Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Gary McCord sucks imo Gary McCord sucks imo

02-10-2009 , 04:13 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by POKEROMGLOL
My biggest annoyance with golf announcing is the overdramatizing. When Tiger hits a drive and they all jizz their pants "that must've gone 390!" then you notice his ball roll like 4 yards past Zach Johnson's.
This has never once happened. Ever.

Quote:
Or like "lucky to get it within X amount of feet here." I would say they get it within those X amount of feet like 80% of the time. These dudes are pretty damn good at golf.
They are almost always using Shotlink stats as a reference for a percentage. Maybe some ex-players just guess, but if that's the case they're usually pretty damn close to the right number.

Quote:
It also annoys me when they act like 8-10 footers are just gimmes. Sure, they look like it if all you do is follow the leaders around, but hitting it to 8 feet is NOT a guaranteed birdie for the 99% of the field which isn't contending on a Sunday back 9.
Haven't really noticed this myself, but I have nothing to refute what you're saying. I'll look out for this but my initial thought is you're wrong just based on memory.

Some 8 footers are straight in. Some 8 footers have a double-break. I think most announcers are usually aware of this and set the shot up accordingly.

Quote:
I get so tired of Tiger. It isn't Tiger himself's fault, but if I am watching the Bob Hope, Tiger shouldn't be referenced every 4 seconds. I swear, if tiger packed on like 60 pounds and got all fat (funny image), the announcers would ride his jock about how he has found the "optimal weight" or something.
This is like the myth that humans only use 10% of their brain. 4 seconds? Really? You could have said once every segment and still been exaggerating A TON.

Quote:
-I don't mind Tirico. He isn't all that knowledgeable, but I think he does a great job of just calling the action in a calm, normal manner.
Totally agree.

Quote:
-The funniest /worst announcer is Chris Berman doing the U.S. Open. "Here's Hairy Padddington Bear Padraig Harrington shooting for par back back back back back, oh no that ring around the rosey was not so rosey for what a drag harrington. he taps in for a par. over to tiger who is golfing from the sand pit over at 12."
Again, totally agree LOL.
Gary McCord sucks imo Quote
02-10-2009 , 08:57 AM
I really enjoyed Faldo this past Sunday at the Buick. I think he's hitting his stride. He says just enough and then gets out of the way, and has a great sense of humor. I'd like to hear more Baker-Finch, too.
Gary McCord sucks imo Quote
02-10-2009 , 11:42 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by POKEROMGLOL
A fun exchange the other day between him and Faldo:

G-Mac: "When I used to play greens like this, I used to hit down on the ball when I putted so I could get it on the green and rolling faster, what do you think about that Nick?"

Faldo: "How many tournaments did you win again?"
Except that McCord was able to respond with the fact that he'd won one on that very course.

That whole exchange was part of what brought me to post though. McCord was just ****ing loopy the whole time and couldn't stop making some wiseass comment.

I can't really fault him for the para-sailing guy. They're showing this dude as background and then it looks like he crashers, wtf are they supposed to do.
Gary McCord sucks imo Quote
02-10-2009 , 11:47 AM
nantz is the **** (edit: nantz is good). kostis is great, and i really love faldo because he's always speaking from experience (i know nantz played college golf and no idea about kostis) but there is something about a multi-major winner doing color that makes it more intriguing.
Gary McCord sucks imo Quote
02-10-2009 , 02:14 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by shemp
I'm varying levels of satisfied with all of them except for Tirico. It might be because I like ABC's broadcast the least and he is emcee-- it seems to me that in recent years less is live and so much is coming off of tape. More so than the other networks, many times I've felt they are playing a highlight and pretending to call it live-- annoys me.
Yeah they definitely do this, blatantly. You'll see a guy hit a shot, then they'll do some segment or other diversion, then fifteen minutes later he's hitting his next shot. Or, conversely, he's hitting a shot that is ostensibly "live" and then ten seconds later he's already hitting his next one. I have no idea why they do this, it's a screwed up flow. I guess they think the average viewer won't care, or they don't want to mention it's taped, or maybe they don't want you to have the slightest clue when the next meaningful shot is going to be hit so you don't change the channel. It's one of many reasons I didn't mind ABC backing out of every event except for the British.

Nantz does have a little street cred because of his golf background, but for the most part the host should just direct traffic. I don't want Dan Hicks busting out with some analysis any more than I want Kevin Harlan analyzing a complex basketball play to Doug Collins. Luckily they seem to know their limitations and/or are smart enough to defer to those around them.
Gary McCord sucks imo Quote
02-10-2009 , 05:58 PM
what was the thread title i posted again? something like... "anyone else?" i dunno. regardless, i like yours much better.

berman at US open was a joke, and i actually found it kind of funny. maybe it was cause we knew it would never happen again. when he said "cooch" refering to kutcher i lost it. i was kind of hoping he'd call him "cooch-daddy" at some point.

mccord is really the only commentator in golf that i genuinely dislike. i dont mind miller, although i dont particularaly like him either. lerner's bearable i guess.

i agree that faldo is really getting into a groove, and i really like that he'll be on for a while to come. nantz, maltbie, pepper, kostis and baker-finch are all great, obv. and oosterhuis is my fav.
Gary McCord sucks imo Quote
02-11-2009 , 02:57 AM
I've watched a ton of golf like you guys. I've always thought judy rankin was the best.
Gary McCord sucks imo Quote
02-11-2009 , 04:25 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dids
Except that McCord was able to respond with the fact that he'd won one on that very course.

That whole exchange was part of what brought me to post though. McCord was just ****ing loopy the whole time and couldn't stop making some wiseass comment.

I can't really fault him for the para-sailing guy. They're showing this dude as background and then it looks like he crashers, wtf are they supposed to do.
lol. I just thought it was funny because Nick Faldo is like 200x the golfer McCord ever was and he has been on really good nice british man behavior since he became an announcer, but he reverted to "heart of my bottom" Faldo for a second there.

As for the crashing parasailor, I thought McCord was kind of making light of it. I seriously thought the guy was dead and McCord was acting really flippant about it. I kind of got the feeling the others were like "uh oh" and were kind of letting McCord hang himself if in fact the guy was dead.
Gary McCord sucks imo Quote
02-11-2009 , 01:57 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by tuq
I don't want Dan Hicks busting out with some analysis any more than I want Kevin Harlan analyzing a complex basketball play to Doug Collins.

We used to be blessed with Kevin Harlan and Trent Tucker as the everygame announcers for the Timberwolves. Those were the days. Garnett was dubbed " Big Ticket " by Harlan and Tucker would often deliver many observant lines about how " The Timberwolves must continue to put put the ball into the basket." or " I feel ya young fella. " to which we would always add the line deep inside my arse.lol.

Sorry for the tangent.
Gary McCord sucks imo Quote
02-11-2009 , 05:54 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by tuq
Nantz does have a little street cred because of his golf background, but for the most part the host should just direct traffic.
Maybe it's his support staff combined with being on unfamiliar courses with more non-americans (with, perhaps, non-network feeds?). But I thought too many times Tirico gives you, "And here is uh, [pause... waiting for clue in his ear piece...] Oliver uh Wilson. He's playing, uh [pause...] uh, number 7." This doesn't happen on the other broadcasts.
Gary McCord sucks imo Quote

      
m