Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
What is your definition of racism? What is your definition of racism?

01-02-2023 , 12:38 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by chillrob
You're welcome to have that opinion, but since it has nothing to do with this thread I think we can now let it go. I already knew that you didn't appreciate my views.

Also, maybe you missed it, but in the moderation thread, our new mod has asked that people not bring up old things that people have previously said. I almost just reported your original comment about me; I decided to reply to show how that has nothing to do with this thread, but we've both had our say so let's stop the derail.
Thanks. The religion forum is --------->
What is your definition of racism? Quote
01-02-2023 , 01:29 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by shortstacker
So, roughly 95% of Mexicans seeking citizenship in the U.S. should be denied based solely on the fact that they practice religion?

Certainly seems like "backdoor" racism to me.

Most white Western-Europeans are atheist/agnostic, so at least most white people from there won't have a problem with attaining U.S. citizenship.
Correct
What is your definition of racism? Quote
01-02-2023 , 03:43 AM
- jared taylor

why are they allowed to invite this guy to one of my uni classes at penn law? (University of Pennsylvania)

why do I have to listen to him??
I call bs!

that is the definition of racism.

Last edited by browser2920; 01-02-2023 at 04:07 AM. Reason: Deleted racist quote
What is your definition of racism? Quote
01-02-2023 , 04:01 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by washoe
- jared taylor

why are they allowed to invite this guy to one of my uni classes at penn law? (University of Pennsylvania)

why do I have to listen to him??
I call bs!

that is the definition of racism.
You have to listen to him? Are you taking a class that said you have to go listen to him?
What is your definition of racism? Quote
01-02-2023 , 04:06 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by washoe
- jared taylor

why are they allowed to invite this guy to one of my uni classes at penn law? (University of Pennsylvania)

why do I have to listen to him??
I call bs!

that is the definition of racism.
I deleted the quote as it was just a pure piece of racist propaganda by a well known racist speaker and we arent going to repost that sort of material here. I understand you were giving an example of his racist remarks, but we need ti keep that stuff off.

I am curious. When did he speak at Penn State? Did hespeak to a class or give a lecture to anyone who wantedto attend? Was he invited bythe university or some rightwing group?

I ask bc I see he still speaks at colleges, usually invited some republican or right wing student group. Then it becomes a freedom of speech issue as to whether the school should allow him to speak his racist stuff.
What is your definition of racism? Quote
01-02-2023 , 04:06 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by chillrob
You have to listen to him? Are you taking a class that said you have to go listen to him?

No, I mean if you took a class there and she was your prof you would have to listen to him.
I used "you" so you undertand that you would be forced to listen to this. how is that flying?
What is your definition of racism? Quote
01-02-2023 , 04:09 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by browser2920
I deleted the quote as it was just a pure piece of racist propaganda by a well known racist speaker and we arent going to repost that sort of material here. I understand you were giving an example of his racist remarks, but we need ti keep that stuff off.

I am curious. When did he speak at Penn State? Did hespeak to a class or give a lecture to anyone who wantedto attend? Was he invited bythe university or some rightwing group?

I ask bc I see he still speaks at colleges, usually invited some republican or right wing student group. Then it becomes a freedom of speech issue as to whether the school should allow him to speak his racist stuff.

I understood that. good call I think. that quote is from the linked article and gives information about this guy. I got outraged, when reasearching amy wax, who invited him to his class. couldnt you sue her as one of her students? why is she not layd off? I mean this is is supposed to be one of the best schools you have there.

and btw that jared talyor himself is allowed to teach english at havard, which is equally unbelievable.

Last edited by washoe; 01-02-2023 at 04:15 AM.
What is your definition of racism? Quote
01-02-2023 , 04:11 AM
I deleted another post that essentially was a summary of all the racist stuff that was put out at that class. . We don't allow the posting of racist views on the website. Just because you may be quoting a racist speaker and then saying it's bad doesnt mean you can in fact post all that hate speech.
What is your definition of racism? Quote
01-02-2023 , 04:13 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by shortstacker

Most white Western-Europeans are atheist/agnostic, so at least most white people from there won't have a problem with attaining U.S. citizenship.
As in 50.1%+ ?
U have any data to support that claim ?
What is your definition of racism? Quote
01-02-2023 , 04:20 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by browser2920
I deleted another post that essentially was a summary of all the racist stuff that was put out at that class. . We don't allow the posting of racist views on the website. Just because you may be quoting a racist speaker and then saying it's bad doesnt mean you can in fact post all that hate speech.

