I do think they should be allowed to breed, but honestly I think it should be illegal for someone without a special license to breed dogs. There are way too many dogs out there already and people have no clue what they're doing.
Should pit bull owners be allowed to breed? Quote
05-20-2011 , 04:29 AM
Chump Change's posts makes me wonder, why hasnt there been a thread on legislation for human breeding and caps on how many kids 1 person can have?


Nothing in this world is more violent then the human animal. No being can end more lives then the human. As the world is filled with more and more humans each life is made that much more worthless. Each crowded population makes the world worse. Ill stop now cuz wrong thread ect......
Should pit bull owners be allowed to breed? Quote
05-20-2011 , 05:08 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by demon102
Chump Change's posts makes me wonder, why hasnt there been a thread on legislation for human breeding and caps on how many kids 1 person can have?


Nothing in this world is more violent then the human animal. No being can end more lives then the human. As the world is filled with more and more humans each life is made that much more worthless. Each crowded population makes the world worse. Ill stop now cuz wrong thread ect......
That's way too depressing... Instead, let's watch this video of pitbull mixed with a weiner dog:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BmJDA...eature=related
Should pit bull owners be allowed to breed? Quote
05-20-2011 , 11:08 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Chump Change
Gobbo, the best way I know how to put it is that the concept of certain breeds being naturally 'dog-aggressive' or 'human-aggressive' is outdated and refuted science and it not so coincidentally falls in line with how people in the early 1900s and before viewed genetics in all species, mainly humans. Even the pro-pitbull and pro-big-scary-dog people have been slow in catching up. Basically their hands have been forced in trying to defend breeds against breed-specific-banning legislation and the people saying all along that 'nurture has much more do to with dog disposition than nature' have found out that nature has even less impact that they previously thought.
Seems like such a line to draw. Some breeds clearly have huge behavior tendencies, why is it so hard for part of it to be aggression based? Nurture > nature for sure but there are some things it'll be 100x as hard to take out as others. My dachshund barks. It's what they do. He's decent at stopping if I tell him to quiet down but it's going to take a lot more training before he does it consistently. Some breeds don't bark at all. Why draw the line at everything else but not dog/human aggression?
Should pit bull owners be allowed to breed? Quote
12-13-2011 , 04:56 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Whippersnapper



Is it because pits are inherently more dangerous? I doubt it. I just think there are a lot less dumb**** Neapolitan Mastiff owners since it's a niche breed. The wiki says their skin is loose like that to aid them in fighting due to less chance of injury, de-sensitization of pain, and a more difficult target. I thought that was pretty cool and didn't know that.
But if rapper dbags start putting them in music videos looking tuff and kewl then other pos dbags will want to have one, and then there goes the breed.
Should pit bull owners be allowed to breed? Quote
12-13-2011 , 05:19 PM
locking jaws tho
Should pit bull owners be allowed to breed? Quote
12-13-2011 , 05:42 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Whippersnapper

That said, can the people who like this breed in this thread explain why they like them?


They're ****ing ugly. Looks like a giant penis with legs.

That's just like, your opinion, man.

I actually think most pits are quite beautiful.
Should pit bull owners be allowed to breed? Quote
12-13-2011 , 06:00 PM
She doesn't bark when people knock on the door, ring the bell, or just walk in. She just lies there. So, if you break into my place, please take her outside so she doesn't poop under the tree again.



Uploaded with ImageShack.us
Should pit bull owners be allowed to breed? Quote
12-13-2011 , 06:28 PM
since this is the thread about lame dog stories, i share mine as well:

when I was like 10 years old, the german shepherd of a friend starts chasing me without a reason.(we were playing outside). I run for my life, as fast as possible, like 200 yards until i stumble and fall. I made my last prayers knowing i would die now. Luckily it seemed like the dog already gave up long ago. Most scary moment of my life.
Should pit bull owners be allowed to breed? Quote
12-13-2011 , 07:21 PM
they can't chase you if you don't run
Should pit bull owners be allowed to breed? Quote
12-13-2011 , 07:32 PM
My only experiences with Pit Bulls are bad ones. A neighbor kid's family had a pit bull, which got out and bit 2 kids. Another guy a couple blocks down also had one. Scared the hell out of me and I avoided those places at all costs when I was out and about. There seem to be more than are wanted though, which would be the main reason for limiting their breeding. A local shelter here is usually just loaded full of pit bulls that people bring in.
Should pit bull owners be allowed to breed? Quote
12-13-2011 , 10:12 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by BuckyK
She doesn't bark when people knock on the door, ring the bell, or just walk in. She just lies there.
That's the pit bull MO - zero warning and then... straight for the jugular!
Should pit bull owners be allowed to breed? Quote
12-13-2011 , 10:38 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by amplify
by far the most vicious, mean, ill-tempered, poorly-behaved, rabid ass hole dogs I see are chihuahuas. i hate those little ****ers.
It's Funny
Should pit bull owners be allowed to breed? Quote
12-13-2011 , 10:54 PM
Pit Bull bit my sister a few months back. The owners were all "oh, she never has hurt anyone, you probably scared her." A few months after that, it bites and maims a child. Good job, dumbasses.
Should pit bull owners be allowed to breed? Quote
12-13-2011 , 11:11 PM
In Palmdale, CA last month 4 pit bulls got in with a herd of goats and killed* 42 of them.

*including the mauled ones that were put down
Should pit bull owners be allowed to breed? Quote
12-13-2011 , 11:42 PM
Holy ****.
Should pit bull owners be allowed to breed? Quote
12-14-2011 , 09:41 AM
imagine if that was a herd of children!!!
Should pit bull owners be allowed to breed? Quote
12-14-2011 , 10:52 AM
Looking forward to onslaught of pit bull apologists ITT in 3..2..1..
Should pit bull owners be allowed to breed? Quote
12-14-2011 , 03:29 PM
How many 5 year olds could one pit bull take?
Should pit bull owners be allowed to breed? Quote

      
m