Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
questions for theists about homosexuality/bisexuality among animals questions for theists about homosexuality/bisexuality among animals

08-29-2010 , 11:57 AM
A post I just made in SMP gave me the idea for this thread.

I have a few questions about this subject.


First of all, it appears that animals go to heaven also.

Quote:
This plan, which God will complete when the time is right, is to bring all creation together, everything in heaven and on earth, with Christ as head.
- Ephesians 1:10


Quote:
Wolves and sheep will live together in peace, and leopards will lie down with young goats, calves and lion cubs will feed together, and little children will take care of them. Cows and bears will eat together, and their calves and cubs will lie down in peace. Lions will eat straw as cattle do . . . The land will be as full of knowledge of the Lord as the seas are full of water.
- Isaiah 11:6-9


Quote:
Search in the Lord's book of living creatures and read what it says. Not one of these creatures will be missing and not one will be without its mate. The Lord has commanded it to be so; He Himself will bring them together. It is the Lord who will divide the land among them and give each of them a share. They will live in the land age after age, and it will belong to them for ever.
- Isaiah 34:16, 17

source
http://www.thebibleandanimals.org/Ar...andanimals.htm


And also, for formality, it's made very clear that homosexuality is not tolerated in the bible.

Old testament:

Quote:
Thou shalt not lie with mankind, as with womankind: it is an abomination
- Leviticus 18:22


Quote:
If a man also lie with mankind, as he lieth with a woman, both of them have committed an abomination: they shall surely be put to death; their blood shall be upon them
- Leviticus 20:13


New testament:

Quote:
Because of this, God gave them over to shameful lusts. Even their women exchanged natural relations for unnatural ones.
- Romans 1:26


Quote:
In the same way the men also abandoned natural relations with women and were inflamed with lust for one another. Men committed indecent acts with other men, and received in themselves the due penalty for their perversion.
- Romans 1:27

source
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Bib..._homosexuality


In these new testament verses it is made clear that homosexuality is unnatural. Unnatural obviously meaning against nature.



Many species of animals outside of humans have been observed engaging in homosexual behavior.

A few examples.


Bonobo:
Quote:
The Bonobo, which has a matriarchal society, unusual amongst apes, is a fully bisexual species—both males and females engage in heterosexual and homosexual behavior, being noted for female-female homosexuality in particular.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homosex...and_other_apes


Bottlenose dolphins:
Quote:
Bottlenose dolphin males have been observed working in pairs or larger groups to follow and/or restrict the movement of a female for weeks at a time, waiting for her to become sexually receptive. The same pairs/groups have also been observed engaging in ardent sexual play with each other.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homosex...enose_dolphins


Elephants:
Quote:
African and Asiatic males will engage in same-sex bonding and mounting. Such encounters are often associated with affectionate interactions, such as kissing, trunk intertwining, and placing trunks in each other's mouths. Male elephants, who often live apart from the general flock, often form "companionships", consisting of an older individual and one or sometimes two younger, attendant males with sexual behavior being an important part of the social dynamic. Unlike heterosexual relations, which are always of a fleeting nature, the relationships between males may last for years. The encounters are analogous to heterosexual bouts, one male often extending his trunk along the other's back and pushing forward with his tusks to signify his intention to mount. Same-sex relations are common and frequent in both sexes, with Asiatic elephants in captivity devoting roughly 45% of sexual encounters to same-sex activity
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homosex...mals#Elephants



My first question is, the bible makes it clear that homosexuality is both sin and unnatural, but homosexuality is found all over nature. What caused this discrepancy?

Many theists believe homosexuality is a choice, is it a choice that humans alone make, or do animals also choose it?

Do animals that engage in homosexual behavior go to hell? Do they accept jesus as their lord and savior and find forgiveness resulting in acceptance into heaven? Or do they get a free pass and only humans are punished for their (natural) homosexual behavior?

My final question on this subject I suppose is, do you indeed believe that homosexuality is an unnatural sin, and if not, why do you dissent from the bible on this?

Last edited by LirvA; 08-29-2010 at 12:10 PM. Reason: thread title should more accuartely be questions for christians imo
questions for theists about homosexuality/bisexuality among animals Quote
08-29-2010 , 12:21 PM
Those 3 verses don't prove that animals will go to heaven. Or do you think it really is meant with "all creation" also trees, water, air, plants, bacteria's , diseases etc.? No, animals do not have souls, thus when they die, they are dead, and that's it... (at least that's what I've understood from the NT and Church etc.)

KJV on Ephesians 1:10
" 10That in the dispensation of the fulness of times he might gather together in one all things in Christ, both which are in heaven, and which are on earth; even in him: "

Which looks to me as kinda different. It is the purpose of God to put all things together under Christ.