I understand the problem, you should be allowed to post the link at least imo, as it is the opposite of racism, it is to expose amy wax and her racism, somehow you need to explain what she said to undertand the problem.


its all from the website https://abovethelaw.com/ which is a law website. here is their about site:


Spoiler:
About

By Breaking Media Share
/ Mar 8, 2010 at 8:37 PM

Above the Law takes a behind-the-scenes look at the world of law. The site provides news and insights about the profession’s most colorful personalities and powerful institutions, as well as original commentary on breaking legal developments. Above the Law is published by Breaking Media.
What is your definition of racism? Quote
01-02-2023 , 04:34 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by washoe
I understand the problem, you should be allowed to post the link at least imo, as it is the opposite of racism, it is to expose amy wax and her racism, somehow you need to explain what she said to undertand the problem.


its all from the website https://abovethelaw.com/ which is a law website. here is their about site:


Spoiler:
About

By Breaking Media Share
/ Mar 8, 2010 at 8:37 PM

Above the Law takes a behind-the-scenes look at the world of law. The site provides news and insights about the profession’s most colorful personalities and powerful institutions, as well as original commentary on breaking legal developments. Above the Law is published by Breaking Media.
The website per se is ok. But we don't allow links to articles filled with racist propaganda ,even if the author then says its bad. It's just like not putting it in here. We don't allow anything that facilitates connections to racist material. Anyone interested in digging deeper can easily google the topic and a lot of articles come up about Amy Wax and the Jared Taylor visit.

So a post informing us about Jared Taylors visit to Penn Law and questioning the appropriateness of it is fine. And saying he is a well known white supremacist speaker is fine. We just don't want a listing of his racist views on here.
What is your definition of racism? Quote
01-02-2023 , 04:41 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by browser2920
The website per se is ok. But we don't allow links to articles filled with racist propaganda ,even if the author then says its bad. It's just like not putting it in here. We don't allow anything that facilitates connections to racist material. Anyone interested in digging deeper can easily google the topic and a lot of articles come up about Amy Wax and the Jared Taylor visit.

So a post informing us about Jared Taylors visit to Penn Law and questioning the appropriateness of it is fine. And saying he is a well known white supremacist speaker is fine. We just don't want a listing of his racist views on here.
ok yes that is making sense. apologies, so yes in the same sense I dont think any of the students of amy wax should get forced to listen or be exposed to this stuff. they should have the simliar rules in place, which they obviously do not. so screw pennsylvania state and harvard?

for me yes, that is a clear no go.
What is your definition of racism? Quote
01-02-2023 , 05:10 AM
add ASU to the list and sign this petition if you can.

titled
Fire Racist Penn Law Professor, Amy Wax

she would get fired from 2+2 why not here?

https://www.change.org/p/university-...fessor-amy-wax
What is your definition of racism? Quote
01-02-2023 , 05:29 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by shortstacker
I created this thread to capture a discussion breaking out in the mod thread. A lot of the concern expressed over modding relate to the question of what is racism and how will we identify it in posts. Also, what constitutes talking about racism vs posting racist views. I'd like to hear your thoughts ITT about how to topic should be addressed and give examples. I'll start by moving the other posts over and we can take it from there.

Due to the way posts are moved by date my opening thread post actually is several posts down. So I inserted these comments here.

Browser



Here are a couple of definitions as "food for thought:"

Racism: Asserting or implying that some races are in some important sense either superior or inferior to other races.

Sexism: Asserting or implying that some sexes/genders/orientations are in some important sense superior or inferior to other sexes/genders/orientations.
Ideological racism: The explicit ideology that races exist and that some are superior to others. This idea usually coupled with ideas that a race war is necessary, imminent or unavoidable. Examples would be supremacist views, Nazism.

