Quote:
Originally Posted by cha59
I watched that video you linked. I think I can see now why you think a DL might have aggravated the shoulder. If that did happen, I think you probably let your shoulder blades roll up and didnt use your lats to keep them down. That would put the joint in a bad position.
Quote:
Originally Posted by cha59
yeah, unracking the weight and letting your back come loose will really mess things up if you bench after that. If that ever happens in the future and you're aware that you unracked it bad before you do any reps, stop the set & rerack the weight.
Agreed. When I do 180/185lbs territory, the unrack feels not awkward. I assume I could tell if the unrack was "bad" vs. "fine".
However, at 200lbs+ the unrack feels awkward and heavy. I'm not sure I can tell the difference at that weight between "acceptable" and "bad" unracking tbh. This probably means I need liftoff for any weight > 90% of my 1rm.
I could tell on the 3rd set unracking didn't go well, I shouldn't have done the first rep, let alone tried the second. But the 2nd set (which I now assume was a bad unrack) I couldn't tell.
Quote:
Originally Posted by ExpectedV
I actually didn't look at the videos until now for some reason. How much do you weigh now? and what point is there in waiting until you can pull 405 in order to switch to sumo?
I weighed 184.2lbs this morning but my 7day weight average is at 185.5. So, 185-186 most likely.
The point of waiting until I can pull 405? I dno, arbitrary. Cha has said repeatedly he thinks I should do conventional or at the very least wait until I feel I've gotten very good at conventional before then maybe working in sumo. And not ever stopping conventional.
But, tbh I'm not sure the reasons behind it. I think he just greatly prefers conventional, probably has some bias against sumo being an "inferior" lift of some sort. However, I obviously value his opinion enough to continue conventional. Also, he can coach me on conventional but I assume if I do sumo, I'm completely on my own. I do have a worry that I cannot figure it out by myself. It sucks, but I simply do not have confidence given my lifting history at getting good at lifts by myself. It's pretty sad given the amount of effort, study, and focus I've put forth. I'm used to being good to extremely good at things I put my mind to. Because lifting doesn't come super easy to me, I think I feel worse at it than I probably even am. Every part of lifting seems like an uphill struggle for me to some degree. No part of it seems effortless or that I'm good at, except general compliance, and I do seem to enjoy it/studying it. And the H&F community,
.
Quote:
Originally Posted by cha59
The more I know about sumo, the less I think Yugo should ever do it. Yugo, you dont have anywhere near the hip strength to be successful at sumo for a long time. Watch this vid: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ioo4LKjwQfg
I think I've seen that video ~3 times so it must get linked frequently
.
Quote:
With the problems you have keeping your knees out squatting, you will be asking for knee issues if you do sumos imo.
I guess I don't really agree that from what is said sumo is necessarily bad for me. Tbh it seems weird you seem so convinced it would be bad for me without me actually trying it. The ratio of my limbs is set in stone. I've seen multiple resources suggest I'm built for sumo. Not borderline but clearly.
Now, is my potential lack of hip strength and knee cave something that might mean sumo is not for me? Maybe? But if sumo is a better mechanical situation for my body then it seems likely doing it a bunch would potentially solve such weak points or issues. The simple fact that it's likely a more favorable mechanical situation suggests to me it would be better and cause less stress on my long-term.
Quote:
Also, conventional DLs have better carry-over to everyday use and general strength and fitness than sumos do.
You say that but I'm not sure why or how it's true or even that it is. Even if whatever you mean by that statement is true across everyone as a whole, I'm not everyone, I am built differently. Additionally, it seems there is at least one clear benefit to sumo:
- Less stress on lower back. This is inherent in the lift to begin with but is even moreso for me given that even in an optimal conventional setup, my back is barely at any angle at all. Given what you know about how bad low back issues are, I'd imagine you would see long-term value in this.
Quote:
Sumos are good for a specific thing - moving more weight if you are better at them than conventional DLs. You arent planning to powerlift anyways, so I dont see any reason for you to do them.
I don't agree with that statement and I don't think you would believe it if you gave more thought to the difference between sumo and conventional.
Think about why some people can move more weight at it than conventional. I think there is a misconception that they are "cheating" the movement somehow to get more weight out of it. But if it were that, everyone would sumo more weight. Which obviously isn't true. In fact, don't most of the heaviest DLers not sumo? Those individuals are obviously built well for DLing in general to some degree. Plus they then have found a specific technique/setup along the conventional lines to get the most out of it. Guys pulling sumo probably do it b/c they aren't built as well for DLing to begin with and that's why sumo allows them to get more out of the lift.
Quote:
Originally Posted by BPA234
My wingspan is ~1 inch shorter than my height, iirc, but I haven't made the specific calculations in that article. I did compare my torso to arm and torso to lower body via this method over a year ago:
http://forum.bodybuilding.com/showth...#post181075901
My torso to arm ratio is .94 (under .82 -> conventional, over .82 -> sumo)
My torso to lower body ratio is .64 (under .55 -> conventional, over .55 -> sumo)
While my arms are noticeably short, I do think they would likely come in at under 38% of my height. My torso for sure would come in at over 47% of my height I'd guess. It looks noticeably long (not weirdly, but you can tell), putting me in the short arms and long torso, sumo camp.
Last edited by The Yugoslavian; 06-07-2014 at 02:20 PM.