Isaiah 11:6-9, again, not proof that animals go to heaven too.
Isaiah 34:16, 17, also not.

If you believe it does, OK, let's keep it at that.

---
When the Bible refers to nature, it is different than the nature you think of. Nature does not mean, "what you see in reality". No it means, against the purpose that God meant.

Quote:
My first question is, the bible makes it clear that homosexuality is both sin and unnatural, but homosexuality is found all over nature. What caused this discrepancy?
I think this can be explained by the fall of man, all of the earth was corrupted.
Yes you can see homosexuality in the animal kingdom. Likewise, you can see murder in the animal kingdom. Likewise you can see all sorts of things which are natural, but immoral, according to the Christian standards.

Quote:
Many theists believe homosexuality is a choice, is it a choice that humans alone make, or do animals also choose it?
I don't know if animals can rationally choose what they do like human beings. I don't think so though.

Quote:
My final question on this subject I suppose is, do you indeed believe that homosexuality is an unnatural sin, and if not, why do you dissent from the bible on this?
Yes I believe the act of homosexuality is sinful. Depending on the definition of nature, according to the 'scientific' or the Christian one, it can be natural or unnatural.
questions for theists about homosexuality/bisexuality among animals Quote
08-29-2010 , 12:34 PM
questions for theists about homosexuality/bisexuality among animals Quote
08-29-2010 , 12:49 PM
^
lol very very funny
questions for theists about homosexuality/bisexuality among animals Quote
08-29-2010 , 01:01 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Aigyptos
Those 3 verses don't prove that animals will go to heaven. Or do you think it really is meant with "all creation" also trees, water, air, plants, bacteria's , diseases etc.? No, animals do not have souls, thus when they die, they are dead, and that's it... (at least that's what I've understood from the NT and Church etc.)

KJV on Ephesians 1:10
" 10That in the dispensation of the fulness of times he might gather together in one all things in Christ, both which are in heaven, and which are on earth; even in him: "

Which looks to me as kinda different. It is the purpose of God to put all things together under Christ.

Isaiah 11:6-9, again, not proof that animals go to heaven too.
Isaiah 34:16, 17, also not.

If you believe it does, OK, let's keep it at that.

Well, I read the verse you posted, and I reread the verses I posted, and I have no idea how anyone could come to the conclusion that according to the versus, animals do NOT go to heaven.

I even read the wikipedia page on dispensation of the fulness of times and it doesn't mention animals not going to heaven or anything regarding animals.

As an observer, yes. I believe these verses are saying that animals go to heaven.

Where in the bible does it differentiate between man and animals and man has a soul but animals do not?


Quote:
Originally Posted by Aigyptos
I think this can be explained by the fall of man, all of the earth was corrupted.
Yes you can see homosexuality in the animal kingdom. Likewise, you can see murder in the animal kingdom. Likewise you can see all sorts of things which are natural, but immoral, according to the Christian standards.

wait, natural as in the purpose of god or natural as in nature?



Quote:
Originally Posted by Aigyptos
I don't know if animals can rationally choose what they do like human beings. I don't think so though.
Do you believe humans choose to be gay? If so, why do humans choose it but animals do not?
questions for theists about homosexuality/bisexuality among animals Quote
08-29-2010 , 01:05 PM
i believe its natures way of culling the herd, its like a charles darwin sceince proven.
questions for theists about homosexuality/bisexuality among animals Quote
08-29-2010 , 01:17 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by goldenchild123
i believe its natures way of culling the herd, its like a charles darwin sceince proven.
That doesn't work because personal and societal bigotry makes gays feel guilty for being gay and they sometimes end up in marriages and have kids.
questions for theists about homosexuality/bisexuality among animals Quote
08-29-2010 , 01:20 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by batair
That doesn't work because personal and societal bigotry makes gays feel guilty for being gay and they sometimes end up in marriages and have kids.
Or option nr1

(you know what i'm talking about)
questions for theists about homosexuality/bisexuality among animals Quote
08-29-2010 , 01:59 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by goldenchild123
i believe its natures way of culling the herd, its like a charles darwin sceince proven.
So natural has a goal now?
questions for theists about homosexuality/bisexuality among animals Quote
08-29-2010 , 02:00 PM
The animal world is ripe with murder, cannibalism, rape, and a host of other things that we feel are morally detestable. Should we change our views on those as well?