Explicit racism: Actions taken or words used to favor one race or ethnicity because of preference. Not necessarily hinged on the idea that this and that race are superior, but typically more on dislike of the outgroup. Examples would be nationalism, xenophobia

Implicit racism: Actions taken or words used that create or continue unfair divisions between races or ethnicities. Examples would be the typical difficulties many minority groups face when applying for jobs, renting a place to live, being negatively stereotyped in media etc.

I would say that the word discrimination is often an excellent tool to use for many of the debates that crop on subjects related to racism. It is broader term, less loaded and often more useful. Affirmative action for example, is a discriminatory practice, but it is not a racist one.
What is your definition of racism? Quote
01-02-2023 , 05:42 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by tame_deuces
I would say that the word discrimination is often an excellent tool to use for many of the debates that crop on subjects related to racism. It is broader term, less loaded and often more useful. Affirmative action for example, is a discriminatory practice, but it is not a racist one.
What would you think if a black nationalist group somehow took control of the US government and instituted "Affirmative Action" hiring processes which favored blacks over whites: still not racist?
What is your definition of racism? Quote
01-02-2023 , 05:55 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by chillrob
What would you think if a black nationalist group somehow took control of the US government and instituted "Affirmative Action" hiring processes which favored blacks over whites: still not racist?
If the motivation is rooted in an ideological view of a race as inferior, as a view that it is necessary or preferable to hold a race down or it perpetuates unfair divisions in society based on race, I say go ahead and use the R-word. Admittedly the last one is so broad that it should be used with care. If you want to be unreasonable when using that one, arguments would quickly become pretty tiresome.

Discriminatory practices are not necessary unreasonable or bad on the other hand. They can be, but it is not a given. For example if you want to be a firefighter, then you need to be able to carry a certain load over a certain distance and walk with it upstairs / climb with it in ladders. This is a discriminatory practice which favors men, but it is not in itself a sexist practice. However, it does not take a genius to see that it could cross that line and be abused as a sexist practice if controlled by the wrong people.
What is your definition of racism? Quote
01-02-2023 , 05:58 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by tame_deuces
Ideological racism: The explicit ideology that races exist and that some are superior to others. This idea usually coupled with ideas that a race war is necessary, imminent or unavoidable. Examples would be supremacist views, Nazism.

Explicit racism: Actions taken or words used to favor one race or ethnicity because of preference. Not necessarily hinged on the idea that this and that race are superior, but typically more on dislike of the outgroup. Examples would be nationalism, xenophobia

Implicit racism: Actions taken or words used that create or continue unfair divisions between races or ethnicities. Examples would be the typical difficulties many minority groups face when applying for jobs, renting a place to live, being negatively stereotyped in media etc.

I would say that the word discrimination is often an excellent tool to use for many of the debates that crop on subjects related to racism. It is broader term, less loaded and often more useful. Affirmative action for example, is a discriminatory practice, but it is not a racist one.
Very useful definitions. Thanks for sharing. Introducing some nuance to the conversation can be quite helpful.
What is your definition of racism? Quote
01-02-2023 , 06:49 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by chillrob
What would you think if a black nationalist group somehow took control of the US government and instituted "Affirmative Action" hiring processes which favored blacks over whites: still not racist?
There is too many elements that are imply which isn’t just related to racism .
That is just populism , taking a complex problem trying to simplifying it to a simple conclusion and thinking simple solution exist .
What is your definition of racism? Quote
01-02-2023 , 10:06 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by washoe
add ASU to the list and sign this petition if you can.

titled
Fire Racist Penn Law Professor, Amy Wax

she would get fired from 2+2 why not here?

https://www.change.org/p/university-...fessor-amy-wax
Amy Wax has been an embarrassment for years. She seems to be on a crusade to test the boundaries of the academic tenure system.
What is your definition of racism? Quote
01-02-2023 , 10:20 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by browser2920
The website per se is ok. But we don't allow links to articles filled with racist propaganda ,even if the author then says its bad. It's just like not putting it in here. We don't allow anything that facilitates connections to racist material. Anyone interested in digging deeper can easily google the topic and a lot of articles come up about Amy Wax and the Jared Taylor visit.

