Quote:
Originally Posted by MrJuliusDhelas
Its very hard to have a precise calculation about this i can give u 1 example of some1 who bought a video pack for spins (not yours act.) after 1000 games
he is BE chi+ev (i know this doesnt mean anything as there are hundreds of people with diff experiences but im talking about his case)
Then he got coaching , spent the same and now wins consistently 7%ev
Imagine u buy a pack and get 4% roi , but if u bought the coaching u would get 8%
What is more expensive ? Buy a pack play 10k games with 4% and then buy coaching to have 8% or just pay the coaching
Prices for coaching are not always expensive i see people with the same level charging completely different hour rates.
I know im oversimplifying and this can be complex , but i dont feel the best approach is ALWAYS buy a video pack first and i have already experience that shows actually in some cases its the most "expensive" option
Your example is valid, but there's the converse examples that happen way more often of guys that spend thousands on coaching and don't get better and are out thousands of dollars now, even being coached by great players.
I agree it's not always best, but I think when it's not best to buy a vid pack first (or study with others or join a staking program or study alone with free materials) is usually when you have a lot more income than the average beginner has to spend on getting good. You should also be very motivated and professional about poker playing.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nefirmative
At this point in poker, at least in the case of spins and anything at high stakes people can't charge an amount that people would be willing to pay for actually great information in a video pack. A truly comprehensive video pack on how to crush spins by someone actually crushing 60s-100s spins would be worth 10s of thousands of dollars and almost no-one would pay even 5k.
Quote:
Originally Posted by acbarone
This
I disagree, I feel that every other game out there has basically proven this point untrue.
In MTTs, Cash, HUSNGs (Think Mersenneary, Croixdawg, etc.) there have been high level guys literally explaining what they do, why, how they study and so on and the material hasn't been worth near 5-50k per person, even if it helped many get better.
And they still felt it was well worth giving away their valuable strategies (they kept crushing, and games got more profitable in the years after they stopped playing poker).
I think it's finally obvious that one person's quality information isn't impacting things to any noticeable level. I think the evidence is in dozens of staking programs and HS players working both in open and closed groups, coaching dozens of hours a week each. Sure things are being impacted by that, but it's taken such a large machine to noticeably impact things... one guy deciding to private coach or do videos or even stake isn't going to matter.
Quote:
Originally Posted by blobbloblob
Video Packs are only good for beginners while coaching is best for Experienced Experts/Veterans at a game.
As a beginner there is no reason to pay someone 100/hr for the same "beginner" information that you would get out of a video pack.
This is generally my experience, particularly given how many players will quit or move on from a game and never advance beyond beginner, and for reasons that have more to do with motivation or personal issues or lack of motivation which most hourly coaches aren't going to have anything to do with improving.
It's not that coaching can't do it, it actually does it better when done well, it's just the risk reward for the higher cost of quality coaching is usually too great for beginners to make it the right play.
One exception I can think of has been Cog over the years. But his 4 hour course for HUSNGs, which was great for beginning players, was more like a live video pack than most people's personal coaching. More tailored to the individual than a vid pack, but mostly the same fundamental winning strategy that helped many newer players for a price they could justify risking to get that content to help them improve.