Who said that nature was perfect? Not the bible. Your argument is baseless.
questions for theists about homosexuality/bisexuality among animals Quote
08-29-2010 , 02:04 PM
Wait, so the bible says that homosexuality is unnatural, yet we actually see it occur naturally, and this does not in any way inform us that the bible is inaccurate on the topic?
questions for theists about homosexuality/bisexuality among animals Quote
08-29-2010 , 02:06 PM
Thats the second time i have heard animals murder itt. But doesn't murder take freewill and or the conscious decision to kill or not to kill.

Are you guys saying they are not robots?
questions for theists about homosexuality/bisexuality among animals Quote
08-29-2010 , 06:12 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Aigyptos
If you believe it does, OK, let's keep it at that.
I really hope this means you agree that everyones religious beliefs are opinion and not fact, including yours
questions for theists about homosexuality/bisexuality among animals Quote
08-29-2010 , 06:31 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Aigyptos
Those 3 verses don't prove that animals will go to heaven. Or do you think it really is meant with "all creation" also trees, water, air, plants, bacteria's , diseases etc.? No, animals do not have souls, thus when they die, they are dead, and that's it... (at least that's what I've understood from the NT and Church etc.)

KJV on Ephesians 1:10
" 10That in the dispensation of the fulness of times he might gather together in one all things in Christ, both which are in heaven, and which are on earth; even in him: "

Which looks to me as kinda different. It is the purpose of God to put all things together under Christ.

Isaiah 11:6-9, again, not proof that animals go to heaven too.
Isaiah 34:16, 17, also not.

If you believe it does, OK, let's keep it at that.

---
When the Bible refers to nature, it is different than the nature you think of. Nature does not mean, "what you see in reality". No it means, against the purpose that God meant.



I think this can be explained by the fall of man, all of the earth was corrupted.
Yes you can see homosexuality in the animal kingdom. Likewise, you can see murder in the animal kingdom. Likewise you can see all sorts of things which are natural, but immoral, according to the Christian standards.



I don't know if animals can rationally choose what they do like human beings. I don't think so though.



Yes I believe the act of homosexuality is sinful. Depending on the definition of nature, according to the 'scientific' or the Christian one, it can be natural or unnatural.
do you believe that neandertals were human and had souls? if not when did the change soul/no sould occur in our evolutionary past?
if you dont believe in evo. you dont have to answer - yet.
we can wait till we are actually able to recreate neandertals from DNA.
questions for theists about homosexuality/bisexuality among animals Quote
08-29-2010 , 06:48 PM
OP Quote:
This plan, which God will complete when the time is right, is to bring all creation together, everything in heaven and on earth, with Christ as head.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Why is this heaven? Haven't you ever heard of the Millenial Kingdom?

Animals have souls. It says it in many passages of the bible. But a soul and a spirit aren't the same thing.

Gen 1:20 And God said, Let the waters swarm with swarms of living souls, and let fowl fly above the earth in the expanse of the heavens.

Gen 1:21 And God created the great sea monsters, and every living soul that moves with which the waters swarm, after their kind, and every winged fowl after its kind. And God saw that it was good.

Gen 1:24 And God said, Let the earth bring forth living souls after their kind, cattle, and creeping thing, and beast of the earth, after their kind. And it was so.

Gen 1:30 and to every animal of the earth, and to every fowl of the heavens, and to everything that creepeth on the earth, in which is a living soul, every green herb for food. And it was so.

Gen 2:19 And out of the ground Jehovah Elohim had formed every animal of the field and all fowl of the heavens, and brought {them} to Man, to see what he would call them; and whatever Man called each living soul, that was its name.

Gen 9:10 and with every living soul which is with you, fowl as well as cattle, and all the animals of the earth with you, of all that has gone out of the ark -- every animal of the earth.

Gen 9:12 And God said, This is the sign of the covenant that I set between me and you and every living soul that is with you, for everlasting generations:

Gen 9:15 and I will remember my covenant which is between me and you and every living soul of all flesh; and the waters shall not henceforth become a flood to destroy all flesh. 16 And the bow shall be in the cloud; and I will look upon it, that I may remember the everlasting covenant between God and every living soul of all flesh that is upon the earth.

Lev 11:10 but all that have not fins and scales in seas and in rivers, of all that swarm in the waters, and of every living soul which is in the waters -- they shall be an abomination unto you.

Rev 8:9 and the third part of the creatures which were in the sea which had life [soul] died; and the third part of the ships were destroyed.
questions for theists about homosexuality/bisexuality among animals Quote
08-30-2010 , 02:14 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jibninjas
The animal world is ripe with murder, cannibalism, rape, and a host of other things that we feel are morally detestable. Should we change our views on those as well?

Perhaps you should.

When you have a religious view that something is a sin according to god, and animals exhibit the same behaviors, then perhaps your view shouldn't be "zomg god says this stuff is sin and the work of the devil so I better not do it or not repent cause then I'll go to hell for all eternity."