So a post informing us about Jared Taylors visit to Penn Law and questioning the appropriateness of it is fine. And saying he is a well known white supremacist speaker is fine. We just don't want a listing of his racist views on here.
I understand the point, and it's fine when we are discussing Amy Wax and Jared Taylor. But sadly, we live in a world in which the occasional U.S. politician says crazy stuff about race. Steve King is an obvious example. How exactly would we discuss such issues if we can't even link to articles in the MSM that mention the comments?
What is your definition of racism? Quote
01-02-2023 , 11:25 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Montrealcorp
There is too many elements that are imply which isn’t just related to racism .
That is just populism , taking a complex problem trying to simplifying it to a simple conclusion and thinking simple solution exist .
I don't think you know what "populism" means.
What is your definition of racism? Quote
01-02-2023 , 11:30 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Rococo
Amy Wax has been an embarrassment for years. She seems to be on a crusade to test the boundaries of the academic tenure system.
This is a an excellent example of why tenure (when conflated with sinecure) is stupid.

If you can't summarily fire someone who is inviting White Supremacists into the classroom, then the system itself is obviously broken.
What is your definition of racism? Quote
01-02-2023 , 11:32 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Rococo
Amy Wax has been an embarrassment for years. She seems to be on a crusade to test the boundaries of the academic tenure system.

I hear you. she has got at least 2 problems now:

cancer and disciplinary proceedings against her.
so yea, shes got problems.

the students and staff recorded everything she said and the
new law dean doesnt like her and asks for major sanctions/ termination of her. I woulndt like her either.
never had a prof like her luckily, sorry for the students.

Amy Wax submits memorandum for dismissal of disciplinary ...

http://www.thedp.com › 2022/09

19.09.2022 — The 59-page memorandum claims that Wax is undergoing treatment for “life-threatening” cancer, meriting the postponement of the proceedings ...

Embattled Penn Law Prof Amy Wax, Citing Cancer Treatment ...

https://www.law.com › 2022/09/20

20.09.2022 — Amy Wax has requested that the University of Pennsylvania Carey Law School postpone disciplinary proceedings against her while she is ...

Penn Law dean asks for 'major sanction' against professor ...

https://www.thefire.org › news › p...

13.07.2022 — Penn Law dean asks for 'major sanction' against professor Amy Wax, creating tenure threat for all Penn faculty.



Last edited by washoe; 01-02-2023 at 11:51 AM.
What is your definition of racism? Quote
01-02-2023 , 11:56 AM
weird that her cancer treatment overlaps with the hearings.

she was already banned from teaching a course here it says.

"Penn Law Dean Ted Ruger banned Wax from teaching a mandatory first-year course."

https://www.thedp.com/article/2018/0...s-philadelphia


Last edited by washoe; 01-02-2023 at 12:04 PM.
What is your definition of racism? Quote
01-02-2023 , 12:06 PM
that only leaves the question why harvard is/was letting jared taylor
teach japanese in summer school. I mean harvard? cmon!

Jared Taylor - Wikipediahttps://en.wikipedia.org › wiki › Ja...

"Samuel Jared Taylor (born September 15, 1951) is an American white supremacist and editor of ... He has also taught Japanese at the Harvard Summer School, and worked as a..."

that wiki isnt even correct. he didnt teach japanese, he tought english to japanese students imo. he is fluent in japanese bc he was born in japan and lived there until the age of 16 as the son of missionaries.

JARED TAYLOR Samuel Jared Taylor (born 1951 in Oakton ...

https://vk.com

"Taylor taught Japanese students at Harvard University Summer School. Taylor believes that white people have their own racial interests, and that it is ..."

maybe the wiki is even correct though, the fact that he tought there is the issue, not what.

Last edited by washoe; 01-02-2023 at 12:29 PM.
What is your definition of racism? Quote

      
m