Quote:
Originally Posted by Max Cut
Cite the racism stat please. (One of the things that used to be enforced by the worst mod ever was that you had to support claims like that or retract them. ****ing crazy, I know.)
I don't think there is a single, definitive measure that could be used to decide the factual claim here. Particularly because of different possible ways of defining racism, i.e. measures of individual prejudice would be quite different from measures of institutional/structural issues.
For the latter, I'm not aware of any holistic attempts to measure trends, and I'm not sure how it would work. But for individual attitudes, there are several large surveys that provide some evidence. The most widely used is the
General Social Survey. Even there, though, the survey has asked a number of different questions in different ways over the years, so it's not trivial to boil it all down into one measure.
So, caveats in mind, my impression of data that I've looked at from GSS is that there isn't a
very clear trend over 20 years for some of the questions they ask, though
there are definitely trends over 50 years. But, for at least some questions, in the last decade, there appears to be a trend towards wider acceptance of anti-racist views. As an example, consider
this question:
Quote:
On the average African-Americans have worse jobs, income, and housing than white people. Do you think these differences are because most African-Americans just don't have the motivation or will power to pull themselves up out of poverty?
(data tables at the link above. I calculated the percent as [number answering yes]/[number who gave an answer], i.e. I excluded "no answer" and "not applicable". The latter is, I believe, people who took a version of the survey which did not include the question
The percentage is still pretty shockingly high, in my view, but the trend looks real. It should also be noted that it appears to be
largely driven by changes in Democrats' attitudes:
See also
this report which documents other similar trends in GSS:
Quote:
Attitudes toward race relations are liberalizing, with increasing support for government assistance to black Americans. A collaborative analysis by The Associated Press-NORC Center for Public Affairs Research and the General Social Survey (GSS) staff using the 2018 General Social Survey shows that more Americans than ever (52 percent) say the government spends too little on improving the conditions of blacks and that more say the government should try to make up for past discrimination (28 percent). These increases occurred across ages and racial groups and among Democrats, independents, and Republicans.
Americans overall are also now more likely to attribute inequalities between blacks and whites to discrimination (up from 33 percent in 2014 to 45 percent in 2018) and lack of access to education (up from 42 percent in 2014 to 50 percent in 2018) and are less likely to attribute them to a lack of motivation or will among blacks (down from 45 in 2014 percent to 36 percent in 2018). White Democrats show some of the largest shifts in attitudes.