But perhaps your view should be something like "this occurs in nature as well, so why should we blindly put faith in the bible and fear possible repercussions in the afterlife? Maybe the bible isn't really the word of god, but a giant bull**** work of fiction. Maybe my religion isn't great, but a scourge upon the progress of science and mankind."
questions for theists about homosexuality/bisexuality among animals Quote
08-30-2010 , 02:18 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Splendour
Animals have souls. It says it in many passages of the bible. But a soul and a spirit aren't the same thing.

ahh. This story is getting good!






Then what is the difference between a soul and a spirit?


And I have not heard of the Millenial Kingdom, but from everything I have heard about christianity, I'm obviously skeptical.
questions for theists about homosexuality/bisexuality among animals Quote
08-30-2010 , 02:45 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jibninjas
The bible is ripe with murder, cannibalism, rape, and a host of other things that we feel are morally detestable. Should we change our views on those as well?

Who said that nature was perfect? Not the bible. Your argument is baseless.
FYP.
questions for theists about homosexuality/bisexuality among animals Quote
08-30-2010 , 05:49 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Conspire
I really hope this means you agree that everyones religious beliefs are opinion and not fact, including yours
I can't convince a non-Christian anyway. What's the point in that. He will keep his opinion because he found a way Christian morality is not consistent. Do you think he will concede?
questions for theists about homosexuality/bisexuality among animals Quote
08-30-2010 , 08:27 AM
I once asked the question where does grass go when it dies and i got laughed at
questions for theists about homosexuality/bisexuality among animals Quote
08-30-2010 , 09:08 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by LirvA
Perhaps you should.

When you have a religious view that something is a sin according to god, and animals exhibit the same behaviors, then perhaps your view shouldn't be "zomg god says this stuff is sin and the work of the devil so I better not do it or not repent cause then I'll go to hell for all eternity."

But perhaps your view should be something like "this occurs in nature as well, so why should we blindly put faith in the bible and fear possible repercussions in the afterlife? Maybe the bible isn't really the word of god, but a giant bull**** work of fiction. Maybe my religion isn't great, but a scourge upon the progress of science and mankind."
Wait, are you suggesting that murder, cannibalism, and rape are ok, and we should just go with it? I must be reading something wrong here.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Thijs908
I once asked the question where does grass go when it dies and i got laughed at
There's a difference between plants and animals.
questions for theists about homosexuality/bisexuality among animals Quote
08-30-2010 , 09:15 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by LirvA
ahh. This story is getting good!






Then what is the difference between a soul and a spirit?


And I have not heard of the Millenial Kingdom, but from everything I have heard about christianity, I'm obviously skeptical.
You can google the Millenial Kingdom and get a million hits. But its the 1,000 year reign that commences after the 2nd Coming of Christ. Can I definitively prove animals don't go to heaven: no. But I don't think there is a verse that says they do. Afaik everyone goes into the dust until they are resurrected but then again we don't know how God bridges time once that occurs. If somebody finds a verse then please show it. Of course some people think and are writing books that animals go to heaven. I saw Sylvia Browne had one out (All Pets Go to Heaven is the title) but I don't trust Sylvia Browne so I didn't even look at it.

But the spirit is given by God:http://becomingone.org/nm/nm22.htm

I think hundreds of years of philosophizing the scriptures and that famous verse of Christ's has caused people to think spirit and soul are the same thing: "Do not be afraid of those who kill the body but cannot kill the soul. Rather, be afraid of the One who can destroy both soul and body in hell." (Matthew 10:28)
questions for theists about homosexuality/bisexuality among animals Quote
08-30-2010 , 09:37 AM
It's a non-issue because animals very rarely keep the sabbath holy.
questions for theists about homosexuality/bisexuality among animals Quote
08-30-2010 , 12:11 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by LirvA
My first question is, the bible makes it clear that homosexuality is both sin and unnatural, but homosexuality is found all over nature. What caused this discrepancy?
Animals steal from each other all the time too. Do you also think the commandment: "Thou shalt not steal" is a natural discrepancy too?
questions for theists about homosexuality/bisexuality among animals Quote
08-30-2010 , 12:15 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by LirvA
When you have a religious view that something is a sin according to god, and animals exhibit the same behaviors, then perhaps your view shouldn't be "zomg god says this stuff is sin and the work of the devil so I better not do it or not repent cause then I'll go to hell for all eternity."
If a severly ******ed person who has little to none in the way of reason or intellect kills someone else, we don't convict that person of a crime.

If bonobos had the same faculties as a human...homosexuality would be sinful for them as well.
questions for theists about homosexuality/bisexuality among animals Quote

      
m