Quote:
Originally Posted by Wilbury Twist
I am what many people would probably refer to as a "libtard," but when it comes to guns, I actually do mostly adhere to the "good guy with a gun" narrative*.
As such, I feel a bit safer in a place with reasonable CCW laws. Maybe I'm being naive, and I'm open to see some stats that will force me to rethink this, but I generally think a given person – e.g. the unstable, angry-tempered player in ECB's example – is less likely to pull something if he/she knows any given person in the room might be carrying.
Purely anecdotally, have there been many casino shootings in recent years? It's kind of hard to look up via Google, since most searches will yield the Route 91 concert incident outside Mandalay Bay four years ago.
Also, gotta agree with dude45: I don't oppose allowing casinos to honor the state CCW laws, but I also don't imagine it changes anything, what with any decent room having security. (Of course, that might be as naive as anything else I've said in this post – we've seen plenty of other incidents that make us ask, "Wait, where the hell was security when this happened??")
*For those of you who don't follow the U.S. political landscape, the stereotype is that liberals also want to disarm all other citizens. It's a subject we shouldn't get into too much per NVG rules. Just wanted to point it out, and in fairness, the stereotype of the "pro-gun" crowd also gets oversimplified quite a bit.
This is a pretty reasonable take on the issue, but I *think* I disagree with you. I'm of the mindset that I'd personally feel comfortable carrying a gun for myself (I don't fwiw), but I believe less guns in general is safer.
The idea is that introducing guns at all into the equation allows for the ability to escalate a benign situation into a deadly one. Even in your example, I believe most people would pull a gun out due to emotional distress, something that's not often deterred from others having guns. This could result in a shootout.
If the argument is that some people will carry guns anyway, therefore we should level the playing field to deter them from use -- that's fair, but I'd still argue that casino's already have security, so it would not be a planned use often at all, it would still be purely an emotional reaction, and if somebody in a rage pulls out a gun, having 5 others pull out a gun in response guarantees a shootout whereas there's a decent chance the aggressor will calm down if not antagonized further.
Anywho, it could play out a million different ways, but I believe adding more guns will end up with more overall deaths if we ran the sims.